A retail taxpayer defeated a P69.98M BIR assessment after the tax court found that the BIR ignored a timely PAN reply and violated due process.
Taxpayers who timely answer a Preliminary Assessment Notice must have their explanations and supporting documents genuinely considered before the BIR issues a final assessment. In this April 2025 decision, a retail sole proprietor defeated a multimillion-peso deficiency income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, registration fee, surcharge, interest, and compromise penalty assessment because the assessment process failed the basic requirements of administrative due process.
CTA 1st Division Decision REBEC…
Background of the Tax Assessment Dispute
The taxpayer was the owner of a sole proprietorship engaged in retail business in Sorsogon City. The BIR issued a Letter of Authority covering the taxpayer’s internal revenue taxes for calendar year 2018. During the audit, the BIR requested records, later served a subpoena duces tecum, and then issued a Notice of Discrepancy, Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice, and Final Decision on Disputed Assessment.
The assessment involved alleged deficiency income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, registration fee, surcharges, interest, and compromise penalty for calendar year 2018. The final amount sought to be collected reached P69,976,123.84, inclusive of surcharge, interest, and compromise penalty. The taxpayer challenged the assessment before the tax court (CTA Case No. 10898), arguing that the assessment lacked factual and legal basis, that the BIR failed to consider her evidence, and that collection through a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy was pursued despite unresolved disputes.
The Core Issue: Was the Taxpayer Given Real Due Process?
The central question was not simply whether the BIR could audit the taxpayer or use available records where documents were incomplete. The decisive issue was whether the BIR complied with Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code and the implementing rules requiring that a taxpayer be informed in writing of the law and the facts on which an assessment is made, and that the taxpayer’s timely explanations be considered before the assessment becomes final.
The taxpayer had responded to the Preliminary Assessment Notice within the 15-day period. However, the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice were issued before the BIR received and considered that reply. The revenue officer also admitted that the findings and total tax deficiency in the Preliminary Assessment Notice and the Formal Letter of Demand were the same. This became highly significant because it showed that the taxpayer’s reply did not meaningfully affect the final assessment process.
Why Identical PAN and FAN Findings Became Fatal
The Court emphasized that the BIR’s procedures are not empty formalities. The Preliminary Assessment Notice stage exists so that a taxpayer may respond before a final assessment is issued. If a taxpayer disputes the findings within the prescribed period, the BIR must first consider the response and then issue the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice within the period provided by the regulations.
In this case, the taxpayer mailed her reply within the reglementary period. The final assessment, however, had already been issued before the BIR received and evaluated that reply. The Court treated this as a disregard of the taxpayer’s right to administrative due process. The BIR could reject the taxpayer’s explanations, but it had to provide some reason for doing so. It could not simply proceed as though no answer had been made.
The Court Also Questioned the Treatment of the Taxpayer’s Evidence
The case also involved alleged undeclared sales based on POS and Z-reading data. The taxpayer presented witnesses who stated that the business reported the correct sales and that the POS system contained a configuration issue. The system provider’s representative testified that the POS system mistakenly displayed accumulated centralized sales instead of stand-alone accumulated sales per POS machine, but clarified that the upper portion of the Z-reading report correctly reflected daily stand-alone sales.
The Court did not need to uphold the taxpayer’s factual theory on every accounting point because the due process defect was already decisive. Still, the treatment of the taxpayer’s documents strengthened the ruling. The Court noted that there was no clear explanation on record why the taxpayer’s arguments and supporting documents were rejected. It also found troubling the unexplained increase in underdeclared sales and disallowed expenses from the Notice of Discrepancy to the Preliminary Assessment Notice and Formal Letter of Demand despite the taxpayer’s document submissions.
Why the Warrant of Distraint and Levy Was Also Set Aside
The taxpayer also received a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy after filing a motion or request for reconsideration. The Court recognized that the issuance of a warrant or the pursuit of collection measures may be treated as an adverse decision that can be appealed to the tax court. Because the warrant related to assessments that were found void, the warrant could not stand independently.
The Court therefore granted the taxpayer’s petition. It declared the notices and assessments void and cancelled them. It also cancelled and set aside the Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy covering the assessed 2018 deficiency tax liabilities, and enjoined the Commissioner or any person acting on the Commissioner’s behalf from pursuing action against the taxpayer relative to the void assessments.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Facing BIR Assessments
This ruling is important for business owners, CFOs, tax managers, and accountants handling BIR audits because it reinforces that the taxpayer’s protest file matters. A reply to a Preliminary Assessment Notice should not be treated as a mere procedural hurdle. If filed on time, it must be considered before the BIR proceeds to a final assessment.
Taxpayers should also preserve proof of mailing, receipt, transmittal, and submission of supporting documents. In a tax assessment appeal, the timeline may decide the case. Here, the sequence of the PAN reply, the issuance of the final assessment, and the later collection action became central to the finding that due process had been violated.
The ruling also warns taxpayers not to rely only on general denials. When disputing alleged undeclared sales, POS data, Z-reading reports, disallowed expenses, or withholding tax findings, taxpayers should submit reconciliations, affidavits, system explanations, accounting records, and documentary support. Those submissions create the record that may later show whether the BIR genuinely considered the taxpayer’s side.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in responding to BIR audits, preparing replies to Preliminary Assessment Notices, filing protests to Formal Letters of Demand and Final Assessment Notices, challenging Final Decisions on Disputed Assessment, and seeking relief before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice focuses on building a complete evidentiary record, identifying procedural defects, and protecting taxpayers from premature or unlawful collection measures.
For businesses, sole proprietors, importers, and corporate officers facing a BIR assessment, warrant of distraint and levy, or tax collection threat, early legal intervention can determine whether the dispute is resolved administratively or must be elevated to litigation. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco regarding tax assessment defense and Court of Tax Appeals litigation.