The CTA En Banc upheld the Bureau of Customs’ seizure of goods, clarifying that advance duty payments do not substitute for procedural compliance and proper documentation.
Importers are reminded that advance payments of customs duties do not automatically exempt them from procedural compliance when goods are subject to seizure or forfeiture. The recent En Banc resolution in favor of the Bureau of Customs underscores the importance of maintaining comprehensive documentary evidence to prove timely and accurate payment, as well as adherence to applicable customs orders.
Background
The dispute involved Victor R. Del Rosario Rice Mill Corporation challenging the seizure of imported goods at the Manila International Container Port. The importer filed a Petition for Review which was denied by the Court, prompting a Motion for Reconsideration. The motion contended that Customs Memorandum Order No. 17-2019 did not apply to goods declared abandoned prior to its issuance, and argued that previous advance payments of duties had been properly credited to the Bureau of Customs account (CTA EB No. 2731).
CTA En Banc’s Ruling
The Court denied the Motion for Reconsideration, affirming its prior decision. The Court held that the date of abandonment of the goods was not controlling; rather, the issuance of the Consolidated Order on May 2, 2019, governed the procedural compliance at issue. The Court also clarified that being classified as a