{“title”:”False Time Records Can Cost a Government Employee One Month’s Salary”,”article_content”:”

Government employees who make false entries in their daily time records may be administratively punished even when the false entry concerns only a single afternoon and even when it is their first infraction. The practical lesson is direct: attendance records are not casual office paperwork. They are official accountability documents, and a false entry can trigger a salary fine, a formal finding of guilt, and a warning that any repetition will be treated more severely.

\n

The Doctrine: Daily Time Records Are Official Accountability Records

\n

The ruling establishes what may be called the official time record accountability doctrine. A government employee who records that he was in the office during a period when he was actually elsewhere commits a punishable administrative offense. The misconduct does not disappear merely because the employee claims that a superior allowed him to leave, especially where the supposed permission is not clearly proven or where the absence exceeds the kind of short break ordinarily permitted in the workplace.

\n

For public offices, courts, government agencies, and regulated workplaces, the case is a reminder that timekeeping is not a minor clerical ritual. Daily time records support payroll, discipline, supervision, and public trust. In a government setting, an inaccurate entry can amount to falsification of an official record, even if the employee’s rank is modest and even if no larger scheme is shown.

\n

Background: A Janitor Recorded Full Afternoon Attendance While He Was Elsewhere

\n

The administrative case involved Florentino Bagaso as complainant and Edilberto Suarez, a janitor in the Court of First Instance of Cebu, Cebu City, as respondent. The matter was decided by resolution dated December 28, 1973 (A.M. No. P-127).

\n

Suarez admitted that in his daily time record for March 28, 1969, he entered that he was in the office from 1:00 p.m. to 5:10 p.m. In fact, from 1:00 p.m. to past 4:00 p.m. that same day, he was at the office of Atty. Garcillano at V. Rama Avenue. The record therefore stated that he was working in the court office during hours when he was physically away from it.

\n

Suarez attempted to explain the discrepancy by saying that his superior, Mrs. Mercedes Orson, had given him permission to leave the office that afternoon. The Supreme Court did not fully accept that explanation. Mrs. Orson testified that she did not remember whether Suarez had asked permission to leave on that date. She also explained that she usually gave verbal permission to subordinates for short coffee or merienda breaks, but only for brief periods. In the Court’s words as summarized by the ruling, half an hour was already too long, and Mrs. Orson had reprimanded personnel for leaving the office for more than one hour.

\n

The Ruling: Guilty of Falsification, But Mitigated by First Offense and Long Service

\n

The Supreme Court found Suarez guilty of falsification of his daily time record. The key fact was not complicated: he claimed_


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *