The CTA ruled that Diageo Philippines’ alleged tax assessments were void due to improper service, invalidating related collection actions and WDLs.

Taxpayers and importers should be aware that assessments not properly served are considered void, blocking the Bureau of Internal Revenue from enforcing collection. This has immediate implications for companies facing alleged late payment of income taxes or VAT.

Background

Diageo Philippines, Inc., a major importer and distributor of beverages and liquors, faced alleged deficiency taxes covering the periods 2016 to 2018. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue issued Preliminary Notices in 2018 and a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy (WDL) in December 2020, seeking collection of Php7,665,972.88 for unpaid income taxes, VAT, and penalties. The taxpayer contested the WDL through a petition filed on January 15, 2021 (CTA Case No. 10452), asserting that it never received valid assessment notices prior to the WDL.

CTA’s Ruling

The Court found that the assessment notices were not properly served. The taxpayer received only an email from the BIR indicating that scanned copies of the assessments would be provided upon request, and the physical WDL was delivered to a lobby receptionist rather than an authorized representative. The Court emphasized that service via email or improperly through registered mail, without showing that personal service was impracticable, does not comply with RR No. 18-2013. Accordingly, the assessments were void, and any WDL issued based on them was invalid.

Key Legal Principles Applied

The CTA relied on established due process jurisprudence, noting that a valid assessment must be properly served to allow the taxpayer to file a protest or administrative appeal. Cases such as Metro Star Superama, Inc., BASF Coating + Inks Phils., Inc., and Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Reyes reinforced that a WDL cannot be enforced in the absence of a valid assessment. Additionally, the lifeblood doctrine confirms that while the BIR has discretion to collect taxes expeditiously, such collection cannot override fundamental procedural requirements.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers

Companies should verify receipt of assessment notices and ensure proper service is documented. If an assessment is not validly served, taxpayers may challenge both the assessment and any resulting collection action. Registries, emails indicating copies upon request, or delivery to unauthorized persons do not satisfy due process requirements. Importers and businesses should maintain evidence of official communications and request assessments when not provided.

Conclusion

In this case, the CTA declared the WDL and underlying assessments void, preventing the BIR from collecting the alleged deficiency taxes. Taxpayers facing similar disputes now have a precedent confirming that improper service invalidates assessments and bars enforcement.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Our tax litigation team helps businesses navigate complex disputes with the BIR, including challenging improperly issued assessments and WDLs. Visit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *