Customs Smuggling Charges Fail When Prosecutors Cannot Prove Importation

The tax court acquitted an importer in a customs smuggling case after prosecutors failed to prove that the alleged cigarette shipment was actually imported. Importers and customs brokers facing criminal smuggling charges should closely examine whether the prosecution can prove the first and most basic fact: that the goods were actually imported into the Philippines. […]

VAT Refund Win: Photocopies and Zero-Rated Invoice Breakdowns Can Support Tax Credit Claims

Taxpayer wins P3.33M VAT refund as court accepts photocopies and invoice breakdowns showing zero-rated sales, while still denying unreadable amounts. VAT refund claimants may avoid losing otherwise valid tax credits merely because supporting documents were submitted as photocopies or because the words β€œzero-rated sale” appeared in the invoice breakdown rather than in a more conspicuous […]

VAT Refunds Survive Reconsideration When the Record Supports Zero-Rated Sales and Input Tax Claims

A VAT refund award was upheld after both reconsideration motions failed, emphasizing proof of zero-rated sales, compliant invoices, and timely evidence objections. Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds must be ready to prove every peso of zero-rated sales and input VAT, but the government cannot wait until reconsideration to attack evidence it failed to challenge at the […]

Tax Assessments Received After the Stated Due Date May Be Voided

A taxpayer defeated a P88.3M BIR assessment after the FAN and FLD were received after the stated due date, making the demand defective. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should examine not only the amount assessed, but also the stated deadline for payment. A Final Assessment Notice and Formal Letter of Demand may be invalid when […]

Deficiency VAT Assessment Cancelled After Reconsideration Fails to Cure Due Process and Factual Defects

The tax court denied reconsideration and kept a deficiency VAT assessment cancelled for lack of factual basis and due process defects. Taxpayers facing a deficiency VAT assessment should treat factual basis and due process objections as potentially case-ending defenses, especially where the assessment appears to be unsupported or where the sequence and service of assessment […]

VAT Refund Claimants Must Prove Where Export Services Were Performed

VAT refund claim partly upheld only to P501,885.07 after the taxpayer failed to prove services to foreign clients were performed in the Philippines. Companies seeking a VAT refund or tax credit for services billed to foreign clients must be ready to prove not only that their customers are nonresident foreign corporations, but also that the […]

BIR Appeal Dismissed After Refund Order Became Final for Lack of OSG Authority

CTA En Banc dismissed the BIR appeal for lack of OSG authority, leaving a P4.046M VAT refund order in favor of the taxpayer final. Taxpayers who have already secured a favorable VAT refund ruling may defeat a government appeal when the Commissioner attempts to elevate the case without proper authority from the Office of the […]

Improper BIR Service Can Defeat Criminal Tax Charges

Improper service of BIR assessment notices led to acquittal in a criminal tax case, voiding the assessment and barring collection. Taxpayers facing criminal prosecution for alleged failure to pay deficiency taxes may still defeat the case if the government cannot prove that the underlying assessment was validly served and that the taxpayer knowingly refused to […]

Local Business Tax Refund Claims Cannot Be Dismissed as Late Protests When No Deficiency Assessment Was Issued

A taxpayer’s local business tax refund claim may proceed when no deficiency assessment was issued and Section 196’s two-year period was met. Businesses seeking refunds of excessive local business taxes should not be forced into the shorter protest route for deficiency assessments when the city merely issued a statement of account for permit renewal. For […]