A BIR assessment was voided after the FAN ignored the taxpayer’s PAN reply, invalidating the FDDA and warrant of distraint and levy.

Taxpayers facing a BIR assessment should treat the reply to a Preliminary Assessment Notice as a critical due process record: if the BIR simply repeats the same findings in the final assessment without addressing the taxpayer’s explanations and documents, the resulting assessment and collection action may be void.

Background: Deficiency Taxes and a Collection Warrant

The dispute involved a domestic corporation assessed for alleged deficiency income tax, expanded withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax for taxable year 2013. The BIR issued a Letter of Authority in 2015, followed by a Preliminary Assessment Notice dated December 20, 2016. The taxpayer filed its reply to the PAN on January 4, 2017, contesting the proposed assessments.

One day later, on January 5, 2017, the BIR issued the Formal Assessment Notice. The FAN reflected alleged deficiency income tax, expanded withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax. The taxpayer then filed a protest and request for reinvestigation. The BIR later issued a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment dated June 5, 2020, and a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy dated October 6, 2021 to collect the total amount of P11,224,733.68. The taxpayer elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals and sought the nullification of the assessment and collection action (CTA Case No. 10668).

The Taxpayer’s Main Objection

The taxpayer argued that the collection warrant was void because it was based on an assessment that had not validly become final and executory. It also maintained that the FDDA was not validly served and that the BIR’s assessment was erroneous and unsupported by law and fact.

The Commissioner, on the other hand, argued that the taxpayer’s appeal was filed out of time, that due process was observed, and that the taxpayer was liable for the assessed deficiency taxes. The Commissioner also contended that the taxpayer was able to contest the FDDA and the warrant before the tax court, which supposedly cured any due process issue.

The Court Found the Appeal Timely

Before reaching the merits, the Court addressed whether the taxpayer properly and timely filed the petition. The taxpayer had electronically filed its petition on November 5, 2021 after the Court closed early for disinfection during the COVID-19 public health emergency. The hard copies and proof of payment of filing fees were submitted within the period allowed under the applicable CTA electronic filing rules.

The Court held that the taxpayer sufficiently proved payment of docket fees and that the petition was timely filed. It also recognized that the validity of a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy falls within the Court’s jurisdiction over “other matters” arising under the National Internal Revenue Code and laws administered by the BIR. This is important for taxpayers because a collection warrant may be questioned before the tax court even where the immediate issue is not merely the amount of tax, but the legality of the BIR’s collection action.

Why the Assessment Failed: The BIR Ignored the PAN Reply

The decisive issue was due process. Section 228 of the Tax Code requires that a taxpayer be informed in writing of the law and the facts on which an assessment is made; otherwise, the assessment is void. Revenue Regulations No. 12-99, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 18-13, likewise requires that the FAN state the facts, law, rules and regulations, or jurisprudence on which the assessment is based.

The Court found that the taxpayer timely replied to the PAN on January 4, 2017. However, the FAN was issued the next day and did not mention, acknowledge, or address the taxpayer’s reply. More importantly, the Court observed that the FAN merely reiterated the findings in the PAN. The basic tax amounts in the PAN and FAN were identical: P4,746,175.81 for income tax, P358,354.61 for expanded withholding tax, and P86,941.00 for documentary stamp tax. The Details of Discrepancies attached to the FAN were also found to be an exact verbatim copy of the Details of Discrepancies attached to the PAN.

For the Court, the problem was not simply that the FAN was issued one day after the reply to the PAN. The fatal defect was the absence of any indication that the BIR actually considered the taxpayer’s explanations and supporting documents. The Court emphasized that due process is not satisfied by giving the taxpayer a formal opportunity to submit a reply if the agency then ignores that reply. The right to be heard includes the right to have the evidence and arguments considered.

The PAN, FAN, FDDA, and WDL Were Voided

Relying on due process principles under the Tax Code, BIR regulations, and Supreme Court jurisprudence, the Court held that the Commissioner failed to consider or appreciate the arguments raised in the taxpayer’s reply to the PAN. Because the PAN and FAN were effectively identical and the FAN did not address the taxpayer’s defenses, the assessment process violated the taxpayer’s right to due process.

As a result, the PAN, FAN, and FDDA were declared null and void and without force and effect. The Court further held that it no longer mattered whether the FDDA had been duly served or actually received, because a void assessment cannot produce a valid FDDA. The Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy, being the fruit of void assessments, could not be enforced against the taxpayer.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Under BIR Audit

This ruling reinforces a practical litigation point: taxpayers should prepare a detailed, evidence-based reply to the PAN and preserve proof that it was filed on time. The PAN stage is not a mere formality. It is part of administrative due process and is meant to give both the taxpayer and the BIR a chance to resolve the matter before a formal assessment is issued.

Taxpayers should also compare the PAN, the FAN, and the Details of Discrepancies side by side. If the FAN simply repeats the PAN without discussing the taxpayer’s reply, documents, or legal arguments, that may support a due process challenge. Identical amounts, identical findings, and verbatim discrepancy schedules may help show that the BIR did not genuinely evaluate the taxpayer’s defenses.

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, this case highlights the importance of building the record early. A short or unsupported PAN reply may limit the taxpayer’s later arguments. A complete reply, with documentary attachments and clear legal positions, can become the foundation for contesting a void assessment if the BIR proceeds mechanically to a FAN.

Collection Warrants Should Not Be Ignored

The ruling also shows that a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy is not simply a collection notice to be handled administratively. If a WDL is issued based on a disputed or void assessment, the taxpayer may need to act quickly because appeals to the tax court are subject to strict periods. In this case, the taxpayer’s timely appeal from receipt of the WDL allowed the Court to review the legality of the collection action.

Businesses should therefore review any WDL immediately upon receipt. The key questions include whether the assessment became final, whether the FDDA was validly issued and served, whether the underlying PAN and FAN complied with Section 228, and whether the BIR considered the taxpayer’s protest and supporting documents.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in BIR audits, administrative protests, requests for reinvestigation, collection disputes, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice helps clients evaluate PANs, FANs, FDDAs, collection letters, warrants of distraint and levy, and other BIR actions for factual, legal, procedural, and due process defects.

If your business has received a BIR assessment or collection warrant, early review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team on how to preserve your remedies, challenge void assessments, and protect your company from premature or unlawful tax collection.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *