Fuel importers may recover excise tax on Jet A-1 fuel later sold to international carriers for foreign use if Section 135 requirements are proven.

Importers of aviation fuel may recover excise taxes previously paid on Jet A-1 fuel when the fuel is later sold to international air carriers for use or consumption outside the Philippines, provided the taxpayer can prove the importation, tax payment, qualifying sale, and actual entitlement to refund. For petroleum companies, airline suppliers, and tax teams handling excise tax claims, the decision reinforces that Section 135 of the Tax Code can convert a previously paid excise tax into an erroneously collected tax once the statutory conditions are met.

Background of the Refund Dispute

The taxpayer imported Jet A-1 fuel in 2018 through separate shipments. Some fuel was initially stored in Customs Bonded Warehouse facilities, while other volumes were later treated as tax-paid fuel after the taxpayer lodged the relevant importation details through the Bureau of Customs system and paid excise tax at Php4.00 per liter. The fuel was eventually transferred to aviation storage facilities and sold to international air carriers for use or consumption outside the Philippines.

The taxpayer filed administrative claims for refund or tax credit with the BIR to recover excise taxes paid on the Jet A-1 fuel. The claim covered sales made to international airlines during the period from September to November 2018. Because the Commissioner did not act on the administrative claims, the taxpayer elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals. In the proceedings below, the Division initially granted a reduced refund, and later increased the approved amount to Php82,640,348.00 after reconsideration. The Commissioner then challenged the amended decision before the Court En Banc (CTA EB No. 3027).

The Commissioner’s Main Objection

The Commissioner argued that excise tax on imported petroleum products becomes due upon importation and was therefore validly collected. From that view, the taxpayer, as importer, could not claim that the tax was erroneous merely because the fuel was later sold to international carriers. The Commissioner also argued that Section 135 of the National Internal Revenue Code does not create a refund right in favor of sellers or importers, and that any exemption should benefit only the buyer or exempt entity.

The Commissioner further relied on the general rule that tax refunds are construed strictly against taxpayers because they operate similarly to tax exemptions. In practical terms, the government’s position would have limited refund claims by fuel importers and would have treated Section 135 mainly as a prohibition against passing on excise tax to exempt buyers, rather than as a basis for refunding excise taxes already paid by the statutory taxpayer.

Why the Taxpayer Won

The Court En Banc denied the Commissioner’s petition and affirmed the refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate in favor of the taxpayer in the amount of Php82,640,348.00. The court held that the controversy was controlled by Supreme Court precedent involving the same taxpayer and the same type of Jet A-1 fuel refund claim. Applying stare decisis, the court followed the rule that excise taxes paid on petroleum products become refundable when the products are subsequently sold to international carriers for use or consumption outside the Philippines under Section 135 of the Tax Code.

The court emphasized that excise tax is imposed on articles manufactured or imported for domestic consumption. It is also an indirect tax: the statutory liability rests on the manufacturer or importer, although the economic burden may be passed on to the buyer as part of the purchase price. This distinction mattered because international carriers that purchase fuel do not become the statutory taxpayers merely because they may bear the economic burden of the tax.

Section 135 Exempts the Petroleum Product, Not Merely the Buyer

A key point in the decision is the characterization of the Section 135 exemption as impersonal. The exemption attaches to the petroleum product when it is sold to the persons or entities described in the law, including international carriers of Philippine or foreign registry using or consuming the fuel outside the Philippines. The enumerated buyers operate as qualifiers for determining when the petroleum product becomes exempt from excise tax.

This means the exemption is not simply a personal privilege of the international carrier. Since the importer remains the statutory taxpayer for excise tax purposes, the importer is the proper party to benefit from the exemption once the conditions under Section 135 are satisfied. The court rejected the Commissioner’s theory that Section 135 only prevents the passing on of excise tax to the airline buyer. Instead, the provision was treated as a substantive exemption affecting the taxability of the petroleum product itself.

Why Previously Paid Excise Tax Became Erroneously Paid

The timing of excise tax liability did not defeat the refund. The court recognized that excise tax generally accrues upon importation. However, the final tax status of petroleum products covered by Section 135 may be confirmed later, depending on whether the products are actually sold to qualifying entities for qualifying use. Once the Jet A-1 fuel was sold to international carriers for use or consumption outside the Philippines, the excise tax previously paid on that fuel was deemed erroneously or illegally collected.

That conclusion brought the taxpayer’s claim within the refund framework under the Tax Code. The court also noted that the taxpayer had adequately proven its entitlement before the Division through competent evidence showing the importations, the excise tax payments, and the subsequent sales to international carriers for qualifying use outside the Philippines. The Commissioner failed to present a sufficient reason for the En Banc to disturb those factual findings.

Practical Takeaways for Fuel Importers and Airline Suppliers

Fuel importers should not assume that excise tax paid at importation is automatically a final cost when the fuel is later sold to international carriers. Where the petroleum products fall within Section 135 and the taxpayer can document the qualifying sale and use, a refund or tax credit claim may be available. This is especially important for suppliers of aviation fuel, companies operating bonded storage arrangements, and taxpayers transitioning products from bonded to tax-paid status.

At the same time, the ruling does not create an automatic refund. The taxpayer must still prove the factual chain: the importation of the petroleum product, the payment of excise tax, the identity and qualifying status of the buyer, the sale of the fuel, and the use or consumption outside the Philippines. In refund litigation, documentary completeness remains decisive. Import entries, payment records, sales invoices, delivery records, storage and transfer documents, and airline customer documentation may determine whether the claim succeeds or fails.

The decision also strengthens the position of taxpayers facing repeated BIR objections that have already been resolved by controlling Supreme Court precedent. Where the factual pattern is materially similar to an established ruling, the doctrine of stare decisis can be a powerful response to attempts to relitigate settled tax principles.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Excise tax refunds and tax credit certificate claims require careful legal framing and meticulous documentation from the administrative claim through Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, fuel suppliers, and corporate finance teams in evaluating refund eligibility, preparing evidentiary support, responding to BIR objections, and litigating disputed tax refund claims before the CTA.

For businesses dealing with excise tax on petroleum products, VAT refunds, customs disputes, or contested BIR assessments, our tax litigation team can help assess the strength of your claim and develop a practical strategy before deadlines expire. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco regarding Philippine tax litigation and refund remedies.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *