A criminal tax case stayed dismissed after the CTA held that filing a DOJ complaint did not interrupt prescription; the information must be filed in court on time.
Tax prosecutors must file the information in the Court of Tax Appeals within the five-year prescriptive period for Tax Code offenses; a complaint filed with the Department of Justice will not, by itself, save a criminal tax case from prescription.
Background of the Criminal Tax Case
The case involved a criminal prosecution for alleged violation of Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended, in relation to Sections 253(d) and 256. Section 255 generally penalizes failure to file returns, supply correct information, pay tax, withhold and remit tax, refund excess taxes withheld, or comply with other Tax Code requirements. For business owners, corporate officers, and finance teams, this type of case is serious because it is not merely an assessment dispute; it may involve criminal exposure for the corporation and responsible officers.
The prosecution had earlier suffered a dismissal after the Court found that the offense charged had prescribed. The People then filed a motion for reconsideration, arguing that the Court should reverse the dismissal because the complaint had been filed with the Department of Justice on September 28, 2017, before February 8, 2019, which the prosecution identified as the last day of the five-year prescriptive period for the offense charged. In the prosecution’s view, the DOJ filing tolled or interrupted prescription (CTA Crim. Case No. O-833).
The Motion for Reconsideration Was Denied
The Court denied the prosecution’s motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. The result was that the earlier dismissal of the criminal tax case due to prescription remained undisturbed. For the accused taxpayer and responsible officer, this meant that the prosecution failed to revive the criminal case after dismissal. For similarly situated taxpayers, the ruling underscores that prescription is a real and potentially decisive defense in criminal tax cases.
The Court gave three reasons for denying the motion. First, the prosecution failed to comply with the Court’s electronic-copy submission rules. The governing CTA En Banc Resolution required that when the primary filing is made by personal filing, registered mail, or accredited courier, the corresponding PDF copies must be transmitted to the official email addresses within twenty-four hours from filing the paper copies. Otherwise, the pleading or court submission is deemed not filed. Based on the records verification report, the prosecution failed to transmit the motion for reconsideration by email within the required twenty-four-hour period. Applying the rule, the Court treated the motion as not filed.
Second, the Court found that the prosecution failed to show that the BIR legal officers who prepared, signed, verified, and certified the motion had been duly deputized by the Department of Justice or public prosecutor for purposes of prosecuting the case. Under Section 3, Rule 9 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, criminal actions are conducted and prosecuted under the direction and control of the public prosecutor. For Tax Code violations, prosecution may be handled by duly deputized legal officers, but there must be proof of deputation. No such document was attached to the motion.
Filing a DOJ Complaint Did Not Interrupt Prescription
Even assuming the Court disregarded the procedural defects, it still rejected the prosecution’s main legal argument. The prosecution argued that the filing of the complaint with the Department of Justice interrupted the running of the prescriptive period. The Court disagreed.
The Court applied Section 281 of the Tax Code, which provides a five-year prescriptive period for violations of the Tax Code, including Section 255. That period is interrupted when proceedings are instituted against the guilty persons. The critical question was when criminal proceedings before the CTA are considered instituted for purposes of interrupting prescription.
The Court then referred to Section 2, Rule 9 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, which provides that criminal actions before the CTA in Division, in the exercise of original jurisdiction, are instituted by filing an information. The same rule states that the institution of criminal actions interrupts the running of prescription. From this, the Court concluded that it is the filing of the information in court, not merely the filing of the complaint with the DOJ, that interrupts the prescriptive period for criminal tax cases before the CTA.
Why the Ruling Matters to Taxpayers and Corporate Officers
This ruling is particularly important for companies and officers facing criminal tax exposure because it separates the administrative or preliminary investigation stage from the actual institution of a criminal action in court. A taxpayer may be investigated by the BIR, referred to the DOJ, or made the subject of a preliminary investigation, but for prescription purposes, the Court focused on the filing of the information before the CTA.
That distinction matters because tax investigations can take years. If the government delays too long before filing the information in court, the accused may have a viable prescription defense. In a criminal tax case, prescription is not a technical afterthought. It goes to the State’s right to prosecute. Once the offense has prescribed, the case may be dismissed regardless of the underlying tax allegations.
The ruling also reminds government lawyers and tax litigators that CTA procedural rules must be followed strictly. A motion may be treated as not filed if the required electronic copy is not transmitted within the prescribed period. Likewise, pleadings signed by BIR legal officers in criminal tax cases should be supported by proper DOJ deputation authority. These procedural requirements can independently affect the viability of a prosecution.
Practical Takeaways for Businesses Under Tax Investigation
For taxpayers, the first practical takeaway is to build a complete timeline immediately. The relevant dates may include the taxable period, date of discovery, assessment or investigation milestones, referral to the DOJ, filing of the complaint, preliminary investigation dates, and the filing of the information in the CTA. In criminal tax litigation, timing can be as important as the merits.
Second, taxpayers should not assume that a pending DOJ proceeding automatically means the government has preserved its right to prosecute. Based on this ruling, the filing of a complaint with the DOJ was not enough to interrupt the prescriptive period for a criminal tax action before the CTA. The decisive act was the filing of the information in court.
Third, corporate officers named in tax cases should separately evaluate whether they were validly charged as responsible officers. The case involved corporate and officer liability under the Tax Code. In many criminal tax cases, the government must connect the officer to the alleged act or omission, not merely rely on corporate title.
Finally, taxpayers should review not only substantive tax defenses but also procedural defenses. Prescription, lack of authority, defective filings, and failure to comply with CTA rules may all affect the outcome. A strong criminal tax defense requires both tax law analysis and litigation discipline.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco represents taxpayers, corporate officers, and businesses in tax assessments, BIR investigations, DOJ preliminary investigations, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice assists clients in evaluating prescription defenses, challenging defective criminal tax filings, preparing responses to BIR and DOJ proceedings, and building a coordinated civil and criminal tax defense strategy.
If your company, officers, or finance team are facing a tax investigation, a criminal tax complaint, or a case before the Court of Tax Appeals, early legal review can be decisive. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team and assess your available defenses before deadlines and procedural issues determine the outcome.