A taxpayer’s local business tax refund claim may proceed when no deficiency assessment was issued and Section 196’s two-year period was met.
Businesses seeking refunds of excessive local business taxes should not be forced into the shorter protest route for deficiency assessments when the city merely issued a statement of account for permit renewal. For taxpayers that paid local taxes first and later discovered that the amount collected may have exceeded what the local government could lawfully impose, the ruling confirms that the refund remedy under Section 196 of the Local Government Code remains available if both the administrative and judicial claims are filed within the two-year period.
Background of the Local Business Tax Dispute
The taxpayer is a corporation engaged in freight forwarding, transporting, conveying, and carrying goods, merchandise, products, and cargoes by land, sea, and air to destinations outside the Philippines. In January 2019, it renewed its business permit and received a statement of account from the city government requiring payment of local business tax for calendar year 2019. The taxpayer paid the assessed local business tax in four quarterly installments totaling P20,004,333.20.
The taxpayer later filed a written administrative claim for refund with the city treasurer on January 15, 2021, alleging that local business tax had been excessively and erroneously collected. Without waiting for action on that administrative claim, and with the two-year refund period about to expire, the taxpayer filed a judicial claim before the Regional Trial Court on January 18, 2021. The trial court dismissed the complaint, treating the case as an untimely protest against an assessment rather than a refund action. The dispute reached the Court of Tax Appeals on appeal (Case No. AC-337).
The Core Issue: Refund Claim or Protest Against Assessment?
The city treasurer argued that the statement of account for the 2019 business permit renewal was already a notice of assessment. On that theory, the taxpayer should have filed a protest within 60 days under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. Because the taxpayer instead filed its refund claim in 2021, the city treasurer claimed that the assessment had become final, executory, and unappealable.
The taxpayer disagreed. It argued that it was not protesting a deficiency tax assessment. Rather, it was seeking the return of local business taxes already paid, on the ground that the city allegedly used gross sales or receipts figures and revenue inclusions that resulted in excessive local business tax. The distinction mattered because Section 195 and Section 196 impose different procedural routes and deadlines.
Why the Statement of Account Was Not a Deficiency Tax Assessment
The Court held that the taxpayer used the correct remedy under Section 196 of the Local Government Code. Section 195 applies when the local treasurer or an authorized representative finds that the correct taxes, fees, or charges have not been paid and issues a notice of assessment stating the nature of the tax, the amount of deficiency, and the applicable surcharges, interests, and penalties.
That was not what happened here. The statement of account issued for the taxpayer’s business permit renewal did not qualify as a notice of assessment for a deficiency local business tax. It was issued as part of the city’s ordinary power to impose and collect business taxes, not because the local treasurer had found that the taxpayer had failed to pay the correct tax. Since there was no deficiency assessment, the taxpayer was not required to file a Section 195 protest within 60 days.
The Court relied on settled doctrine distinguishing local tax assessment protests from local tax refund claims. A protest under Section 195 is the remedy when the taxpayer receives a deficiency assessment and contests the local treasurer’s demand for additional payment. A refund claim under Section 196 is the remedy when the taxpayer has already paid the tax, fee, or charge and seeks recovery because the amount was allegedly erroneously or illegally collected.
The Two-Year Period for Local Tax Refunds Controlled
Because the claim was governed by Section 196, the taxpayer had to file a written claim for refund with the local treasurer before maintaining a court action. The court action also had to be brought within two years from payment of the tax, fee, or charge, or from the date the taxpayer became entitled to the refund or credit.
The taxpayer paid the first quarterly installment on January 19, 2019. The Court observed that, even using the earliest payment date, the two-year period would end on January 19, 2021. The taxpayer filed the administrative refund claim on January 15, 2021 and the judicial claim on January 18, 2021. Both were therefore timely under Section 196.
What the Court Ultimately Decided
The taxpayer did not yet receive a final refund award. Instead, the Court granted the petition, reversed and set aside the trial court’s dismissal order, and remanded the case to the trial court for continuation of proceedings, reception of evidence, and determination of the amount of local business tax refundable, if any.
This is important. The ruling did not automatically decide that the taxpayer was entitled to recover the full alleged excess amount. It decided the threshold procedural issue: the trial court had jurisdiction because the taxpayer timely pursued a Section 196 refund claim, and the case should proceed to trial on the merits.
Practical Takeaways for Businesses Paying Local Business Taxes
For corporations, logistics companies, contractors, retailers, service providers, and other businesses paying local business taxes, the ruling is a reminder to carefully classify the local tax dispute before choosing a remedy. If the local treasurer issues a true deficiency assessment stating the unpaid tax, deficiency amount, penalties, surcharge, and interest, the taxpayer must act quickly under Section 195. Missing the protest and appeal deadlines can make the assessment final and unappealable.
However, when the business has already paid local business tax and later discovers that the city may have used an incorrect tax base, included exempt revenues, misclassified the business, applied the wrong rate, or otherwise collected more than what the law authorizes, the appropriate remedy may be a Section 196 refund claim. In that situation, the taxpayer must file a written claim with the local treasurer and ensure that the judicial action is filed within the two-year prescriptive period.
The ruling also cautions trial courts and local treasurers against treating every refund case as a disguised assessment protest. A taxpayer must be allowed to explain why the tax already paid was allegedly excessive or erroneous. Those allegations are part of proving a refund claim; they do not automatically convert the case into a belated protest under Section 195.
Why Early Review of Local Business Tax Computations Matters
Many local business tax disputes arise during business permit renewal, when companies pay under time pressure to avoid interruption of operations. Because payments may be made quarterly and the two-year period may run from payment dates, businesses should review statements of account, official receipts, gross receipts bases, local tax classifications, exemptions, situs rules, and revenue inclusions as soon as possible.
Waiting until the end of the two-year period creates procedural risk. Even when a refund claim is legally proper, a taxpayer may still lose if it fails to file the administrative claim and court action on time, or if it cannot prove the factual basis for the alleged excess collection.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in evaluating local business tax assessments, refund claims, deficiency tax protests, and litigation before the Regional Trial Courts and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help determine whether the proper remedy is a protest, refund claim, appeal, or other local tax action; compute and preserve applicable deadlines; prepare administrative filings; and build the evidence needed to prove erroneous or excessive collection.
For businesses facing local business tax issues, deficiency assessments, or refund disputes with city or municipal treasurers, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.