Supreme Court held a golf club may be non-stock despite issuing shares if dividends are barred, allowing lawful limits on member voting rights.
Golf and country clubs that issue shares are not automatically stock corporations. If their articles prohibit dividends and their purpose is social, recreational, or athletic rather than profit distribution, they may be treated as non-stock corporations with the power to limit or structure member voting rights in their by-laws.
Why This Ruling Matters to Clubs, Associations, and Members
The ruling is important for membership clubs, homeowners’ associations, recreational corporations, and other private associations that use shares, certificates, or transferable memberships as part of their internal structure. The Supreme Court clarified that the mere existence of capital stock or share certificates does not, by itself, determine whether a corporation is stock or non-stock. What matters is whether the corporation is authorized to distribute dividends or surplus profits to the holders of those shares.
For ordinary members, the practical consequence is direct: a club may issue membership-related shares and still remain a non-stock corporation if no part of its income is distributable as dividends. As a non-stock corporation, it may limit, broaden, or deny voting rights by class of members, if the articles of incorporation or by-laws validly provide for those limits. That can affect who votes in club elections, who counts for quorum, and who may participate in corporate governance.
Background: Forest Hills’ By-Laws Were Rejected Because the SEC Treated It as a Stock Corporation
Forest Hills Golf and Country Club, Inc. was registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission in 1995. In 2013, it applied for approval of amended by-laws that would limit voting rights to bona fide individual regular members and duly designated nominees of juridical entities, all of whom had to be in good standing. It also proposed provisions on quorum and amendment of by-laws.
The SEC Company Registration and Monitoring Department rejected the amendments, reasoning that Forest Hills was a stock corporation and that stockholders could not be deprived of voting rights except as allowed by law. The SEC En Banc affirmed and directed Forest Hills to amend its articles to reflect that it was a stock corporation. The Court of Appeals agreed, with some modification, finding that the club’s issuance of shares and the potential increase in share value supported its classification as a stock corporation. The Supreme Court, in Forest Hills Golf and Country Club, Inc. v. SEC-Company Registration and Monitoring Department (G.R. No. 256634), reversed.
The Supreme Court’s Doctrine: The Two-Requisite Test for Stock Corporations
The Court applied Section 3 of the Corporation Code and the Revised Corporation Code. A stock corporation exists only when two requisites concur: first, it has capital stock divided into shares; and second, it is authorized to distribute dividends or allotments of surplus profits to holders of those shares on the basis of their shareholdings. These requirements are cumulative, not alternative.
Forest Hills satisfied the first requirement because it had capital stock divided into shares. But it did not satisfy the second. Its stated corporate purpose was to promote social, recreational, and athletic activities on a non-profit basis among its members, including the construction and maintenance of golf, tennis, swimming, and related recreational facilities. Its articles also expressly provided that no profit would inure to any member, no dividend would be declared or paid, and members would only be entitled to a pro-rata share of assets upon dissolution or liquidation.
Because the club was not authorized to distribute dividends, the Court held that it could not be classified as a stock corporation. The Court emphasized that classification is not controlled by labels such as