A criminal VAT case was dismissed after the government appealed late, mishandled the Information, and filed beyond the Tax Code’s five-year prescriptive period.
Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may defeat the case without a full trial when the government misses the appeal deadline, repeatedly files defective Informations, or files the criminal action beyond the five-year prescriptive period under the Tax Code. For business owners and corporate officers, the ruling is a reminder that criminal exposure for alleged non-payment of tax depends not only on the amount claimed by the BIR, but also on strict compliance with procedural deadlines, proper charging documents, and timely prosecution.
Background of the Criminal Tax Dispute
The prosecution charged a sole proprietor engaged in the wholesale and retail distribution of pharmaceutical supplies with willful failure to pay value-added tax under Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. The alleged unpaid VAT related to the fourth quarter of taxable year 2016 and amounted to ₱1,372,880.30, exclusive of surcharges and interests.
The case arose after the BIR issued collection notices, a final notice, and a final notice and demand before suit. The original Information, however, contained several deficiencies. The taxpayer’s name was incorrectly stated in one version, the tax type was inconsistently described, and the taxable period required further correction. After the case was transferred between divisions and after multiple opportunities to correct the defects, the prosecution filed a second amended Information. The Court in Division still dismissed the case for failure to prosecute, and later denied reconsideration. The government elevated the matter to the Court En Banc (CTA EB Crim. No. 150).
Appeal Deadline: Receipt by the Principal Prosecutor Controlled
The first major issue was whether the government’s appeal was filed on time. The prosecution computed the 15-day appeal period from the date the deputized BIR special prosecutor received the resolution denying reconsideration. The Court En Banc rejected that computation because the Department of Justice, as the principal public prosecutor, received the resolution earlier.
The Court applied the principle that the appeal period is reckoned from receipt by the principal counsel, not by the deputized lawyer. Although earlier Supreme Court rulings involved the Office of the Solicitor General and deputized government counsel, the Court found the same reasoning applicable where the DOJ deputizes BIR lawyers to prosecute criminal tax cases. BIR lawyers may conduct the prosecution in tax violation cases, but they do so under the ultimate direction and control of the DOJ.
Because the DOJ received the denial of reconsideration on May 2, 2024, the 15-day period expired on May 17, 2024. The Petition for Review was filed only on May 22, 2024. On this ground alone, the appeal was time-barred.
Repeated Defects in the Information Supported Dismissal for Failure to Prosecute
Even if the appeal had been timely filed, the Court En Banc held that the Court in Division did not err in dismissing the case for failure to prosecute. The prosecution had been given several opportunities to correct the Information and comply with court directives. The Court noted that the case had already been delayed for more than a year because of repeated errors in the charging document.
The second amended Information corrected the tax type by stating that the taxpayer was required to pay VAT and allegedly failed to pay VAT for the fourth quarter of taxable year 2016. The Court observed that this amendment was formal because it did not change the nature of the offense, add new elements, or alter the prosecution’s theory. The supporting records already included DOJ resolutions, the investigation data form, the referral letter, the joint complaint-affidavit, collection notices, the VAT return, a certification from the BIR collection section, and the final notice and demand before suit.
However, the formal nature of the amendment did not save the prosecution from the consequences of its repeated lapses. The Court emphasized that an Information in a criminal case is not a casual pleading. It must be prepared with precision because it enables the court to determine jurisdiction and protects the accused from unfair surprise. Errors in the name of the accused, the tax involved, and the taxable period are serious matters in criminal tax litigation.
Five-Year Prescription Barred the Criminal Tax Case
The Court En Banc also found that the government’s right to prosecute had already prescribed. Section 281 of the Tax Code provides that violations of the Code prescribe after five years. Prescription begins from the commission of the violation, or from its discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment. It is interrupted when proceedings are instituted against the guilty person, and begins to run again if the proceedings are dismissed for reasons not constituting jeopardy.
For the offense of willful failure to pay tax, the Court relied on Supreme Court doctrine stating that the offense can be committed only after notice and demand for payment are served and the taxpayer willfully refuses to pay within the period given. In this case, the unpaid tax was a self-assessed VAT liability declared through the BIR’s electronic filing and payment system. Because it was self-assessed, no further Final Assessment Notice was needed to create the tax liability.
The BIR issued a Final Notice dated May 29, 2017, which the taxpayer received on June 9, 2017. The notice gave the taxpayer ten days from receipt, or until June 19, 2017, to settle the liability. Based on that notice, the offense would have been committed upon non-payment after the deadline, and the five-year prescriptive period would have begun on June 20, 2017.
The BIR later issued a Final Notice and Demand Before Suit dated August 4, 2017. However, the prosecution failed to specify how that notice was served or to prove when the taxpayer received it. Even assuming the latest possible reckoning date discussed by the Court, the government had only until September 14, 2022 to file the Information. The Information was filed on December 5, 2022. The criminal action was therefore filed beyond the allowable period.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Business Owners
The ruling is significant for taxpayers facing criminal tax complaints for willful failure to pay tax, especially where the alleged liability is based on self-assessed VAT, income tax, or other returns filed by the taxpayer. Prescription should always be checked carefully. The critical dates include the filing of the return, the issuance and receipt of collection notices, the deadline given to pay, the DOJ referral, and the actual filing of the Information in court.
The decision also shows that procedural defects in criminal tax cases can be decisive. A taxpayer should examine whether the Information correctly identifies the accused, the tax type, the taxable period, the statutory offense, and the factual basis for willfulness. A mismatch between the Information and supporting documents may affect probable cause, due process, and the viability of the prosecution.
For companies, officers, proprietors, and accountants, the ruling does not mean that unpaid self-assessed taxes can be ignored. Self-assessed taxes are generally due without the need for a formal assessment, and non-payment may expose the taxpayer to collection, civil penalties, and possible criminal prosecution. The key lesson is different: when the government chooses to prosecute criminally, it must do so within the period allowed by law and through legally sufficient pleadings.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, business owners, corporate officers, and accounting teams in defending tax and customs disputes before the BIR, Bureau of Customs, DOJ, and Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can review assessments, collection notices, criminal complaints, Informations, prescription periods, and procedural defects that may affect the government’s right to collect or prosecute.
If you or your company received a BIR notice, subpoena, criminal tax complaint, or adverse ruling involving alleged willful failure to pay tax, VAT deficiencies, or other Tax Code violations, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax litigation strategy, CTA appeals, and criminal tax defense.