CTA cancelled a Php48.59M local franchise tax assessment due to prescription, lack of territorial jurisdiction, and arbitrary LGU computation.
Telecommunications companies and other franchise holders may still defeat a local franchise tax assessment even if they are not exempt from local franchise tax, especially where the local government unit assesses beyond its territorial jurisdiction, issues the assessment after the prescriptive period, or relies on unverifiable estimated figures instead of a rational tax base.
Background: A Provincial Franchise Tax Assessment Against a Telecom Operator
The dispute arose from a provincial assessment for local franchise tax covering calendar years 2011 to 2015, in the aggregate amount of Php48,587,497.20. The taxpayer received the demand letter on May 13, 2016, protested the assessment on June 7, 2016, and later elevated the matter after the protest was not acted upon. The Regional Trial Court initially dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction, later reconsidered and ruled on the merits, but still denied the taxpayerβs appeal.
On review, the Court of Tax Appeals Second Division examined whether the taxpayer was exempt from local franchise tax, whether the 2011 assessment had prescribed, whether the province could tax receipts recorded in Tuguegarao City, and whether the computation used by the province had sufficient legal and factual basis (CTA AC No. 291).
The Taxpayer Was Not Exempt From Local Franchise Tax
The taxpayer argued that its legislative franchise contained an