RMC No. 38-2025 allows cooperative CTE applications to proceed despite missing member TINs if a sworn affidavit is filed and compliance is completed within nine months.

Cooperatives applying for a Certificate of Tax Exemption should no longer be denied, suspended, or delayed solely because not all cooperative members have submitted their Taxpayer Identification Numbers, provided the cooperative files the required sworn affidavit and undertakes to complete the TIN requirement within the prescribed period. RMC No. 38-2025 gives cooperatives immediate relief from a common bottleneck in CTE applications, while still requiring eventual compliance with the BIR’s member TIN submission rules.

What RMC No. 38-2025 Changed

RMC No. 38-2025 clarifies how the BIR will treat cooperative applications for Certificate of Tax Exemption where the remaining problem is the non-submission of Taxpayer Identification Numbers of some or all cooperative members. The key change is practical: if the only lacking requirement is the TIN of members, the BIR office concerned must still process the cooperative’s application and issue the corresponding CTE, as long as the cooperative submits the required sworn affidavit.

This is a significant clarification for cooperatives because earlier compliance rules required the submission of a list of all members with their corresponding TINs, together with other documentary requirements. That general rule remains. RMC No. 38-2025 does not remove the obligation to secure and submit members’ TINs. Instead, it creates an implementation accommodation for cooperatives that have legitimate difficulty securing all member TINs at the time of CTE application.

The Circular recognizes that cooperatives have encountered practical barriers in securing and submitting TINs of their members. These include the capacity of individual members to understand BIR regulations on TIN application, delays in securing documentary requirements for registration, and other administrative difficulties. The BIR’s response is to prevent the CTE process from being held hostage by the TIN issue where there are justifiable reasons and a formal undertaking to comply.

Who Is Affected by RMC No. 38-2025

The issuance directly affects cooperatives applying for or renewing a Certificate of Tax Exemption with the BIR. It is particularly relevant to cooperatives with large memberships, cooperatives in areas where members may have difficulty securing registration documents, and cooperatives whose members are individual taxpayers who may not yet have obtained TINs.

It also affects accountants, tax compliance officers, cooperative officers, and counsel assisting cooperatives in CTE applications. For these advisers, the immediate takeaway is that the absence of complete member TIN information should not automatically stop a CTE application if the cooperative can properly document the reasons for non-compliance and submit the sworn affidavit required by the BIR.

Revenue officials and BIR personnel processing CTE applications are likewise covered. RMC No. 38-2025 is addressed to all revenue officials, employees, and others concerned, and expressly directs that the processing and issuance of the CTE should not be delayed where the Circular’s conditions are met.

Key Compliance Requirements for Cooperatives

Cooperatives must still ensure that their members possess valid TINs in compliance with Section 236 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended, and Revenue Regulations No. 7-2012. As a general rule, the cooperative must submit a list of all members with their corresponding TINs to the BIR, together with the other documentary requirements under Revenue Memorandum Order No. 76-2010.

Where the cooperative cannot secure the TINs of all members, it must submit a sworn affidavit. The affidavit must state all justifiable reasons for failure to comply with the TIN requirement of members before the application for CTE. It must also contain an undertaking that the cooperative will comply with the TIN requirement within nine months from the issuance of the CTE.

The nine-month period is one of the most important compliance details under RMC No. 38-2025. Cooperatives should not treat the issuance as a waiver of the TIN requirement. The rule merely allows the CTE application to proceed while giving the cooperative time to complete the TIN submission requirement after issuance of the CTE.

The sworn affidavit is therefore not a mere formality. It is the document that allows the cooperative to continue with the CTE process despite incomplete member TIN data. Without the sworn affidavit, the relief under RMC No. 38-2025 may not be available.

Effect on CTE Applications Where Member TINs Are the Only Missing Requirement

RMC No. 38-2025 provides that if the only lacking requirement in the cooperative’s application for CTE is the TIN of its members, the application will still be processed and the corresponding CTE will be issued by the concerned BIR office, provided that the sworn affidavit required under the Circular is submitted.

This is the central compliance relief under the issuance. It means a cooperative should be able to move forward with its tax exemption documentation even if it is still completing the TIN registration of members, so long as it can present a sworn explanation and a binding undertaking to complete compliance within nine months from CTE issuance.

For businesses and counterparties transacting with cooperatives, this clarification also matters because a cooperative’s CTE is often needed to support tax treatment, withholding positions, and documentation. Delays in CTE issuance can affect contracts, payments, and accounting treatment. RMC No. 38-2025 helps reduce that delay where the issue is limited to member TIN submission.

Denial, Suspension, or Revocation of CTE

RMC No. 38-2025 expressly states that no CTE of a cooperative shall be suspended or revoked, and no application for CTE shall be denied solely on the basis of non-submission of member TINs, until the availability of the enhanced Online Registration and Update System, or ORUS, and the system is already in place, provided that the cooperative submits the sworn affidavit required under the Circular.

This is a protective rule for cooperatives. It does not excuse non-compliance permanently, but it prevents the harsh result of losing or being denied tax exemption status solely due to the practical difficulty of collecting all member TINs while the improved registration system is not yet fully available and in place.

The Circular also states that a separate revenue issuance will be promulgated as soon as the enhanced ORUS is available and already in place. Cooperatives should monitor further BIR issuances because the compliance treatment may change once the enhanced ORUS becomes operational for this purpose.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

The sworn affidavit must include an undertaking that the cooperative will comply with the TIN requirement within nine months from issuance of the CTE, subject to administrative penalties prescribed under Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 158-2022. RMC No. 38-2025 does not provide a new penalty schedule in the text of the issuance. Instead, it refers to the administrative penalties under RMC No. 158-2022.

For compliance planning, this means cooperatives should calendar the nine-month deadline from the date of CTE issuance and treat it as a hard post-issuance compliance date. The relief granted by RMC No. 38-2025 is conditioned on a commitment to complete the TIN requirement. Failure to honor that undertaking may expose the cooperative to the penalties applicable under the prior BIR issuance.

Practical Steps for Cooperatives and Accountants

Cooperatives applying for a CTE should first determine whether the member TIN issue is the only remaining deficiency. If there are other missing documentary requirements, RMC No. 38-2025 should not be read as curing those separate deficiencies. The clarification is specifically addressed to cases where the only lacking requirement is the TIN of the members.

Second, cooperatives should prepare a complete list of members and identify which members already have valid TINs and which members still need to secure one. This list will help officers, accountants, and counsel demonstrate the cooperative’s actual compliance efforts and isolate the remaining members requiring assistance.

Third, the cooperative should prepare a sworn affidavit stating all justifiable reasons for the failure to secure all member TINs before the CTE application. The affidavit should be specific, factual, and consistent with the cooperative’s records. Generic statements may weaken the cooperative’s position if the BIR later reviews whether the reasons were truly justifiable.

Fourth, the cooperative should include a clear undertaking to comply with the TIN requirement within nine months from the issuance of the CTE. Internal responsibility should be assigned to a particular officer, accountant, or compliance team so that the cooperative can complete the requirement before the deadline.

Finally, cooperatives should monitor the BIR’s future issuance on the enhanced ORUS. RMC No. 38-2025 is partly tied to the availability and implementation of the enhanced Online Registration and Update System. Once that system is available and in place, the BIR may impose updated procedures for TIN issuance and CTE processing.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists cooperatives, corporations, SMEs, and tax-exempt entities with BIR registrations, Certificate of Tax Exemption applications, tax compliance reviews, sworn affidavits, and responses to BIR findings. For cooperatives affected by RMC No. 38-2025, proper documentation is crucial: the sworn affidavit must explain the justifiable reasons for incomplete member TIN submission while protecting the cooperative’s tax exemption position.

Our Makati-based tax and business law team can help review CTE requirements, prepare the required affidavit and undertaking, assess exposure under RMC No. 158-2022, and coordinate the compliance timeline for submission of member TINs within the nine-month period. For assistance with cooperative tax exemption, BIR compliance, and CTE applications, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *