REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES
COURT OF TAX APPEALS
Quezon City
Second Division
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff,
-versus-
RIZALDY GOLORAN CHUA,
(Purok Gumamela, Sta. Cruz, Rosario,
Agusan Del Sur)
Accused.
CTA CRIM CASE NOS. 0-792
& 0-793
For: Violation of Section 255 of the
NIRC of 1997, as amended
Members:
RINGPIS-LIBAN, Chairperson
MODESTO-SAN PEDRO, and
FERRER-FLORES, JJ.
Promulgated:
FEB 1 9 2025
x————–~————————————————————————~———–x
¥ JH~a.L
RESOLUTION
RINGPIS-LIBAN,J:
For resolution is plaintiffs “Motion for Reconsideration (of the Decision
dated October 29, 2024)” 1 filed via registered mail on November 27, 2024, with
accused’s “Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Reconsideration” flied on January
15, 2025.
On November 30, 2023, a Decision2 was promulgated acquitting the accused,
Rizaldy Goloran Chua, of the offenses charged against him. In the interest of justice
however, the Court deemed it proper to reopen the case for reception of accused’s
evidence on the civil aspect of the case. Thus, hearings3 were set to give opportunity
for both the accused and plaintiff to present their evidence. r/
2
3
Docket, pp. 1660-1682.
Id., pp. 1287-1327.
Id., Notice of Hearing dated March 12, 2024 and Notice of Hearing dated July 18, 2024 pp. 1436
and 1587.

RESOLUTION
CTA CRIM CASE· NOS. 0-792 & 0-793
Page 2 of 5
On October 29, 2024, the Decision on the Civil Aspect4 was promulgated
exonerating the accused, Rizaldy Goloran Chua, from the civil liability for the unpaid
taxes in relation to the offenses charged against him.
The dispositive portion of the Decision on the Civil Aspect reads:
“WHEREFORE, premises considered, accused RIZALDY
GOLORAN CHUA is exonerated from the civil liability for the
unpaid taxes in relation to the offenses charged against him in Criminal
Case Nos. 0-792 and 0-793.
SO ORDERED.”
In the “Motion for Reconsideration (of the Decision dated October 29,
2024)”, plaintiff prays for the following:
1)
For the Court to set aside the Decision dated November 30,
2023 acquitting the accused, on the ground that the elements of
the crime, as punished under Sections 255 of the National
_Internal Revenue Code (“NIRC”) of 1997, as amended, has not
been proven beyond reasonable doubt; and
2)
For the Court to set aside the Decision dated October 29, 2024
absolving the accused of any civil liability.
According to plaintiff, the Court erred in holding that a three (3) year
assessment from the filing of the income tax return to assess the accused is required
prior to the finding of civil liability for deficiency taxes. While Section 203 of the
NIRC of 1997, as amended, require as a rule that collection of taxes by a proceeding
in court cannot be done without an assessment, Section 222 of the Code provides
the exception that in case of a false or fraudulent return with intent to evade tax, a
proceeding in court for the collection of such tax may be flied without an assessment.
Additionally, plaintiff avers that it was able to discharge the burden of proving
fraud or falsity. Particularly, its witness Roberto P. Rara, Jr., testified that during his
investigation, he found that accused failed to supply correct and accurate information
for his annual income tax return. He also testified that the accused’s underdeclaration
of more than thirty percent (30%) showed that the failure to supply correct and
accurate information was willful, voluntary, intentional and with specific intent to
make a false ·return. Plaintiff maintains that this is a form of a tax fraud which is
similar if not in the same nature as false or fraudulent return that should have
triggered the application of Section 222 of the NIRC of 1997, as amende~
4
Id, pp. 1648-1658.

RESOLUTION
.
CTA CRIM CASE NOS. 0-792 & 0-793
Page 3 of 5
Plaintiff also submits that even if accused is acquitted for their criminal liability
due to the failure of the plaintiff to prove beyond doubt the elements of the crimes
as charged, a finding of civil liability may still be imposed by this Court.
On December 13, 2024, a Minute Resolution was issued ordering accused to
comment on plaintiffs “Motion for Reconsideration (of the Decision dated October
29, 2024)” within five (5) days from notice; after which, the said motion shall be
deemed submitted for resolution.
On December 23, 2024, the accused filed his “Opposition to Plaintiffs
Motion for Reconsideration” via registered mail, asserting that the arguments in
plaintiffs motion are mere rehash of the arguments already raised and thoroughly
ruled upon in the Decision on the Civil Aspect dated October 29, 2024.
Accused contends that plaintiffs motion for reconsideration merely revolves
around its blind assertion that there was fraud and therefore the ten (1 0) year
assessment period should apply instead of the three (3) year assessment period
limitation. Howeve


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *