Renewable energy developers cannot recover VAT from the BIR when purchases were legally zero-rated; their remedy may be against suppliers.

Renewable energy developers seeking input VAT refunds must first determine whether their purchases were legally zero-rated in the first place, because VAT wrongly charged by suppliers may not be refundable from the government. For renewable energy businesses, exporters, and biofuel manufacturers, the ruling is a warning that a large VAT refund claim can fail even when invoices show VAT was passed on, if the law treats the underlying purchases as zero-rated transactions.

Background: A Biodiesel Exporter Claimed Over Php256 Million in Input VAT

The taxpayer was a Philippine corporation registered with the Department of Energy as a renewable energy developer of biomass resources and accredited as a biodiesel manufacturer. It was also registered with the Board of Investments as a new export producer of coconut methyl ester or coco-diesel, with by-products such as crude glycerin, soap noodles, and toilet soaps.

For calendar year 2018, the taxpayer filed an administrative VAT refund claim with the BIR for alleged excess and unutilized input VAT of Php257,150,311.51. After the BIR denied the claim for lack of factual and legal basis, the taxpayer filed a judicial claim, later reduced to Php256,185,384.47. The Court in Division denied the claim, and the taxpayer elevated the case to the Court En Banc (CTA EB No. 3023).

The Core Issue: Are Renewable Energy Purchases Zero-Rated Even for Non-Power Applications?

The taxpayer argued that it was engaged in non-power applications because it produced biodiesel, not electricity. It maintained that the third paragraph of Section 15(g) of Republic Act No. 9513, which refers to the whole process of exploring and developing renewable energy sources up to conversion into power, should apply only to power applications and not to its biodiesel operations.

The Court En Banc rejected that argument. It held that Section 15 of Republic Act No. 9513 grants incentives to renewable energy developers for both power and non-power applications. The Court emphasized the statutory rule that when the law does not distinguish, courts should not distinguish. Although the disputed paragraph contains the phrase up to conversion into power, the Court found that the phrase did not exclude non-power applications from the incentive. Instead, it extended the coverage of zero-rating for power applications while preserving the broader coverage for renewable energy development activities.

Why the VAT Refund Was Denied

The taxpayer lost because most of the input VAT it claimed related to purchases that should have been zero-rated under the Renewable Energy Act. The Court affirmed the disallowance of Php262,022,961.53 in input VAT because the purchases were covered by zero-rating entitlement. In practical terms, if a transaction should have been zero-rated, the buyer generally should not have paid VAT in the first place, and the buyer cannot convert the supplier’s mistake into a refund claim against the government.

The Court also held that the taxpayer was not the proper party to claim a refund for VAT erroneously passed on by suppliers. Relying on Supreme Court rulings involving zero-rated purchases, including cases concerning ecozone enterprises and renewable energy developers, the Court explained that VAT remains an indirect tax. The seller is the statutory taxpayer responsible for reporting and remitting VAT. If the seller wrongly shifts VAT to a buyer whose purchases are legally zero-rated, the buyer’s recourse is generally reimbursement from the supplier, not a Section 112 VAT refund from the BIR.

Photocopies Helped, But Not Enough to Save the Claim

The taxpayer did secure one favorable ruling. The Court En Banc held that photocopies of invoices and official receipts may be admissible as duplicates under the 2019 Revised Rules on Evidence, absent a genuine question as to authenticity or unfairness in admitting the duplicate. Because the Commissioner did not raise such a challenge, the Court reversed the disallowance of Php16,726.06 that had been rejected merely because the supporting documents were photocopies.

However, that adjustment was too small to change the outcome. The Court increased the valid input VAT for 2018 from Php5,065,059.35 to Php5,081,785.41, but still found no refundable excess input VAT after allocation and application against output VAT.

Deferred Input VAT Must Still Be Properly Substantiated

The taxpayer also claimed deferred input VAT of Php507,249.35 carried over from the prior period. The Court disallowed it because the taxpayer failed to present sufficient supporting documents showing the existence of the capital goods purchases and the correctness of the amortization. The Court recognized that Section 110 of the Tax Code allows input VAT on certain capital goods to be spread over the relevant period, but stressed that the claim must still be proven with competent documents.

This part of the ruling is important for companies with capital-intensive operations. A VAT return showing carryover or amortization is not enough by itself. Taxpayers must be ready to present the underlying invoices, import documents if applicable, subsidiary ledgers, and computations showing that the input VAT was properly amortized and remained claimable in the refund period.

The Chevron Argument Failed Because the Taxpayer Chose to Apply Input VAT Against Output VAT

The taxpayer invoked the Supreme Court’s ruling allowing VAT-registered taxpayers to either charge input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales against output VAT and claim only the excess, or claim the input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales in its entirety. The taxpayer argued that the Court should not have deducted input VAT from output VAT in computing the refund.

The Court En Banc disagreed based on the taxpayer’s own computation in its original petition. The Court found that the taxpayer had chosen the first option: applying input VAT against output VAT and then claiming the alleged excess. Because of that chosen method, the Court found no error in charging the validated input VAT against the taxpayer’s declared output VAT. After recomputation, the Court still found a net output VAT due, not an excess input VAT refundable to the taxpayer.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

First, renewable energy developers, including those engaged in biofuel or other non-power applications, should carefully classify purchases under the Renewable Energy Act before treating supplier-charged VAT as refundable input VAT. If the purchase is legally zero-rated, the safer remedy may be commercial reimbursement or adjustment with the supplier rather than a refund claim against the BIR.

Second, businesses should review supplier invoicing controls. A supplier’s decision to issue a VAT invoice does not automatically make the buyer entitled to a VAT refund. The legal nature of the transaction still controls. This is especially important for renewable energy developers, exporters, PEZA or ecozone entities, and businesses operating under special VAT regimes.

Third, VAT refund claims must be prepared as litigation from day one. The taxpayer must prove not only that input VAT appears in invoices, but also that the purchases are valid, attributable to zero-rated sales, not otherwise disallowed, and properly substantiated. Deferred input VAT and capital goods claims require deeper documentary support than a VAT return entry.

Finally, the method of computing a VAT refund matters. A taxpayer’s own computation may show whether it elected to apply input VAT against output VAT or claim the zero-rated input VAT in full. Once that election is apparent from the pleadings and computations, the Court may use it in determining whether any refundable excess exists.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in VAT refund claims, BIR administrative proceedings, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether a VAT refund claim is legally viable, identify documentation gaps before filing, assess supplier-level remedies for erroneously passed-on VAT, and prepare pleadings and evidence for disputed refund claims.

For businesses facing a denied VAT refund, a renewable energy tax issue, or a pending tax dispute before the Court of Tax Appeals, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *