Franchise holders may defeat local contractor’s tax assessments by proving payment of the 3% franchise tax under a clear “in lieu of all taxes” clause.
Companies operating under a legislative franchise with an express “in lieu of all taxes” clause should preserve complete proof of franchise tax payments, because those records may determine whether a city can still impose local contractor’s tax on the same franchise receipts. In this local tax dispute, the taxpayer avoided a ₱34.598 million Contractor’s/City Tax assessment after proving that it had paid the 3% franchise tax required under its franchise law.
Background of the Local Tax Dispute
The taxpayer is a corporation granted a national franchise under Republic Act No. 9511 to operate, manage, maintain, and develop the country’s high-voltage electricity transmission system. Under Section 9 of that franchise, the taxpayer is required to pay a franchise tax equivalent to 3% of all gross receipts derived from operations under the franchise.
The city treasurer assessed the taxpayer for Contractor’s/City Tax covering calendar years 2009 to 2022 in the aggregate amount of ₱34,598,981.94. The taxpayer filed a written protest under Section 195 of the Local Government Code, arguing that it was exempt from the local tax because its 3% franchise tax under Republic Act No. 9511 was in lieu of income tax and any and all taxes, duties, fees, and charges imposed by any local or national authority on its franchise, rights, privileges, receipts, revenues, profits, and properties used in connection with its franchise.
After alleged inaction on the protest, the taxpayer filed a petition before the Regional Trial Court. The trial court denied the taxpayer’s petition and later denied reconsideration, relying on an earlier Court of Tax Appeals En Banc ruling involving the same taxpayer and local taxing authority. The taxpayer elevated the case to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA AC No. 349), arguing that it had presented evidence proving its payment of the 3% franchise tax for the relevant years and that a later Supreme Court ruling had already reversed the prior ruling relied upon by the trial court.
The Court of Tax Appeals Had Jurisdiction Over the Appeal
Before reaching the merits, the Court of Tax Appeals first confirmed that it had jurisdiction over the petition. Under Republic Act No. 1125, as amended by Republic Act No. 9282, the Court of Tax Appeals has exclusive appellate jurisdiction to review decisions, orders, or resolutions of Regional Trial Courts in local tax cases originally decided or resolved by them.
The taxpayer received the trial court’s order denying reconsideration on September 24, 2024. It then filed its petition for review on October 24, 2024, which was within the 30-day period allowed under the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals. Because the appeal was timely, the tax court proceeded to resolve whether the local contractor’s tax assessment could stand.
Why the Local Contractor’s Tax Assessment Was Cancelled
The tax court held that Republic Act No. 9511 grants the taxpayer an exemption from local taxes on gross receipts arising from its franchise, provided that the taxpayer proves payment of the 3% franchise tax. Section 9 of the franchise law states that the 3% franchise tax shall be in lieu of income tax and any and all taxes, duties, fees, and charges of any kind imposed by any authority, local or national, on the taxpayer’s franchise, rights, privileges, receipts, revenues, profits, and properties used in connection with the franchise.
The decision relied on Supreme Court doctrine recognizing that the taxpayer’s franchise is materially different from franchises whose “in lieu of all taxes” clauses do not expressly mention local taxes. In this case, the statutory wording specifically includes taxes imposed by local authorities and covers receipts, revenues, and profits connected with the franchise. That express language was critical. Tax exemptions are generally construed strictly, but when the exemption is clearly and unequivocally written into the franchise, courts must apply it according to its terms.
The Court of Tax Appeals emphasized that payment of the 3% franchise tax is the operative act that allows the taxpayer to invoke the exemption. Put differently, the exemption is not claimed in the abstract. The taxpayer must show that it actually paid the franchise tax on the gross receipts derived from its franchise operations. Failure to prove payment would defeat the exemption; proof of payment activates the statutory protection against duplicative local taxation.
Proof of Franchise Tax Payment Was the Decisive Evidence
The taxpayer presented BIR Certifications issued by the Large Taxpayers Service and BIR forms used in paying the 3% franchise tax. These documents were offered before the trial court to show that the taxpayer had paid the franchise tax for the period relevant to the local tax assessment.
The tax court found that these records were not successfully challenged. The local government did not object to the presentation or submission of the BIR Certifications and BIR forms. In fact, the local government acknowledged that, in view of the Supreme Court’s reversal of the earlier tax court ruling, its imposition of Contractor’s/City Tax for the period 2009 to 2022 was no longer tenable.
Because the BIR Certifications were issued by the agency tasked with collecting national internal revenue taxes, they enjoyed the presumption of regularity in the performance of official duties. As official records, they carried weight and credence, especially because they were uncontroverted. Together with the BIR forms, they adequately proved payment of the 3% franchise tax.
Practical Takeaways for Franchise Holders and Local Taxpayers
This ruling is important for public utilities, infrastructure operators, telecommunications companies, energy companies, and other businesses operating under legislative franchises. A franchise tax exemption is only as strong as the statutory language and the taxpayer’s evidence. Where the franchise expressly states that the franchise tax is in lieu of local and national taxes, the taxpayer may have a strong defense against local business taxes, contractor’s taxes, or similar local assessments imposed on franchise receipts.
However, taxpayers should not assume that all “in lieu of all taxes” clauses have the same effect. Courts examine the exact wording of the franchise. Some clauses may cover only national taxes. Others may expressly include local taxes. Some may apply only to the franchise itself, while others may extend to receipts, revenues, profits, and properties used in connection with the franchise. The outcome depends on the law’s text, the nature of the tax assessed, and the taxpayer’s proof of compliance with the franchise tax requirement.
The ruling also shows the importance of documentation during local tax audits. BIR Certifications, franchise tax returns, payment forms, and accounting records should be organized by taxable year. When a city or municipality issues an assessment, the taxpayer should be ready to show not only that its franchise contains an exemption, but also that it paid the national franchise tax that triggers the exemption.
For local governments, the ruling is a reminder that local taxing power remains subject to express statutory exemptions granted by Congress. While cities and municipalities have broad authority to impose local business taxes, that power cannot override a clear legislative franchise provision exempting particular receipts or operations from local taxation once the required franchise tax has been paid.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, franchise holders, public utilities, contractors, importers, and business owners in handling local tax assessments, BIR assessments, Court of Tax Appeals petitions, protests under the Local Government Code, and tax litigation strategy. Our tax litigation practice can review the legal basis of an assessment, evaluate available exemptions, prepare administrative protests, organize documentary evidence, and represent taxpayers before local treasurers, trial courts, and the Court of Tax Appeals.
If your company has received a local business tax, contractor’s tax, franchise tax, or real property tax assessment, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on how to protect your rights, preserve deadlines, and challenge improper tax assessments.