The CTA En Banc dismissed a criminal VAT case against a taxpayer due to prescription and improper BIR filing, affirming strict timelines and the Solicitor General’s role in appellate tax cases.
Taxpayers and corporate practitioners should note that the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc has affirmed the dismissal of a criminal case against a taxpayer for deliberate misreporting in a quarterly VAT return due to the expiration of the prescriptive period. This ruling underscores the strict timelines for prosecuting violations under the Tax Code and clarifies the roles of the BIR and Solicitor General in appellate actions.
Background
The case arose from an Information filed against Antonio Valeriano M. Bernardo, owner of A.V.M. Bernardo Engineering, for misreporting his total vatable sales in the 4th Quarter 2012 VAT return. The BIR audit revealed actual vatable sales of Php22,736,624.00, far exceeding the Php5,472,366.07 reported by Bernardo, resulting in an alleged deficiency of Php2,071,710.95 in VAT. The Information was filed on September 6, 2022, more than six years after the filing of the Joint Complaint-Affidavit with the DOJ for preliminary investigation on February 18, 2016 (CTA EB CRIM. No. 108)
CTA En Banc Division Decision Pโฆ
.
CTA Ruling
The Court in Division dismissed the Information for being barred by prescription, finding that the five-year prescriptive period under Section 281 of the Tax Code had elapsed. The En Banc upheld this dismissal, noting that even if the BIR filed a Verified Petition for Review, it was not properly filed by the Solicitor General or duly deputized legal officers, and thus did not toll the period for appeal. Consequently, the Resolutions dismissing the case became final and executory
CTA En Banc Division Decision Pโฆ
.
Key Legal Principles
The ruling highlights several critical principles: first, the five-year prescriptive period for Tax Code violations commences from the discovery of the violation and institution of judicial proceedings, not merely from the date of the offense. Second, the filing of a complaint with the DOJ for preliminary investigation interrupts but does not extend the prescriptive period beyond five years. Third, the Solicitor General, not the BIR, is responsible for representing the government in appellate proceedings before the CTA En Banc, and filing without proper deputation does not toll the appeal period
CTA En Banc Division Decision Pโฆ
CTA En Banc Division Decision Pโฆ
.
Practical Takeaways
Taxpayers should be aware that criminal tax actions are time-sensitive, and enforcement is constrained by the prescriptive period. Corporate counsel and CFOs should monitor compliance deadlines closely and maintain accurate documentation to avoid exposure to criminal prosecution. Additionally, BIR legal officers must secure proper authorization from the Solicitor General before initiating appellate actions to ensure filings are valid.
Conclusion
The CTA En Banc decision reinforces the importance of timely prosecution and the correct procedural channels in tax enforcement. Tax practitioners, auditors, and corporate officers should be mindful of both the prescriptive periods and the roles of government legal representatives when addressing potential criminal tax violations.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Our tax litigation team provides strategic guidance on VAT compliance, criminal tax exposure, and appellate representation. We help ensure that filings meet procedural requirements and that clients are positioned to protect their rights. Learn more at