Employers must give a specific reassignment, not vague return-to-work notices, or floating status may become constructive dismissal.
Employees placed on floating status are not required to wait indefinitely on unpaid standby while the employer sends vague return-to-work notices. When an employer pulls out a worker from a client assignment, it must eventually give a real reassignment to a specific client or post; otherwise, the employee may be treated as constructively dismissed and may recover backwages, separation pay, attorney’s fees, and legal interest.
Why This Ruling Matters to Employees and Contractors
The ruling in Sagarino v. Toplis Solutions is important for manpower agencies, service contractors, hotel and hospitality staffing providers, security agencies, outsourced personnel providers, and employees assigned to third-party clients. It clarifies that floating status may be lawful at the beginning, but it does not become lawful forever simply because the employer keeps saying that the employee should report back to the office.
For workers, the decision answers a common question: if I was pulled out from my client assignment and told I am on floating status without pay, am I already dismissed? The answer depends on the facts. The filing of an illegal dismissal case may be premature if the six-month floating period has not yet lapsed. But if the employer fails, during the proceedings and beyond the reasonable period, to give a concrete reassignment to a specific client or post, the floating status may ripen into constructive dismissal.
Background: A Hotel Assignment, a Pull-Out Notice, and an Unpaid Floating Status
Andrei Nicholette Sagarino was hired by Toplis Solutions, Inc. and assigned to Azalea Hotel and Residences in Baguio as Front Office Supervisor. Her contract described her employment as probationary, with a monthly salary of PHP 15,000.00. The agreement also stated that Toplis could transfer her to another client and that, if a client requested her relief or if a service contract was cancelled or not renewed, the employer-employee relationship would not be severed and she could become part of the company’s manpower pool.
After an incident involving a subordinate and subsequent discussions at the hotel, Sagarino was issued a Notice of Pull Out effective August 10, 2019. The notice stated that she failed to pass the standard performance evaluation and would be placed on floating status pending redeployment. She disputed the basis for the pull-out and alleged that the evaluation attached to the notice reflected lower scores than a prior evaluation. She filed a labor complaint for illegal dismissal, non-payment of monetary benefits, damages, and attorney’s fees. The Supreme Court decided the case on October 15, 2025 (G.R. No. 267379).
The First Key Doctrine: Probationary Employees Become Regular When Standards Are Not Made Known
The Court first affirmed that Sagarino was a regular employee, despite the contract’s use of the label