The CTA dismissed the criminal tax case against Lilibeth Ramos Aragon, ruling that failure to properly serve a valid FAN/FLD negates willful failure to pay VAT liability.
Taxpayers who receive deficiency assessments must be aware that a valid Final Assessment Notice (FAN) and Formal Letter of Demand (FLD) are indispensable before any criminal liability for willful failure to pay can arise. Business owners and professionals must ensure proper receipt and clarity of tax notices, as failure to meet these requirements can result in dismissal of criminal tax charges.
Background
In 2025, the Court of Tax Appeals 1st Division reviewed the criminal case against Lilibeth Ramos Aragon, owner of On-Line Janitorial Services, who was accused of willfully failing to pay a deficiency Value-Added Tax (VAT) for the taxable year 2014 (CTA Crim. Case No. O-904)
CTA 1st Division Resolution PEOโฆ
. The prosecution claimed she did not pay Php 1,704,177.30 despite receipt of preliminary and final assessment notices, including formal letters of demand.
The accused was initially subject to a warrant of arrest with bail set at Php 60,000.00, but remained at large. During periodic review, the Court noted that the prosecution failed to provide proof that the FAN/FLD was actually received by the accused.
CTA Ruling
The Court dismissed the case, emphasizing that criminal liability for willful failure to pay taxes arises only after the taxpayer has received a valid FAN/FLD with a specific demand for payment within a prescribed period. Previous jurisprudence cited by the Court, including Lim v. Court of Appeals, Tupaz v. Ulep, and Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Fitness by Design, reinforced that actual receipt of the notice is required and the notice must clearly indicate a due date for payment
CTA 1st Division Resolution PEOโฆ
.
The disputed FAN/FLD in Aragon’s case lacked a definite amount and did not indicate a due date for payment. Without these elements, the Court held that the notice was void, rendering any criminal charge baseless. Consequently, the Alias Warrant of Arrest against the accused was recalled and set aside.
Key Legal Principles
1. A final assessment notice must state a definite amount of tax due and demand payment within a specified period.
2. Actual receipt of the FAN/FLD by the taxpayer is essential before criminal liability for willful failure to pay can attach.
3. Assessments that fail to comply with due process requirements, including the absence of a due date, are void and bear no effect.
4. Failure by the BIR to provide verifiable proof of receipt (such as registry return receipts) can invalidate the enforcement of the assessment in criminal cases.
Practical Takeaways
Businesses and tax practitioners must ensure that all deficiency VAT assessments are served properly and received by the taxpayer. Registered mail should be accompanied by verifiable proof of receipt. Assessments must specify a definite amount and a due date for payment, consistent with Sections 105, 106, and 249(C) of the NIRC. Failure to observe these requirements can result in dismissal of enforcement actions, including criminal prosecution for willful nonpayment.
For taxpayers, this ruling reinforces the importance of monitoring correspondence from the BIR and ensuring that formal demands are accurate, clear, and properly documented. For CFOs and accountants, proper recordkeeping of FANs, FLDs, and related correspondence is crucial to safeguard against improper criminal liability.
How We Can Assist
At Ablola, Saribong & Gueco, our tax litigation team assists clients in reviewing BIR assessments, validating FAN/FLD notices, and defending against improper criminal tax charges. We provide comprehensive guidance on compliance, proof of receipt, and due process requirements under Philippine tax law. For professional support in navigating deficiency VAT disputes and safeguarding your business against undue criminal liability, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.