A criminal tax case with no specified principal tax claim may proceed in the RTC when the Tax Code offense carries imprisonment exceeding six years.
Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that a large alleged sales discrepancy automatically places the case within the Court of Tax Appeals at the trial level. Where the Information does not specify the principal amount of taxes and fees being claimed, jurisdiction may remain with the regular courts, and the applicable penalty under the Tax Code becomes critical in determining whether the case belongs before the first-level courts or the Regional Trial Court.
Background of the Criminal Tax Dispute
The case arose from a criminal Information filed against a domestic corporation and two of its officers, who were charged with violation of Section 255, in relation to Sections 253(d) and 256 of the 1997 National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. The prosecution alleged that the corporation, through its president and treasurer, willfully failed to supply correct and accurate information in its Third Quarter Value-Added Tax Return for taxable year 2021.
The Information alleged that the corporation made it appear that its sales amounted to Php1,084,796,944.95, even though it allegedly failed to file its Quarterly Summary List of Sales and Purchases for 2021 and the Summary List of Purchases of all buyers or customers from the corporation allegedly amounted to Php10,010,616,879.89. The Regional Trial Court of Quezon City dismissed the criminal case for lack of jurisdiction, reasoning that criminal tax offenses involving a principal amount of taxes and fees of Php1,000,000.00 or more fall within the exclusive original jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals. The prosecution appealed (CTA Crim. Case No. A-20).
The Court’s Ruling: The RTC Had Jurisdiction
The Court of Tax Appeals granted the prosecution’s appeal, reversed the dismissal orders, and remanded the criminal case to the Regional Trial Court for continuation of proceedings with dispatch. The key point was not the large amount of alleged sales or purchases reflected in the Information. The controlling point was that the Information did not state any specific amount of principal taxes and fees being claimed by the government from the accused.
The Court emphasized that Section 7(b)(1) of Republic Act No. 1125, as amended by Republic Act No. 9282, gives the Court of Tax Appeals exclusive original jurisdiction over criminal tax cases only when the principal amount of taxes and fees, exclusive of charges and penalties, being claimed is at least Php1,000,000.00. By contrast, regular courts have original jurisdiction where the principal amount of taxes and fees claimed is less than Php1,000,000.00 or where there is no specified amount claimed.
Because the Information charged the accused with failure to supply correct and accurate information, but did not identify a specific principal tax liability being claimed, the Court found that the case fell within the original jurisdiction of the regular courts. The remaining question was which regular court should hear the case.
Why the Penalty Matters When No Tax Amount Is Claimed
The Court explained that where no specific principal tax amount is claimed, the proper regular court is determined by the maximum imposable penalty. First-level courts generally have jurisdiction over offenses punishable by imprisonment not exceeding six years. Regional Trial Courts have jurisdiction over criminal cases not falling within the exclusive jurisdiction of another court, including offenses punishable by imprisonment exceeding six years.
Section 255 of the Tax Code punishes, among others, the willful failure to supply correct and accurate information. The provision carries imprisonment of not less than one year but not more than ten years, in addition to the fine provided by law. Since the maximum imposable penalty exceeds six years, the Court concluded that the Regional Trial Court, not a first-level court, had exclusive original jurisdiction over the criminal case.
This ruling also confirms a familiar rule in criminal procedure: jurisdiction over a criminal case is determined by the allegations in the complaint or Information. Courts do not simply look at the commercial size of the transaction, the magnitude of alleged sales, or the amount of alleged purchases. For jurisdictional purposes in criminal tax cases, the charging document must be examined to determine whether the government is actually claiming a specified principal amount of taxes and fees.
Why the Trial Court’s Dismissal Was Reversed
The Regional Trial Court dismissed the case on the theory that the Court of Tax Appeals has original jurisdiction where the principal amount of taxes and fees is Php1,000,000.00 or more. While that jurisdictional rule is correct as a general proposition, the Court of Tax Appeals found that it was misapplied. The Information did not allege that the government was claiming at least Php1,000,000.00 in principal taxes and fees. It alleged figures relating to declared sales and third-party purchases, but those figures were not pleaded as the principal tax amount claimed by the government.
That distinction mattered. A discrepancy in reported sales or purchases may be relevant to the prosecution’s theory of criminal liability, but it is not automatically the same as the principal amount of taxes and fees claimed for jurisdictional purposes. Without a specified principal tax claim, the case remained within the original jurisdiction of the regular courts. Since the charged offense under Section 255 carries a maximum imprisonment term of ten years, the proper forum was the Regional Trial Court.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers, Officers, and Corporate Counsel
For corporate taxpayers and officers named in criminal tax cases, the Information should be reviewed carefully at the outset. The jurisdictional issue may turn on whether the prosecution alleges a specific principal tax amount, not merely on whether the case involves large transactions, billions in purchases, or significant discrepancies in VAT reporting. This can affect where the case should be tried, the remedies available, and the strategy for challenging the proceedings.
For companies dealing with VAT assessments, third-party matching issues, and summary list discrepancies, the decision is also a reminder that administrative tax exposure and criminal tax exposure are not the same thing. A VAT return discrepancy may lead to assessment, investigation, or prosecution, but the charging document must still properly allege the offense and establish the correct forum. Where the alleged violation is failure to file, failure to supply correct information, or similar conduct under Section 255, counsel should analyze both the alleged facts and the penalty structure.
For the prosecution, the ruling underscores the need for precision in drafting Informations for tax offenses. If the government intends to invoke the original jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals, the Information must clearly state the principal amount of taxes and fees being claimed, exclusive of charges and penalties. If no amount is specified, the case may belong in the regular courts, and the particular regular court will depend on the maximum penalty imposable under the statute charged.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, importers, and businesses involved in tax assessments, criminal tax investigations, Court of Tax Appeals litigation, and jurisdictional challenges involving the Bureau of Internal Revenue and the Bureau of Customs. Our tax litigation practice can review Informations, assessment records, notices, protest histories, VAT documentation, and procedural timelines to determine the proper forum and available defenses.
If your company or officers are facing a criminal tax complaint, VAT discrepancy investigation, or tax case before the regular courts or the Court of Tax Appeals, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax litigation strategy, jurisdictional defenses, and representation in tax and customs disputes.