Clark Freeport PAGCOR licensees remain under the 5% gross income tax regime, not the 5% franchise tax imposed by RMC No. 32-2022.

PAGCOR licensees operating inside Clark Freeport should not automatically be shifted from the 5% gross income tax regime to the 5% franchise tax merely because their revenues come from gaming operations. For registered enterprises in ecozones and freeports, the decision reinforces that the BIR cannot use a revenue memorandum circular to override statutory incentives granted under the Bases Conversion and Development Act and related freeport laws.

Background: A BIR Circular Changed the Tax Treatment of Freeport Gaming Revenues

The dispute arose after the BIR issued Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 32-2022, which clarified the tax treatment of PAGCOR, its licensees, and its contractees. For PAGCOR licensees located in ecozones or freeports, the circular stated that income from gaming operations would not be subject to the 5% gross income tax, income tax holiday, or regular corporate income tax, but would instead remain subject to the 5% franchise tax under the PAGCOR Charter.

The taxpayers were corporations registered in the Philippines and operating in the Clark Freeport Zone. They held Certificates of Registration and Tax Exemption from the Clark Development Corporation granting them the incentive to pay 5% tax on gross income earned in lieu of national and local taxes. After the issuance of the circular and related BIR reminders, the taxpayers challenged the BIR’s position before the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA EB No. 2975).

The BIR’s Position: Gaming Income Must Pay the 5% Franchise Tax

The Commissioner argued that the Court of Tax Appeals had no jurisdiction because petitions for certiorari and prohibition were not within the enumerated cases under the CTA law. The BIR also maintained that the circular was merely interpretative, issued under the Commissioner’s authority to implement internal revenue laws.

On the merits, the BIR argued that the 5% franchise tax under the PAGCOR Charter applied to gaming revenues of PAGCOR licensees. In the BIR’s view, there was no conflict between the PAGCOR Charter and the Clark Freeport tax regime because the franchise tax applied to the privilege of operating casinos, while the 5% gross income tax applied to registered business activities inside the freeport. The BIR also contended that imposing the 5% franchise tax would not amount to double taxation.

The Taxpayers’ Position: Freeport Incentives Cannot Be Removed by Circular

The taxpayers countered that they were registered Clark Freeport enterprises entitled to the 5% gross income tax regime in lieu of national and local taxes. They argued that requiring them to pay the 5% franchise tax, whether in addition to or in replacement of the 5% gross income tax, would effectively amend or repeal the statutory incentives granted to registered freeport enterprises.

The taxpayers also argued that RMC No. 32-2022 was invalid because it imposed a tax treatment inconsistent with law and jurisprudence. Their position was that a revenue memorandum circular may interpret the law, but it cannot create a new tax burden or carve out an exception not found in the statute governing freeport enterprises.

The Court’s Ruling: The Tax Court May Review the Validity of Revenue Issuances

The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc first held that the Court in Division had jurisdiction to take cognizance of the taxpayers’ challenge. Citing Supreme Court rulings, the Court explained that the tax court may directly review the constitutionality or validity of tax laws, regulations, and administrative issuances such as revenue memorandum circulars, revenue orders, and rulings.

This is important for taxpayers because it confirms that a taxpayer does not always have to wait for a full-blown assessment before questioning the validity of a tax regulation or administrative issuance. Where the challenge is directed against the validity of a tax issuance that affects the taxpayer’s legal obligations, the Court of Tax Appeals may be the proper forum.

PAGCOR’s Tax Exemption Extends to Licensees, But Freeport Rules Still Matter

The Court recognized that under the PAGCOR Charter and Supreme Court jurisprudence, PAGCOR’s tax exemption and the 5% franchise tax regime may extend to its licensees and contractees for income connected with gaming operations. The Court discussed the doctrinal rulings stating that PAGCOR licensees are generally liable to pay the 5% franchise tax on gaming income in lieu of other taxes.

However, the Court did not stop there. The taxpayers were not ordinary PAGCOR licensees operating outside a special tax zone. They were registered enterprises within the Clark Freeport Zone, and their tax incentives were governed by the Bases Conversion and Development Act, as amended, and related rules implementing the freeport regime.

Why the 5% Gross Income Tax Prevailed for Clark Freeport Enterprises

The Court held that entities located within the Clark Freeport Zone enjoy exemption from national and local taxes, subject to the 5% tax on gross income earned by registered business enterprises within the freeport. The Court noted that the taxpayers’ Certificates of Registration and Tax Exemption confirmed their entitlement to pay 5% tax on gross income earned in lieu of national and local taxes.

As between the PAGCOR Charter’s general rule for gaming licensees and the BCDA framework governing Clark Freeport enterprises, the Court treated the freeport incentive law as the more specific rule for enterprises located within the zone. The Court emphasized that the BCDA amendments did not exclude PAGCOR licensees from the incentives enjoyed by other registered businesses in the freeport.

The Court also relied on the purpose of the freeport amendments: to provide uniform tax incentives to registered business enterprises located in ecozones and freeports. Applying the 5% franchise tax only to PAGCOR licensees within the Clark Freeport Zone, while other registered freeport enterprises continued under the 5% gross income tax regime, would defeat that uniformity.

The Invalid Portion of RMC No. 32-2022

The Court affirmed the nullification of the portion of RMC No. 32-2022 stating that income from gaming operations of PAGCOR licensees located in ecozones or freeports shall not be subject to the 5% gross income tax, income tax holiday, or corporate income tax, but shall remain subject to the 5% franchise tax.

For the Court, the BIR acted with grave abuse of discretion when it inserted the 5% franchise tax as the applicable tax on PAGCOR licensees within special economic zones, despite the statutory freeport incentive regime. The petition filed by the BIR was denied, and the prior amended decision and resolution were affirmed.

Practical Takeaways for PAGCOR Licensees, Freeport Locators, and Tax Managers

First, PAGCOR licensees located in ecozones or freeports should closely review whether their income is covered by their registered activity and by their Certificate of Registration and Tax Exemption. The ruling is especially relevant for Clark Freeport enterprises that have been granted the 5% gross income tax incentive in lieu of national and local taxes.

Second, BIR circulars cannot amend statutory tax incentives. A revenue memorandum circular may clarify the BIR’s interpretation of the law, but it cannot impose a tax treatment that is inconsistent with the governing statute or with the incentives granted to registered enterprises.

Third, taxpayers affected by a revenue issuance may have a direct remedy before the Court of Tax Appeals when the dispute concerns the validity of a tax regulation or administrative issuance. This can be critical where immediate compliance would expose the business to substantial tax costs, reporting changes, or collection risk.

Fourth, gaming operators and freeport locators should not assume that all gaming revenues are treated alike. The applicable tax regime may depend on where the enterprise is located, what incentives have been granted, and whether the income arises from registered activities covered by the relevant investment promotion authority.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, gaming-related businesses, freeport locators, and corporate groups in disputes involving BIR assessments, revenue issuances, tax incentives, collection actions, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether a BIR position is consistent with the governing statute, prepare administrative protests, seek injunctive relief where warranted, and litigate complex tax disputes before the CTA.

If your company is facing a BIR assessment, a disputed tax incentive issue, or a revenue issuance that materially affects your operations, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *