The CTA En Banc rejected the BIR appeal, limiting the taxpayer’s liability after finding prescription, valid export zero-rating, and withholding defenses.
Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should closely examine both prescription and the written basis of the assessment because the government cannot simply invoke the 10-year assessment period after the fact. Where the assessment notices fail to communicate the factual and legal basis for applying the extraordinary period, and the taxpayer can substantiate its reported transactions, deficiency VAT and withholding tax assessments may be cancelled even if the BIR later alleges substantial underdeclaration.
Background of the Tax Assessment Dispute
The dispute arose from a BIR audit of a domestic corporation for taxable year 2015. A Letter of Authority was issued on November 10, 2016 covering all internal revenue taxes for the period January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2015. After an informal conference and preliminary assessment process, the BIR issued a Formal Assessment Notice dated December 21, 2018 assessing deficiency income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, and withholding tax on compensation. The total assessment under the FAN was ₱19,298,153.56, which later increased under the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment to ₱21,301,082.49.
The taxpayer protested and elevated the case to the Court of Tax Appeals. The Division partially granted the taxpayer’s petition, cancelled the deficiency VAT and withholding tax on compensation assessments, and upheld only modified amounts for deficiency income tax and expanded withholding tax. The Commissioner appealed to the En Banc (CTA EB No. 2973), arguing that the cancelled assessments should be reinstated and that the taxpayer’s VAT, withholding, purchases, NOLCO, and MCIT positions were erroneous.
The Government’s Appeal Was Denied
The En Banc denied the Commissioner’s petition for lack of merit and affirmed the Division’s decision and resolution. The final result was that the taxpayer remained liable only for ₱1,686,035.63 in deficiency income tax and expanded withholding tax for taxable year 2015, inclusive of surcharge and deficiency interest computed until January 21, 2019, plus delinquency interest at 12% per annum from January 22, 2019 until full payment.
For taxpayers, the important point is not merely the reduced amount. The ruling demonstrates how a multimillion-peso assessment can fail when the BIR cannot overcome prescription, cannot show that the taxpayer was properly informed of the basis for the extraordinary 10-year period, or cannot rebut documentary proof supporting the taxpayer’s reported transactions.
Prescription: The 10-Year Assessment Period Does Not Apply Automatically
The Commissioner argued that the 10-year period under Section 222 of the Tax Code should apply because the taxpayer allegedly substantially underdeclared receipts subject to VAT and failed to withhold EWT and WTC. The En Banc acknowledged that, under the Supreme Court doctrine on substantial underdeclaration, an underdeclaration exceeding 30% may give rise to a prima facie presumption of falsity. However, that did not end the analysis.
The Court found that the taxpayer overcame the presumption through evidence showing that the questioned sales were export sales subject to VAT zero-rating. The Court also found that the assessment notices did not sufficiently inform the taxpayer that the BIR was invoking falsity or applying the extraordinary 10-year period. The PAN, FAN, and FDDA did not mention any allegation of falsity or any statement that the 10-year period would apply.
As a result, the ordinary three-year period controlled. The BIR’s right to assess deficiency VAT for the first to third quarters of 2015, and EWT and WTC for January to November 2015, had already prescribed. This is a practical defense point for taxpayers: the notice itself matters. It is not enough for the BIR to later argue substantial underdeclaration if the taxpayer was not properly informed of that theory in the assessment process.
Export Sales Were Properly Treated as VAT Zero-Rated
The Commissioner also argued that ₱66,351,051.41 in sales should have been subjected to VAT because the taxpayer allegedly failed to prove that the sales were zero-rated. The Court rejected this argument.
The taxpayer established that the sales were direct export sales to a buyer in Tokyo, Japan. The transactions were supported by commercial invoices, official receipts, bills of lading, passbooks, application and declaration for remittance, bank certification, and debit memo. The Court noted that the aggregate export sales figure matched the sales schedule and audited financial statements. Because the documentary requirements for export sales were satisfied, the deficiency VAT assessment was cancelled.
Payments to General Professional Partnerships Were Not Subject to EWT
The Commissioner challenged the taxpayer’s non-withholding on payments to two general professional partnerships. The Court held that the taxpayer sufficiently proved that the payees were GPPs. For one payee, the Articles of Partnership and official receipts reflected the same taxpayer identification number, which the Court considered sufficient despite differences in the registered name. For the other, the Articles of Partnership, official receipts, and a BIR ruling were traceable to the same GPP.
Accordingly, the income payments to those GPPs were not subject to expanded withholding tax. This part of the decision is useful for businesses paying professional partnerships: discrepancies in names may not be fatal where the taxpayer can establish identity and status through TINs, partnership documents, official receipts, and supporting BIR records.
Withholding Tax on Compensation Was Properly Cancelled
The Commissioner argued that the taxpayer still had deficiency withholding tax on compensation because the independent CPA allegedly did not consider the salaries and wages reported in the income tax return. The Court found the argument unpersuasive because the Division had made its own examination of the taxpayer’s ITR, audited financial statements, alphalist, monthly withholding tax returns, bank receipts, and eFPS confirmations.
The Court found that the taxpayer paid more than what was due, resulting in an overpayment of ₱11,002.93. There was therefore no basis to disallow compensation expense of ₱151,460.92 or subject the same to deficiency withholding tax on compensation.
Invoices Issued Before Authority to Print May Fail as Deduction Proof
The Commissioner partly succeeded on one substantiation point. The Court agreed that purchases from one supplier amounting to ₱2,006,216.00 were not properly substantiated because the sales invoices were issued before the supplier’s authority to print took effect. The absence of the seller’s signature was not fatal because Section 237 of the Tax Code did not require the issuer’s signature on the invoice. However, issuance before the ATP validity period meant the invoices were not considered properly registered with the BIR and had no probative value for claiming deductions.
Even so, this did not change the final deficiency income tax computation. The increase in unsubstantiated purchases was still absorbed by the taxpayer’s available NOLCO from taxable year 2012. The Court also affirmed that the taxpayer’s claimed NOLCO and MCIT benefits for taxable year 2015 were validly disallowed because the taxpayer’s operations did not result in a net loss and its regular income tax due was higher than MCIT.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and CFOs
This ruling gives taxpayers several concrete audit defense lessons. First, always check prescription by tax type and by taxable period. Quarterly VAT and monthly withholding taxes may prescribe differently from annual income tax issues. Second, if the BIR invokes falsity or the 10-year assessment period, verify whether that theory was clearly communicated in the assessment notices. Third, export sales must be supported not only by invoices but also by shipping documents and proof of foreign currency payment. Fourth, payments to professional partnerships should be backed by documents proving GPP status and identity. Fifth, supplier invoices should be reviewed for compliance with authority-to-print requirements, especially where deductions are material.
For businesses under audit, this decision reinforces that tax litigation is often won through disciplined documentation and procedural scrutiny. A taxpayer may not need to defeat every BIR adjustment if prescription, notice defects, substantiation, and computation issues substantially reduce or cancel the assessment.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, business owners, CFOs, and corporate counsel in evaluating BIR assessments, preparing administrative protests, and litigating tax disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can review assessment notices for prescription, due process defects, VAT zero-rating documentation, withholding tax exposure, and substantiation risks before a case reaches a critical deadline.
If your company has received a PAN, FAN, FDDA, or collection notice, early legal review can determine whether the assessment is valid, partially contestable, or vulnerable to cancellation. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.