The CTA acquitted Fritz and Macziol Asia, Inc. and its president of criminal WTC violations due to lack of willfulness, but the corporation remains civilly liable for unpaid taxes.

Taxpayers and corporate officers should carefully note that being listed as a corporate president does not automatically impose criminal liability for a company’s unpaid taxes. In a recent Court of Tax Appeals decision, a domestic corporation and its president were acquitted of criminal charges for willful failure to remit withholding taxes on compensation, despite the company’s large unpaid balances. However, the corporation may still face civil liability for the outstanding amounts.

Background

The case arose from alleged violations of Sections 253(d), 255, and 256 of the National Internal Revenue Code, where the Bureau of Internal Revenue charged Fritz and Macziol Asia, Inc., a software and systems integration firm, and its president, Reynaldo Y. Dia, for willfully failing to remit withholding taxes on compensation (WTC) for 16 taxable periods between December 2016 and July 2019 (CTA CRIM. CASE NO. 0-1002). The corporation had received Preliminary and Final Collection Notices from the BIR and was alleged to owe over Php44 million in WTC.

CTA’s Ruling

The Court carefully examined whether the prosecution proved that the corporation acted willfully in failing to remit taxes. Testimony and documentary evidence revealed that while WTC returns had not been fully paid, the corporation had made partial payments and attempted to settle its liabilities. Financial constraints, discontinued projects, terminated client contracts, and previous legal actions against the company contributed to its inability to pay the full amounts.

Regarding corporate officer liability, the Court emphasized that merely holding the title of president does not establish criminal responsibility. The prosecution must prove that the officer was


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *