Tax Orders of Payment were not treated as local tax assessments, allowing the taxpayer’s refund claim under Section 196 to proceed to trial.

Businesses challenging local business tax payments should not automatically treat every tax order of payment as a deficiency assessment that triggers the protest procedure under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. Where the local government document does not require payment of deficiency taxes, a taxpayer seeking refund or tax credit may still rely on the two-year remedy under Section 196, provided the action is timely filed and the claim is properly proven on the merits.

Background: A Local Business Tax Refund Dispute Reaches the Tax Court

The dispute involved a taxpayer that questioned local business tax payments for taxable years 2022 and 2023 before the Municipality of Pagbilao, Quezon. The taxpayer sought relief in the form of a refund or issuance of a tax credit, while the municipal officials argued that the taxpayer failed to follow the proper local tax protest procedure.

The case reached the Court of Tax Appeals after the Regional Trial Court in Lucena City issued an order dated June 25, 2024. In its earlier decision, the tax court reversed and set aside that RTC order and remanded the case for further proceedings on the merits, specifically for determination of the amount of excess local business tax, if any, that should be refunded or credited to the taxpayer (CTA AC No. 331).

The Municipality’s Argument: Tax Orders of Payment Should Be Treated as Assessments

The municipality and its officials moved for reconsideration. Their core position was that the 2022 and 2023 Tax Orders of Payment substantially informed the taxpayer of the factual and legal basis for the local business tax imposed. On that theory, the municipality argued that the Tax Orders of Payment should be treated as notices of assessment under Section 195 of the Local Government Code.

This distinction mattered because Section 195 governs protests of local tax assessments. If the Tax Orders of Payment were valid assessment notices, the taxpayer would have been required to comply with the protest mechanism under that provision. The municipality argued that the taxpayer failed to comply with the alleged twin requirements of Section 195, making the refund claim baseless.

The Taxpayer’s Position: The Claim Was a Refund Case Under Section 196

The taxpayer opposed the motion for reconsideration and maintained that the Tax Orders of Payment were not assessments. Its position was that the documents could not be considered assessment notices even if they contained factual and legal bases, because they did not require payment of deficiency taxes.

Because the taxpayer was not contesting a deficiency assessment, it argued that Section 195 did not apply. Instead, the taxpayer relied on Section 196 of the Local Government Code, which governs claims for refund or credit of local taxes erroneously or illegally collected. The taxpayer also reiterated that it filed its complaint within the two-year period under Section 196.

The Ruling: Reconsideration Denied, Remand to the RTC Maintained

The tax court denied the municipality’s motion for reconsideration. It held that the arguments raised by the municipality were essentially the same arguments already considered and rejected in the earlier decision. The municipality did not present any new argument or novel issue that would justify reconsidering or departing from the prior ruling.

The earlier ruling therefore remained in place. The tax court had already found that the 2022 and 2023 Tax Orders of Payment were not notices of assessment contemplated under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. It also held that the taxpayer’s remedy lay under Section 196 and that the taxpayer timely availed itself of that remedy.

Importantly, the tax court did not finally determine the amount refundable or creditable. Instead, it maintained the remand to the Regional Trial Court, Branch 58, Lucena City, for further proceedings on the merits. The reason was practical and procedural: no trial on the merits had yet been conducted, and neither party had presented evidence. The refund or tax credit claim still had to be proven before the trial court.

Why the Difference Between Section 195 and Section 196 Matters

For companies paying local business tax, this ruling highlights a critical procedural distinction. Section 195 applies when a taxpayer is protesting a local tax assessment. Section 196 applies when a taxpayer seeks refund or credit of local taxes alleged to have been erroneously or illegally collected.

The classification of a local government document can determine the applicable deadline, remedy, and litigation strategy. A document labeled as a Tax Order of Payment is not automatically a notice of assessment. The substance of the document matters. If it does not demand deficiency taxes and functions instead as a payment document, the taxpayer may have a viable argument that the refund route under Section 196 applies.

At the same time, the ruling should not be read as an automatic victory for taxpayers in all local business tax refund cases. The taxpayer here survived the municipality’s procedural attack, but the case was still remanded for trial. The taxpayer must still establish, through evidence, that there was an excess local business tax payment and that the amount claimed should be refunded or credited.

Practical Takeaways for CFOs, Tax Managers, and Local Taxpayers

First, companies should carefully review whether a local government issuance is truly a notice of assessment or merely a tax order, billing, computation, or payment document. The answer may determine whether the proper remedy is a protest under Section 195 or a refund or credit claim under Section 196.

Second, taxpayers should not delay. Even where Section 196 applies, the claim must be pursued within the applicable two-year period. A local tax refund case can be lost not only on the merits but also through the use of the wrong remedy or missed deadlines.

Third, taxpayers should preserve evidence from the beginning. Proof of payment, the underlying local tax computation, the taxpayer’s gross receipts or taxable base, correspondence with the local treasurer, and any relevant ordinances or local revenue issuances may become essential once the case proceeds to trial.

Fourth, local government units should ensure that assessment documents clearly comply with the requirements of the Local Government Code. If the document is intended to be a formal assessment, it should be drafted and served as such. Ambiguity may allow the taxpayer to argue that the Section 195 protest procedure was never triggered.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Local tax disputes often turn on procedural classification, deadlines, and documentary proof. A business may have a valid substantive position but still lose if it files the wrong remedy, misses a deadline, or fails to prepare the evidentiary record needed for trial.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, property owners, importers, and corporate taxpayers in disputes involving local business tax, real property tax, national internal revenue taxes, customs matters, refunds, assessments, and cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation team can help evaluate whether a local tax issuance should be protested, refunded, credited, or litigated, and can represent clients through administrative proceedings, trial, and appeal.

For assistance with a local business tax refund, local tax assessment, or Court of Tax Appeals dispute, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco’s tax litigation practice.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *