Professional partnerships may recover erroneous local business tax payments, but only for periods brought to court within the two-year refund deadline.
Professional partnerships that pay local business tax despite being engaged purely in the practice of a regulated profession may recover the erroneous payment, but only for tax periods brought to court within the two-year refund period. For taxpayers dealing with local treasurers, the ruling underscores a critical distinction: not every billing statement is a deficiency assessment that must be protested within 60 days.
Background of the Local Business Tax Dispute
The dispute arose after a professional architectural partnership in Makati was assessed and made to pay local business tax as a contractor for several quarters in 2014 and 2015. The partnership maintained that it was a general professional partnership whose licensed architect-partners were already subject to professional tax, and that its architectural services constituted the practice of profession rather than a taxable contractor business.
The taxpayer filed an administrative claim for refund with the City Treasurer on March 15, 2016, seeking recovery of local business taxes paid from the second quarter of 2014 through the fourth quarter of 2015. After the claim was denied, the taxpayer went to court. The controversy eventually reached the Court En Banc after the City questioned the Division ruling that allowed a reduced refund (CTA EB No. 2771).
The Key Issue: Protest of Assessment or Claim for Refund?
The City argued that the taxpayer should have followed the protest remedy under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. Under that provision, when the local treasurer finds that the correct taxes, fees, or charges have not been paid, the treasurer issues a notice of assessment stating the nature of the tax, the amount of deficiency, and the related surcharges, interests, and penalties. The taxpayer then has 60 days from receipt to file a written protest; otherwise, the assessment becomes final and executory.
The taxpayer, however, relied on Section 196 of the Local Government Code, which governs claims for refund or tax credit of taxes, fees, or charges erroneously or illegally collected. That remedy requires a written claim for refund or credit with the local treasurer before filing in court, and the court action must be brought within two years from payment or from the date the taxpayer became entitled to the refund or credit.
Why the Court Treated the Case as a Refund Claim
The Court rejected the City’s position that the taxpayer was required to file a 60-day protest. The Court explained that the billing statements issued upon renewal of the taxpayer’s business permits were not the kind of notice of assessment contemplated under Section 195. There was no prior investigation or examination of books resulting in a finding of deficiency taxes. Without such a deficiency assessment, there was no assessment that had to be protested under Section 195.
Because the taxpayer had already paid the local business taxes and was claiming that the payments were erroneous or illegally collected, the applicable remedy was the refund procedure under Section 196. The Court likewise held that the parallel provisions of the Revised Makati Revenue Code on protest of assessment and payment under protest were inapplicable because those provisions speak of deficiency tax assessments, not ordinary billings or business permit renewal charges.
Professional Practice Was Not Treated as Contractor Business
On the substantive tax issue, the Court sustained the finding that the taxpayer was engaged in architectural practice. The services identified in the case, including interior design and landscaping, were treated as encompassed within the practice of architecture. The Court also noted that there was no evidence showing that the taxpayer was engaged in a separate business such as interior decorating.
This mattered because the taxpayer’s liability turned on whether it could properly be classified and taxed as a contractor for local business tax purposes. Since the taxpayer was found to be engaged purely in the practice of its profession, the local business tax payments collected under the contractor classification were considered erroneous for the covered periods that remained timely recoverable.
The Taxpayer Won, But Only Partly
The Court denied the City’s petition and affirmed the ruling in favor of the taxpayer. However, the taxpayer did not recover all local business taxes it paid from 2014 to 2015. The judicial action was filed only on July 18, 2017. Applying the two-year period under Section 196, the Court held that the payments for the second, third, and fourth quarters of 2014, and the first and second quarters of 2015, were already time-barred.
Only the payments for the third and fourth quarters of taxable year 2015 were considered timely brought to court. The Court therefore affirmed the refund or credit in the reduced amount of P835,151.26, representing the local business taxes erroneously collected for those two quarters.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Professional Firms
For professional partnerships, architectural firms, engineering firms, law firms, accounting firms, and other regulated professional practices, the ruling is a reminder to examine how the local government classifies the business for local business tax purposes. A professional firm should not simply assume that a contractor or business classification is correct merely because the amount appears in a billing or business permit renewal assessment.
For taxpayers seeking local tax refunds, timing is equally important. Filing an administrative claim with the city treasurer is not enough. A judicial claim must also be filed within the two-year period counted from payment, unless another legally recognized reckoning point applies. A taxpayer that waits too long may win on the legal theory but still lose recovery for earlier quarters due to prescription.
For local tax disputes, the ruling also helps taxpayers distinguish between two remedies. If the local treasurer issues a true deficiency assessment after finding that correct taxes were not paid, the taxpayer must consider the Section 195 protest process. But where the taxpayer has already paid and seeks recovery of taxes erroneously or illegally collected, Section 196 may govern, even if the dispute involves amounts billed by the local government.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, professional partnerships, property owners, importers, and individual taxpayers in local tax disputes, refund claims, deficiency assessments, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether a local tax payment was validly imposed, determine the correct remedy and filing deadlines, prepare administrative refund claims or protests, and pursue judicial relief when necessary.
For assistance with a Makati local business tax dispute, professional tax classification issue, local tax refund, or Court of Tax Appeals case, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.