A billing statement was not a valid local tax assessment, allowing the taxpayer to claim a timely Section 196 refund of Taguig local business tax.

Businesses that pay local taxes merely to renew a business permit may still recover the payment if the city did not issue a proper local tax assessment stating the factual and legal basis of the charge. A billing statement, by itself, does not automatically trigger the protest procedure under Section 195 of the Local Government Code; where no valid assessment exists, the taxpayer may pursue a refund under Section 196 within the two-year period from payment.

Background: Business Permit Renewal Led to Local Business Tax on Dividend Income

The dispute arose from a corporation’s renewal of its business permits with the City of Taguig for 2018 and 2019. In connection with those renewals, the taxpayer received billing statements that included local business tax on dividend income. For 2018, the amount billed for local business tax on dividend income was Php139,064.34. For 2019, the amount was Php514,035.47. The taxpayer paid the amounts, resulting in a total disputed local business tax payment of Php653,099.81.

The taxpayer later filed an administrative claim for refund on September 18, 2019, asserting that the local business tax was erroneously paid and illegally collected because it was not a bank or financial institution but a holding company. Afterward, it filed a court action before the Regional Trial Court on January 20, 2020, seeking refund of the local business tax payments. The trial court granted the refund, and the City Treasurer elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA AC No. 324).

The Core Issue: Section 195 Protest or Section 196 Refund?

The City Treasurer argued that the taxpayer’s claim was filed too late because the billing statements should be treated as notices of assessment. Under Section 195 of the Local Government Code, a taxpayer who receives a local tax assessment must file a written protest within sixty days from receipt. If the protest is denied, or if the treasurer fails to act within the prescribed period, the taxpayer must elevate the matter to court within thirty days. If those periods are missed, the assessment becomes final, conclusive, and unappealable.

The taxpayer countered that Section 195 did not apply because the billing statements were not proper notices of assessment. Instead, the taxpayer relied on Section 196, which governs recovery of local taxes, fees, or charges erroneously or illegally collected. Under Section 196, no court case for recovery may be maintained unless a written claim for refund or credit is first filed with the local treasurer, and no court case may be entertained after the expiration of two years from the date of payment or from the date the taxpayer became entitled to the refund or credit.

Why the Billing Statements Failed as Local Tax Assessments

The Court of Tax Appeals agreed with the taxpayer and affirmed the trial court. The Court emphasized that a notice of assessment under Section 195 must inform the taxpayer of the nature of the tax, fee, or charge, the amount of deficiency, and the applicable surcharges, interests, and penalties. It must be sufficiently informative so that the taxpayer can understand the basis of the alleged liability and prepare an intelligent protest.

The billing statements in this case did not meet that standard. They were issued in connection with business permit renewal and contained a breakdown of items such as permit fees, inspection fees, fire permit fees, signage-related fees, and other charges. The Court found that they lacked the necessary details as to the basis of the alleged deficiency, the legal basis for imposing the local business tax, and the applicable surcharge, interest, or penalty. The Court also noted testimony that the documents were specifically designated as billing statements, not notices of assessment, and that they were issued by the Business Permits and Licensing Office rather than as formal notices of assessment by the City Treasurer.

Section 196 Applied Because No Valid Assessment Was Issued

Because no valid notice of assessment was issued, the taxpayer’s remedy was not confined to a Section 195 protest. The Court applied the Supreme Court’s distinction between the two local tax remedies: when a taxpayer receives an assessment, the protest procedure under Section 195 governs; but when no assessment notice is issued and the taxpayer claims that a tax, fee, or charge was erroneously paid or illegally collected, Section 196 applies.

Applying Section 196, the Court held that the refund claim was timely. The taxpayer paid the 2018 local business tax on January 20, 2018 and the 2019 local business tax on January 19, 2019. It filed the administrative claim for refund on September 18, 2019, and filed the judicial claim on January 20, 2020. The Court treated both the administrative and judicial claims as having been filed within the two-year prescriptive period applicable to the payments.

The City Could Not Cure the Defect by Raising the Ordinance in Court

The City Treasurer also argued that the taxpayer, as a holding company, was liable for local business tax under Taguig’s tax ordinance. The Court was not persuaded. Even assuming the city had a taxing power and an ordinance it wished to invoke, the exercise of local taxation must still comply with the requirements of law. The taxpayer must be informed at the administrative level of the legal and factual basis for the tax being imposed.

The Court held that raising the ordinance only when the case had already reached the judicial level did not cure the failure to state the legal basis in the billing statements. The defect was not merely technical. A taxpayer cannot be expected to properly contest a local tax charge if the city does not first state why the taxpayer is liable, what law or ordinance is being applied, how the amount was computed, and whether any deficiency, surcharge, interest, or penalty is being imposed.

Practical Takeaways for Businesses Facing Local Business Tax Assessments

This ruling is important for corporations, holding companies, real estate companies, and other businesses that pay local taxes as part of business permit renewal. A city or municipality may have broad local taxing powers, but those powers are not self-executing in a way that bypasses due process. If the local government is asserting a deficiency or imposing a local business tax based on a particular classification, it must clearly communicate the basis of the assessment.

For taxpayers, the ruling highlights the need to distinguish between a true notice of assessment and a mere billing statement. If a valid assessment is issued, the taxpayer must act quickly under Section 195 by filing a protest within sixty days and, if necessary, going to court within the prescribed period. If no proper assessment exists and the tax was paid, Section 196 may allow a refund action, provided both the administrative and judicial steps are taken within the two-year period.

Businesses should also avoid treating business permit renewal payments as routine or uncontestable. Local business tax computations may include classifications, gross receipts bases, or income items that deserve review, especially where the taxpayer is being treated as a bank, financial institution, contractor, dealer, holding company, or other taxable category with different local tax consequences. Payment under a billing statement should be documented carefully, and any refund theory should be evaluated immediately to avoid prescription issues.

Result: Refund of Local Business Tax Affirmed

The Court denied the City Treasurer’s petition for review and affirmed the trial court’s ruling ordering the refund of Php653,099.81, with legal interest of six percent per annum from finality of the decision until full satisfaction, plus costs of suit. The ruling reinforces that local governments must issue legally sufficient assessments before invoking the strict protest deadlines under Section 195 of the Local Government Code.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in local tax assessments, business permit tax disputes, refund claims, and appeals before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can evaluate whether a city or municipality issued a valid assessment, determine the correct remedy under Sections 195 or 196 of the Local Government Code, prepare administrative protests or refund claims, and represent taxpayers in court when local taxes have been unlawfully assessed or collected. For assistance with local business tax, real property tax, customs, or national tax disputes, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *