Criminal tax charges for failure to pay deficiency taxes were dismissed after the government filed beyond the five-year Tax Code prescriptive period.

Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges should closely examine not only the alleged deficiency tax, but also when the assessment became final and when the government actually filed the criminal case. A prosecution for willful failure to pay deficiency taxes under the Tax Code may be dismissed if the five-year prescriptive period has already expired, even if the alleged assessment amount is substantial.

Background of the Criminal Tax Case

The case involved a criminal charge for alleged violation of Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended. The prosecution sought to proceed against a corporate taxpayer and certain individuals for alleged failure to pay deficiency taxes. The original Information was filed on April 8, 2024, but the Court required the prosecution to amend the Information to properly implead the corporate taxpayer and correct deficiencies in the charge (CTA Crim. Case No. O-1140).

The Court first directed the prosecution to amend the Information within five days from notice. The prosecution belatedly filed a Motion to Admit Amended Information. The Court later noted a substantial discrepancy between the amount of income tax due stated in the Formal Assessment Notice, which was PhP28,096,320.76, and the amount stated in the Amended Information, which was only PhP28,096.76. The Court also observed that the BIR had recommended charges under Section 255 in relation to Sections 253(d) and 256 of the Tax Code, but the Amended Information cited only Section 255.

Because an accused has the constitutional right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, the Court directed the prosecution to make the necessary corrections. Despite notices and repeated opportunities, the prosecution failed to comply within the periods given. The Court remarked that almost a year had passed since the original Information was filed and that it had already been lenient in allowing corrections to the deficiencies.

Why the Case Was Dismissed

The Court held that the case could already be dismissed due to the prosecution’s failure to comply with its orders and prosecute the case with sufficient diligence. However, the more decisive point was prescription. Upon reviewing the facts, the Court concluded that the offense charged was already barred by the five-year prescriptive period under Section 281 of the Tax Code.

Section 281 provides that all violations of any provision of the Tax Code prescribe after five years. The prescriptive period generally begins from the day of the commission of the violation. If the violation was not known at the time, prescription begins from discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment. The running of prescription is interrupted when proceedings are instituted against the guilty persons, but begins to run again if the proceedings are dismissed for reasons not constituting jeopardy.

When Prescription Starts in Failure-to-Pay Tax Cases

The key issue was identifying when the alleged offense of willful refusal to pay deficiency taxes was committed. The Court applied Supreme Court rulings holding that this kind of offense is not committed merely upon the filing of the tax return, or even simply upon issuance of an assessment. For refusal to pay deficiency taxes, the offense can be committed only after notice and demand for payment, and more specifically, after the assessment has become final and unappealable, coupled with the taxpayer’s willful refusal to pay within the allotted period.

The Court relied on the principles from Lim and Tupaz. In these cases, the Supreme Court explained that before the taxpayer receives the assessment and before the assessment becomes final, there is still no completed offense for nonpayment of deficiency tax. The taxpayer must first be given the opportunity to protest or question the assessment. Only after the assessment becomes final and the taxpayer willfully refuses to pay may the criminal violation arise.

Application to the Taxpayer

In this case, the Written Report on Personal Service or Substituted Service attached to the Joint Complaint-Affidavit of the Revenue Officers stated that the Formal Assessment Notice was served on the taxpayer on February 7, 2018. The taxpayer had thirty days, or until March 9, 2018, to protest the Formal Assessment Notice, but allegedly did not do so. Because March 9, 2018 led to the assessment becoming final on March 12, 2018, the Court treated March 12, 2018 as the date when the accused allegedly committed the offense of willful refusal to pay the tax.

Counting five years from March 12, 2018, the Information should have been filed with the Court by March 12, 2023. The prosecution, however, filed the Information only on April 8, 2024. By that time, the five-year prescriptive period had already expired. On this basis, the Court dismissed the case.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers

This ruling is important for taxpayers, directors, officers, accountants, and finance teams because it confirms that prescription is a threshold defense in criminal tax cases. A taxpayer accused of willful failure to pay tax should not limit its defense to whether the assessment was correct. It should also reconstruct the timeline: when the FAN was served, when the period to protest expired, when the assessment became final, when the complaint was filed for preliminary investigation, and when the Information was filed in court.

For companies, the ruling also shows the importance of preserving proof of receipt of assessment notices. The date of service of the Formal Assessment Notice can determine when the protest period begins, when the assessment becomes final, and when the prescriptive period for criminal prosecution starts to run. A few dates may decide whether a criminal case may proceed or must be dismissed.

For corporate officers, this decision is a reminder that criminal tax exposure is not automatic merely because a corporation has an assessed deficiency. The prosecution must still comply with procedural requirements, properly state the offense charged, identify the correct legal basis, and file the criminal case within the statutory period. Deficiencies in the Information may implicate the constitutional right of the accused to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation.

For the government, the ruling underscores that tax enforcement must be timely and precise. Courts may give the prosecution opportunities to correct defects, but repeated failure to comply with court orders and missed statutory deadlines can defeat the case entirely.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, importers, and businesses in defending tax assessments and criminal tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate assessment timelines, prescription defenses, validity of notices, defects in Informations, exposure of responsible officers, and available remedies before the BIR, Department of Justice, and the courts.

If your company has received a Formal Assessment Notice, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, demand letter, subpoena, or criminal tax complaint, early review of the timeline and procedural history is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team and assess your options before deadlines affect your defenses.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *