Milk-based powdered drinks classified by the FDA may be excluded from sweetened beverage tax, supporting a major excise tax refund or tax credit claim.
Manufacturers of powdered beverage products should not assume that the sweetened beverage tax automatically applies merely because a product is sweetened, powdered, or chocolate-flavored. Where the product is properly classified by the Food and Drug Administration as a dairy-based or milk product, the excise tax may be considered erroneously paid, and a refund or tax credit may be available if the taxpayer can prove both the product classification and the actual tax payments.
Background of the Refund Dispute
The taxpayer, a domestic manufacturer of food and beverage products, sought the refund of P1,266,599,459.91 in sweetened beverage tax allegedly paid on removals of MILO powdered chocolate malt milk drink products from May 1, 2018 to December 31, 2018. The products were registered with the FDA under Certificates of Product Registration covering several product names that included powdered milk drink, powdered choco malt milk drink, and related adult variants.
The dispute arose after the TRAIN Law introduced Section 150-B of the National Internal Revenue Code, imposing excise tax on sweetened beverages effective January 1, 2018. The taxpayer filed an administrative refund claim under Section 204(C) of the NIRC and later elevated the matter to the tax court after the claim was not granted. The Court in Division initially denied the refund, holding that the products fell within the sweetened beverage tax provisions and were not excluded as milk products. On appeal, the taxpayer challenged that ruling before the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc (CTA EB No. 2896).
The Core Issue: Sweetened Beverage or Excluded Milk Product?
The central tax question was whether the products were taxable sweetened beverages or excluded milk products under Section 150-B of the NIRC, as amended by the TRAIN Law. The Commissioner argued that the products could not be treated as flavoured fluid milk drinks because they were in powder form, not liquid form. The Commissioner also argued that allowing the exclusion would defeat the purpose of the sweetened beverage tax.
The taxpayer countered that the law itself excludes all milk products, including powdered milk and flavored milk, from the scope of the sweetened beverage tax. It relied heavily on the FDA product registrations, the Codex Alimentarius food category system, and testimonial evidence showing that the FDA-approved product names and categories reflected the products’ true nature as milk-based drinks.
The En Banc Ruling: The Refund Was Granted
The Court En Banc granted the petition, reversed the Court in Division, and ordered the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate in the amount of P1,266,599,459.91. The court held that the taxpayer sufficiently proved that the products were milk products excluded from the sweetened beverage tax, and that the excise taxes paid on those products were therefore erroneously collected.
A key part of the ruling was the treatment of Codex Stan 192-1995. The court rejected the view that the Codex food category descriptors became relevant only after a later Department of Health circular. It found that the Codex standards were already adopted for purposes of the sweetened beverage tax framework when the TRAIN Law and Revenue Regulations No. 20-2018 took effect. Otherwise, the statutory references to food category classifications would have been inoperative during the relevant period.
FDA Classification Carried Significant Weight
The court placed substantial importance on the Certificates of Product Registration issued by the FDA. These CPRs categorized the products as dairy-based drinks, flavored and/or fermented, and approved product names containing the term milk. For the court, this supported the conclusion that the FDA had determined the products to be milk products.
The testimony of a former FDA Director-General also mattered. The court noted that FDA approval of a product name is not a casual label choice. Under food labeling rules, a product name must indicate the true nature of the food and must not be false, misleading, or deceptive. Since the approved product names included milk, and there was no showing that the FDA failed to apply the relevant standards, the court treated the FDA action as entitled to the presumption of regularity.
Powder Form Did Not Defeat the Milk Product Exclusion
The Commissioner argued that the Codex category for flavoured fluid milk drinks referred only to liquid products. The court disagreed. It reasoned that the Codex description included all mixes and ready-to-drink milk-based drinks. The court further observed that the Codex category separately excluded cocoa-sugar mixtures under another food category. That specific exclusion indicated that mixes could include powdered forms; otherwise, there would have been no need to expressly exclude powdered cocoa-sugar mixtures.
The court also rejected the idea that the products were merely cocoa-sugar mixtures. The evidence showed that the products contained milk, malted barley, cocoa powder, and added sugar, with milk identified as the top ingredient by weight for the relevant products. The court found that products containing milk in addition to cocoa and sugar could not simply be treated as cocoa-sugar mixtures excluded from the flavoured milk category.
Documentary Proof of Payment Was Still Essential
The taxpayer did not win on classification alone. The court also examined whether the claimed amount was supported by documentary evidence. A court-commissioned independent certified public accountant reviewed payment forms, eFPS payment details, excise taxpayer removal declarations, official record books, liquidation reports, and related documents.
The court found that the taxpayer had available advance excise tax payments sufficient to cover the claimed excise tax. It also verified the removals of the products from the manufacturing facilities and toll manufacturers. Although there were discrepancies between the claimed volumes and certain records, the court ultimately used the supported volume reflected in the excise taxpayer removal declarations and sustained the claimed refundable amount of P1,266,599,459.91.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers
This ruling is important for food and beverage manufacturers because it shows that sweetened beverage tax exposure depends on product classification, not merely on the presence of sugar or the product’s powdered form. FDA registrations, approved product names, Codex classifications, product composition, and contemporaneous tax payment records can become decisive in refund litigation.
For taxpayers considering a sweetened beverage tax refund, the practical lesson is to build the case around both technical classification and accounting substantiation. The taxpayer must be prepared to prove what the product is, how the FDA classified it, how the statutory exclusion applies, how the excise tax was paid, and how the refund amount was computed. A legally sound classification argument may still fail if the claimed tax payments and removals are not adequately documented.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises and represents taxpayers in tax assessments, refund claims, excise tax disputes, customs controversies, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can assist in reviewing product classifications, evaluating refund feasibility, preparing administrative claims, organizing evidentiary support, and prosecuting refund or tax credit claims before the appropriate forum.
If your company paid sweetened beverage tax, excise tax, VAT, customs duties, or other national taxes that may have been erroneously assessed or collected, our Makati-based tax litigation team can help evaluate your remedies and litigation strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.