A holding company’s local tax challenge failed because payment under protest did not replace the required written refund claim with the city treasurer.

Taxpayers disputing local business tax collections cannot rely on a payment under protest alone when the controversy is treated as a refund case. Where the local government’s demand does not qualify as a valid notice of assessment under the Local Government Code, the taxpayer must first file a written administrative claim for refund with the local treasurer before going to court; otherwise, even a potentially defective tax demand may not result in immediate judicial relief.

Background: Local Business Tax on Dividend Income of a Holding Company

The dispute arose from a local business tax deficiency demand issued by the City Treasurer of Taguig City against a holding company for taxable year 2022. The taxpayer received a document titled “Tax Deficiency Assessment For the year 2022” assessing deficiency tax based on dividend income as a holding company. The amount initially stated was P9,664,415.59, inclusive of penalties and interests. The computation identified the line of business as holding companies, declared gross sales or receipts of P36,072,916.64, gross sales or receipts as presented in audited financial statements of P12,308,346,673.00, a tax due of P6,154,173.34, and resulting surcharges and interest.

The taxpayer objected, arguing that it was a holding company whose earnings consisted of dividends, bank interest, and interest from affiliates; that passive income should not be treated as gross sales or receipts for local business tax purposes; and that it should not be liable for local business tax on dividends from investments. The City Treasurer rejected the request for waiver, citing the Taguig Revenue Code provision, as amended by Ordinance No. 34, Series of 2017, which taxed dividend income received by holding companies from investments in shares of stock or interests in other companies at five percent of one percent.

The taxpayer then paid P10,014,185.04 under protest, including P9,971,222.43 described as deficiency tax relating to holding companies, and filed a petition before the Regional Trial Court seeking to declare the ordinance contrary to the Local Government Code, cancel the assessment, and obtain a refund. The trial court dismissed the petition for procedural non-compliance with the rules on pleadings, particularly the requirement to identify witnesses, summarize intended testimony, attach judicial affidavits, and include documentary and object evidence. The taxpayer elevated the case to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA AC No. 300).

The Court Treated the RTC Case as an Original Action, Not a Simple Appeal

The taxpayer argued that Section 195 of the Local Government Code uses the word “appeal,” and that the Regional Trial Court should have reviewed the local treasurer’s denial as an appellate court on the basis of the local treasurer’s records, without requiring trial-type pleading attachments. The Court rejected that framing.

Relying on Supreme Court doctrine, the Court explained that when a taxpayer brings the denial of a local tax protest to the Regional Trial Court, the RTC exercises original jurisdiction, not appellate jurisdiction. The reason is straightforward: the local treasurer is not a lower court. The first judicial cognizance of the controversy occurs only when the matter reaches the RTC. Appellate jurisdiction of the RTC under Batas Pambansa Blg. 129 is confined to cases decided by Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts, and Municipal Circuit Trial Courts. It does not extend to rulings made by non-judicial local government officials.

This point matters in actual tax litigation. A taxpayer challenging a local treasurer’s denial cannot assume that the case will proceed like a record-based administrative appeal. The pleading must be prepared as a court action, with the required allegations, evidence, and procedural attachments demanded by the Rules of Court, unless a specific procedural rule validly provides otherwise.

The Tax Demand Was Not a Valid Notice of Assessment Under Section 195

The Court also addressed a deeper issue: whether the document issued by the City Treasurer was the kind of notice of assessment contemplated under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. Section 195 applies when the local treasurer finds that correct local taxes, fees, or charges have not been paid and issues a notice stating the nature of the tax, fee, or charge, the amount of deficiency, and the applicable surcharges, interests, and penalties.

Although the document stated figures for deficiency, surcharge, and interest, the Court found that it did not contain information on the facts and law on which the supposed assessment was based. It did not adequately state the nature of the tax, fee, or charge. It merely identified the line of business as “Holding Companies.” Applying Supreme Court rulings on due process in tax assessments, the Court emphasized that taxpayers should not be forced to guess the legal and factual basis for a tax demand. A taxpayer must be informed not only of the amount demanded, but also of the nature of the tax and the authority for the liability.

For taxpayers, this is an important due process point. A local tax demand that simply lists computations, business classifications, and penalties may still be vulnerable if it fails to disclose the factual and legal basis for the charge. However, recognizing that defect does not automatically mean the taxpayer wins the refund case. The chosen remedy and the administrative steps taken before filing in court remain critical.

Why the Taxpayer Still Lost: No Prior Written Claim for Refund

Because the Court found that there was no proper notice of assessment, it held that Section 195 did not govern the taxpayer’s case. Instead, the claim fell under Section 196 of the Local Government Code, which covers recovery of taxes, fees, or charges erroneously or illegally collected. Section 196 requires that a written claim for refund or credit be filed with the local treasurer before any case or proceeding for recovery may be maintained in court. The judicial action must also be filed within two years from the date of payment or from the date the taxpayer becomes entitled to the refund or credit.

The taxpayer paid the alleged deficiency tax on March 27, 2023. Counting two years from that payment, the Court observed that the taxpayer had until March 27, 2025 to file its administrative and judicial claims for refund, with the administrative claim filed first. The problem was that the taxpayer’s prior letters, including the protest letter and the payment-under-protest letter, did not categorically request or claim a refund of the amount paid as deficiency tax.

On that basis, the Court held that the taxpayer failed to exhaust administrative remedies. Without a written administrative claim for refund filed with the City Treasurer before suit, the petition was premature. The Court therefore denied the petition for review and affirmed the RTC’s dismissal, although it clarified that the dismissal should rest on a different ground: failure to comply with the mandatory refund-claim requirement under Section 196.

Practical Takeaways for Local Business Tax Disputes

The ruling is a cautionary decision for companies facing local business tax assessments, especially holding companies, investment companies, property companies, and businesses whose reported accounting income may include dividends, passive income, interest income, or non-operating receipts. The Court did not finally resolve whether the taxpayer’s dividend income was validly taxable by the local government. Instead, the case turned on procedure. That makes the decision especially important for tax managers and counsel because a meritorious substantive argument can be lost, delayed, or dismissed if the procedural track is mishandled.

First, taxpayers should examine whether the local government’s document is a true notice of assessment. A valid notice should identify the nature of the tax, the amount of deficiency, the surcharges, interests, and penalties, and enough legal and factual basis to allow an intelligent protest. If the document is defective, the taxpayer should carefully decide whether the case is a protest under Section 195, a refund claim under Section 196, or both.

Second, a payment under protest should not be treated as a substitute for a refund claim unless the letter clearly and categorically asks for a refund or credit. The safer practice is to expressly state that the taxpayer is claiming a refund or tax credit of the specific amount paid, identify the payment details, explain why the collection was erroneous or illegal, and reserve the right to bring the matter to court if the local treasurer denies or fails to act on the claim.

Third, when the case reaches the Regional Trial Court, counsel should prepare it as an original court action. The petition should comply with the Rules of Court, include the necessary documentary evidence, identify witnesses where required, and attach judicial affidavits if trial evidence will be presented. The mere use of the word “appeal” in the Local Government Code does not eliminate the need to comply with court pleading requirements.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, holding companies, operating companies, and individuals in tax and customs disputes before local treasurers, the Bureau of Internal Revenue, the Bureau of Customs, Regional Trial Courts, and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether a local tax assessment is valid, prepare Section 195 protests and Section 196 refund claims, preserve deadlines, and file the appropriate court action when administrative remedies fail.

For businesses facing local business tax assessments, dividend income disputes, refund claims, or tax collection threats, early procedural strategy is often as important as the substantive tax argument. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on how to protect your remedies before deadlines and procedural defects affect your case.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *