Petroleum importers may claim Section 135 excise tax refunds, but Jet A-1 fuel sales need proof that airline buyers hold Foreign Air Carrier Permits.
Petroleum importers seeking excise tax refunds on aviation fuel sold to international airlines must prove not only that the buyer is foreign-registered, but that it legally qualifies as an international carrier authorized to operate in the Philippines. In this ruling, the Court of Tax Appeals kept the taxpayer’s refund at the previously allowed amount and refused to add the portion tied to airlines without Foreign Air Carrier Permits, while also rejecting the Commissioner’s attempt to deny the refund altogether.
Background of the Jet Fuel Excise Tax Refund Dispute
The dispute arose from a claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate involving excise taxes paid on Jet A-1 fuel imported in September and October 2020 and later sold and delivered to tax-exempt international air carriers from October to December 2020. In its earlier decision, the tax court partially granted the taxpayer’s claim and ordered the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate in the amount of P82,183,896.00.
Both sides moved for partial reconsideration. The taxpayer asked the court to allow an additional P1,311,624.00 in excise taxes covering Jet A-1 fuel sold to two airlines whose transactions had been disallowed because of the absence of Foreign Air Carrier Permits from the Civil Aeronautics Board. The Commissioner, on the other hand, argued that the taxpayer should not be entitled to the refund because the exemption under Section 135 of the National Internal Revenue Code allegedly applied only to international carriers, not to the petroleum importer or manufacturer that paid the excise tax (CTA Case No. 10966).
The Taxpayer’s Argument on Substantial Compliance Failed
The taxpayer argued that even without the Foreign Air Carrier Permits, other documents sufficiently proved that the airline buyers were foreign or international carriers. It relied on Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines certifications, Aviation Service Returns, and air transport agreements involving Malaysia and Germany. In the taxpayer’s view, these documents established the foreign registry of the airlines and therefore amounted to substantial compliance with the statutory requirement under Section 135(a) of the Tax Code.
The court rejected this position. It explained that a Foreign Air Carrier Permit is not a mere technical document that can be replaced by other proof of foreign registration. Under the regulatory framework governing air transportation in the Philippines, the permit issued by the Civil Aeronautics Board and approved by the President authorizes a foreign carrier to engage in foreign air transportation. The court treated this permit as a condition sine qua non before a foreign carrier may be granted operating rights.
Because of this, the absence of the permit did more than create doubt over the airline’s foreign registry. For purposes of the excise tax exemption, it negated the legal status of the buyer as an international carrier. The court held that without the Foreign Air Carrier Permit, the buyer could not be treated as an international carrier within the contemplation of Section 135(a), regardless of other documents suggesting foreign registration.
Refund Claims Require Strict Proof of Both Legal and Factual Entitlement
The ruling reinforces a recurring principle in Philippine tax litigation: a tax refund is treated in the nature of a tax exemption and is therefore construed strictly against the claimant. The taxpayer must prove both the legal basis and the factual basis for the refund through sufficient and competent evidence. Any well-founded doubt is fatal to the claim.
For taxpayers dealing with excise tax refunds on petroleum products sold to international carriers, this means that the supporting documents must be complete and directly responsive to the statutory exemption. General proof that the buyer is a foreign airline may not be enough. The court required proof that the buyer had the legal authority to operate as a foreign air carrier in the Philippines through the relevant Civil Aeronautics Board permit.
The practical lesson is clear: refund documentation should be collected before or at the time of the transaction, not reconstructed only after the refund claim is disputed. Petroleum companies, aviation fuel suppliers, and tax teams handling Section 135 transactions should secure and preserve Foreign Air Carrier Permits, delivery records, importation documents, sales invoices, proof of excise tax payment, and other supporting records that connect the imported fuel to the exempt sale.
The Commissioner’s Attempt to Deny the Refund Also Failed
The Commissioner argued that Section 135 could not support the taxpayer’s refund claim because the exemption supposedly belonged only to the international carriers. Since the petroleum importer remained the party directly liable for excise tax, the Commissioner maintained that the taxpayer could not invoke the exemption to recover the taxes paid.
The court disagreed and relied on Supreme Court doctrine involving the same type of excise tax issue. It emphasized the distinction between the statutory taxpayer and the party that merely bears the economic burden of the tax. International carriers purchasing petroleum products do not ordinarily manufacture or import those products. They may shoulder the tax cost if it is passed on to them commercially, but that does not make them the statutory taxpayers.
For excise taxes on petroleum products, the importer or manufacturer is the party legally liable for the tax. Therefore, when the law grants an exemption under Section 135 for petroleum products sold to international carriers, the exemption benefits the party legally liable to pay the tax: the importer or manufacturer. The court therefore held that the taxpayer, as statutory taxpayer, was the proper party to claim the refund or tax credit for qualifying transactions.
Final Outcome: Refund Affirmed, Additional Claim Denied
The court denied both motions for partial reconsideration and affirmed its earlier decision. The taxpayer remained entitled to the refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate in the reduced amount of P82,183,896.00 for excise taxes paid on Jet A-1 fuel imported in September and October 2020 and subsequently sold to qualifying international air carriers from October to December 2020.
At the same time, the taxpayer did not recover the additional P1,311,624.00 tied to fuel sold to airline buyers without the required Foreign Air Carrier Permits. The ruling therefore produced a balanced result: the court protected the taxpayer’s right to a refund as the statutory taxpayer, but insisted on strict compliance with documentary requirements for each transaction covered by the claim.
Practical Takeaways for Fuel Suppliers, Airlines, and Tax Teams
First, a petroleum importer or manufacturer may be the proper claimant for an excise tax refund on qualifying fuel sales to international carriers. The fact that the buyer may economically shoulder the tax does not necessarily transfer the legal right to claim the refund.
Second, the identity and regulatory status of the airline buyer matter. For purposes of Section 135(a), it is not enough to show that the buyer is a foreign airline in a general commercial sense. The taxpayer must be ready to prove that the airline qualifies as an international carrier under the applicable aviation regulatory framework.
Third, Foreign Air Carrier Permits should be treated as core refund evidence. Where the exemption depends on sales to international carriers, the absence of the permit may cause a specific sale to be excluded from the refund computation, even if the taxpayer has other documents suggesting that the buyer is foreign-registered.
Fourth, refund claims should be reviewed transaction by transaction. A taxpayer may win a substantial portion of the claim but lose specific amounts where documentation is incomplete. This is especially important for high-volume petroleum, aviation, and logistics businesses where a small documentary gap across several transactions can lead to significant disallowances.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in preparing, prosecuting, and defending tax refund and tax credit claims before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help review documentary requirements, identify weak points in refund evidence, prepare pleadings, and develop litigation strategy for excise tax, VAT, customs, and other tax disputes.
For petroleum companies, importers, airlines, logistics providers, and corporate taxpayers facing refund disallowances or tax assessments, early legal review can make the difference between a recoverable claim and a denied refund. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.