A withholding agent may file an FWT refund claim, but the refund failed because the franchise fee agreement was not properly authenticated as evidence.
Philippine companies claiming a refund of final withholding tax on cross-border royalty or franchise fee payments must prove not only that the tax was paid on time and that the refund claim was timely filed, but also that the contractual basis for the alleged erroneous payment is admissible and credible evidence. A refund claim may fail even where the taxpayer presents invoices, withholding tax returns, accounting entries, and an independent accountant’s report, if the agreement relied upon to justify the reversal of the income payment is treated as an unauthenticated private document.
Background: A Final Withholding Tax Refund Claim on Reversed Franchise Fees
The taxpayer, a domestic corporation also known as KONE Philippines, was engaged in the business of manufacturing, selling, installing, servicing, maintaining, and modernizing elevators, escalators, and related machinery and equipment. It claimed that it had entered into a franchise fee arrangement with its foreign parent company, under which it was granted the right to use KONE technology, know-how, show-how, trademarks, and IT systems for its Philippine business.
Under the arrangement described in the case, the Philippine company was to pay franchise fees computed under the arm’s length principle, based on a percentage of forecasted annual net sales. The fees were billed quarterly, subject to year-end adjustment once actual sales figures became available. The taxpayer asserted that if its actual performance fell below the arm’s length level, the foreign company would credit back the franchise fee and even pay a transfer pricing compensation amount.
For the first quarter of calendar year 2020, the foreign company issued a quarterly invoice imposing a franchise fee of Php22,828,000.00. The taxpayer paid the amount and remitted final withholding tax of Php5,707,000.00, using a 25% rate which the taxpayer stated was based on the Finland-Philippines tax treaty. Due to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, the taxpayer’s actual performance allegedly fell below the forecasted amount. The foreign company later issued a credit invoice dated January 22, 2021, crediting back the franchise fee and paying compensation to the taxpayer.
Because the franchise fee payment was allegedly reversed, the taxpayer filed an administrative claim for refund or tax credit with the BIR on May 25, 2022, and later filed a judicial claim before the Court of Tax Appeals on June 8, 2022 (CTA Case No. 10879). The taxpayer sought recovery of Php5,707,000.00 in final withholding tax for the first quarter of 2020.
The Taxpayer Won on Timeliness and Standing, But Lost on Proof
The Court found that the taxpayer timely filed both its administrative and judicial claims. The final withholding tax was paid on June 8, 2020. Counting two years from that date, the taxpayer had until June 8, 2022 to file the necessary claims. The administrative claim filed on May 25, 2022 and the judicial claim filed on June 8, 2022 were therefore within the two-year prescriptive period under Sections 204(C) and 229 of the National Internal Revenue Code.
The Court also rejected the Commissioner’s argument that the taxpayer had no legal standing because the real taxpayer was the foreign income recipient. Applying Supreme Court jurisprudence, the Court recognized that a withholding agent may file a refund claim where the principal taxpayer does not do so. The withholding agent is treated as a party with sufficient legal interest because it is personally liable for the tax required to be withheld, as well as for possible deficiency assessments, surcharges, and penalties if the withholding is later found insufficient.
However, the Court emphasized an important qualification: if a withholding agent obtains a refund of taxes withheld from the income of a foreign payee, it must return or remit the recovered amount to the principal taxpayer. Otherwise, the withholding agent would be unjustly enriched at the expense of the person from whom the tax was actually withheld.
Why the Refund Was Denied
The decisive issue was evidentiary. The taxpayer’s refund theory depended on the franchise fee agreement. That agreement was the basis for the quarterly billing, the year-end adjustment, the alleged reversal of the franchise fee, and the taxpayer’s argument that the income payment to the foreign company had effectively been cancelled.
The Court found that the agreement was a private document. It had not been notarized or consularized. For a private document to be admitted and given evidentiary weight, it must be properly authenticated under the Rules on Evidence. While the taxpayer’s witness identified the signature of the taxpayer’s own former country manager, the witness failed to authenticate the signature of the person who supposedly signed on behalf of the foreign company.
The Court noted that the signature page contained two signatures: one for the taxpayer and another for the foreign company. However, the name and position of the foreign company’s signatory were not indicated on the agreement. During cross-examination, the taxpayer’s witness referred to a person identified as Robert, allegedly the foreign company’s former country manager, as the signatory for the foreign company. But the witness did not actually authenticate Robert’s signature. The taxpayer also did not present Robert or another competent witness who could authenticate that signature.
Because the agreement was not properly authenticated, the Court held that it lost probative value. The Court further observed that the result could have been different had the agreement been notarized, since notarization converts a private document into a public document and gives it a prima facie presumption of authenticity and due execution. In light of this evidentiary failure, the Court found it unnecessary to address the other arguments raised by the parties, including the Commissioner’s contentions regarding the alleged technology transfer agreement issues under the Intellectual Property Code.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Withholding Agents
This decision is a warning for Philippine companies making cross-border payments to foreign affiliates, especially royalty, franchise fee, technical service, licensing, intellectual property, or transfer pricing-related payments. A taxpayer seeking a refund of final withholding tax must prove more than the existence of payment and later reversal. It must present competent evidence showing why the tax was erroneously or illegally collected.
For companies with intercompany agreements signed abroad, the formalities matter. If the agreement will later be used in a Philippine tax refund case, assessment protest, transfer pricing defense, or withholding tax dispute, the company should consider ensuring that the document is notarized, consularized where appropriate, or otherwise supported by proper authentication evidence. The signatories should be identifiable, their authority should be documented, and a competent witness should be available to authenticate the execution of the agreement if the case reaches litigation.
The ruling also shows that an independent certified public accountant’s report, invoices, BIR Form 1601-FQ, eFPS payment details, SAP entries, and credit invoices may not be enough if the foundational contract is not given evidentiary weight. In refund litigation, the Court examines the chain of proof strictly. The taxpayer must establish the legal basis of the payment, the reason it became erroneous, and the connection between the payment, withholding, reversal, and refund claim.
At the same time, the decision is useful for withholding agents because it confirms that they may have standing to file refund claims involving taxes withheld from foreign payees. But standing does not guarantee recovery. The taxpayer still bears the burden of proving entitlement to the refund, and tax refunds remain in the nature of tax exemptions that are construed strictly against the claimant.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists Philippine companies, foreign investors, importers, and withholding agents in tax refund claims, BIR disputes, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether a refund claim is timely, whether the documentary evidence is sufficient, whether intercompany agreements and foreign documents are properly authenticated, and whether the taxpayer’s litigation theory can withstand scrutiny before the Court.
For companies dealing with final withholding tax refunds, royalty or franchise fee reversals, tax treaty-based withholding, transfer pricing adjustments, or BIR refund denials, early legal review can make the difference between a recoverable claim and a dismissed case. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax refund strategy, assessment defense, and Court of Tax Appeals representation.