Taxpayer’s motion for reconsideration was denied after failing to prove VAT zero-rated sales for a refund or tax credit claim covering 2019 services.

Taxpayers seeking VAT refunds or tax credits must be ready to prove, with competent evidence, every element of their claimed zero-rated sales. A motion for reconsideration will not cure evidentiary gaps if the taxpayer still cannot establish the legal and factual basis for treating its sales as VAT zero-rated or effectively zero-rated.

Background of the VAT Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a taxpayer’s claim for value-added tax refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate covering the third and fourth quarters of taxable year 2019. The claim was tied to alleged zero-rated sales of services rendered to entities connected with renewable energy projects, including services allegedly rendered to Philippine Geothermal Production Company and Energy Development Corporation.

In the earlier decision, the Court denied the taxpayer’s petition for review for lack of merit. In its February 6, 2026 resolution, the Court addressed the taxpayer’s motion for reconsideration in the same case (CTA Case No. 10752). The taxpayer argued that tax refund cases are civil in nature, that the applicable quantum of proof is only preponderance of evidence, and that testimonial evidence and the parties’ conduct were sufficient to prove the existence of contracts and zero-rated sales for the relevant quarters.

Why the Taxpayer’s Motion for Reconsideration Was Denied

The Court denied the motion for reconsideration because the taxpayer failed to present any new or significant ground that would justify modifying or overturning the earlier decision. The Court found that the issues raised in the motion had already been considered and resolved when the petition for review was denied.

The central evidentiary problem remained the same: the taxpayer failed to establish its zero-rated sales for the third and fourth quarters of taxable year 2019. The earlier ruling found that the taxpayer did not prove the Board of Investments registration of Philippine Geothermal Production Company as a renewable energy developer. The Court also found that the taxpayer failed to substantiate its sales of services to Energy Development Corporation and failed to prove the BOI registration for all projects with that customer. Because of those gaps, the claim for VAT zero-rating on the services rendered to those entities was disallowed.

Preponderance of Evidence Still Requires Competent Proof

The taxpayer emphasized that refund claims are civil in nature and should only require proof by preponderance of evidence. The Court did not reject that standard. Instead, it clarified that it had evaluated all the facts, circumstances, and evidence on record, including the testimony offered by the taxpayer’s witness, in determining whether the taxpayer satisfied that standard.

This distinction is important for businesses preparing VAT refund claims. Preponderance of evidence does not mean that a taxpayer can rely on general testimony, incomplete contracts, or assumptions from business conduct when the claim requires specific documentary substantiation. A taxpayer must still show that the sales qualify for zero-rating under the applicable law and regulations, that the customers or projects meet the relevant statutory or regulatory requirements, and that the invoices and supporting documents correspond to the claimed transactions.

Tax Refunds Remain Strictly Construed Against the Taxpayer

The Court reiterated the settled rule that tax refund claims partake of the nature of tax exemptions. For that reason, the rules governing refunds are construed strictly against the taxpayer and liberally in favor of the taxing authority. This principle was decisive because the taxpayer was asking the government to return taxes or issue a tax credit, not merely defending against an assessment.

For CFOs and tax managers, the ruling is a reminder that the burden in VAT refund litigation is front-loaded. The taxpayer must build the record before and during trial. Once the Court finds that the taxpayer failed to prove zero-rated sales, a motion for reconsideration will generally fail unless it identifies a serious error, a material overlooked fact, or a new argument that genuinely changes the result.

Why Renewable Energy-Related Sales Require Careful Documentation

Businesses providing services to renewable energy developers often assume that transactions connected with renewable energy projects are automatically zero-rated. This ruling shows the risk of that assumption. The taxpayer still has to prove the customer’s qualifying status, the relevant registration or entitlement, the connection of the services to the qualified project, and the documentary trail supporting each sale.

Where BOI registration, project registration, service contracts, invoices, and proof of actual rendition of services are incomplete or inconsistent, the VAT refund claim becomes vulnerable. Testimony may help explain the transaction, but it will rarely substitute for the primary documents needed to establish the statutory basis for zero-rating.

Practical Takeaways for VAT Refund and Tax Credit Claims

Taxpayers preparing VAT refund or tax credit claims should treat the claim as a litigation file from the beginning. The company should preserve the customer’s registration documents, renewable energy project approvals, contracts, purchase orders, invoices, official receipts where applicable, accounting schedules, and proof that the services were actually rendered during the period covered by the claim.

Tax teams should also verify whether the invoices comply with Section 113 of the National Internal Revenue Code and the applicable VAT regulations, including the invoicing rules relied upon by the Commissioner in opposing the claim. Even where the Court’s resolution focused on failure to prove zero-rated sales, invoicing compliance remains a recurring issue in VAT refund cases and should be checked before the claim is filed.

Finally, taxpayers should not wait until appeal or reconsideration to complete the evidentiary record. A motion for reconsideration is not a second trial. If the original case record does not prove the zero-rated nature of the sales, the taxpayer may have little room to recover after an adverse decision.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, and corporate groups in evaluating VAT refund claims, preparing documentary support, responding to BIR challenges, and litigating tax disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help determine whether a refund claim is ready for filing, whether the evidentiary record is strong enough for trial, and how to address risks involving zero-rated sales, renewable energy transactions, and tax credit claims.

For assistance with a VAT refund, tax credit certificate claim, BIR assessment, or Court of Tax Appeals case, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco for a focused review of your tax dispute.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *