VAT refund claimants may use proportional input tax allocation for zero-rated sales, but defective receipts can still defeat substantiation before the CTA.

VAT-registered taxpayers claiming refunds for zero-rated sales may rely on proportional allocation when input tax cannot be directly traced to a specific zero-rated transaction, but the claim can still be reduced or denied if the supporting receipts were not duly registered at the point of sale.

Background: A Partially Granted VAT Refund Became a Two-Sided Appeal

The dispute arose from a domestic VAT-registered taxpayer’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate covering excess and unutilized input VAT for all four quarters of calendar year 2019. The taxpayer originally sought Php33,386,031.16 from the Bureau of Internal Revenue. The BIR administratively granted Php22,892,645.58 and disallowed the balance on several grounds, including invoicing issues, big-ticket purchases, discrepancies, penalties, and input VAT allegedly allocated to unqualified zero-rated sales.

The taxpayer elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals Division, which partially granted the judicial claim and ordered the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate for Php2,156,043.74. Both sides were dissatisfied. The Commissioner challenged the partial grant, while the taxpayer sought to recover an additional Php7,155,551.43, bringing the total judicial relief sought to Php9,311,595.17 (CTA EB No. 3062 and CTA EB No. 3066).

The Commissioner’s Argument: Input VAT Must Be Directly Attributable

The Commissioner argued that the taxpayer should not have been allowed any additional refund because the input VAT was not shown to be directly attributable to zero-rated sales. In the Commissioner’s view, it was not enough that the input VAT was merely allocable to zero-rated transactions. The Commissioner also argued that the taxpayer failed to present VAT returns for later quarters in 2020 and 2021, which supposedly prevented the court from determining whether the claimed input VAT had remained unutilized.

This argument matters to exporters, BPOs, service providers to foreign clients, and other VAT-registered businesses with mixed sales. In practice, many taxpayers incur common input VAT expenses that support the entire business, rather than one specifically traceable zero-rated sale. If direct tracing were always required, many legitimate VAT refund claims would become commercially difficult or impossible to prove.

The En Banc Ruling: Proportional Allocation Is Allowed Under Section 112

The Court En Banc rejected the Commissioner’s position. It held that Section 112(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code allows input taxes to be allocated proportionately on the basis of sales volume when the taxpayer is engaged in zero-rated or effectively zero-rated sales and also has taxable or exempt sales, and the creditable input tax cannot be directly and entirely attributed to any one transaction.

The court emphasized that the law requires the input tax to be attributable to zero-rated sales, but does not require direct attribution in every case. Input taxes that have a direct or indirect connection with the taxpayer’s zero-rated sales may satisfy the statutory requirement. Applying the principle that courts should not distinguish where the law does not distinguish, the En Banc refused to impose a stricter direct-attribution test not found in the text of the law.

The court also sustained the Division’s finding that the taxpayer had established non-utilization of the claimed input VAT. The taxpayer presented its amended VAT return for the first quarter of 2020, where the full Php33,386,031.16 input VAT claim was deducted as VAT refund or tax credit certificate claimed. For the En Banc, there was no need to require VAT returns for the second quarter of 2020 and onward because the amount had already been removed from the carry-over pool in the first quarter of 2020.

Why the Taxpayer Still Lost Its Own Appeal

The taxpayer’s separate appeal focused on the disallowance of input VAT connected with receipts that it argued should remain valid despite being antedated. The taxpayer maintained that the NIRC does not prohibit antedating of invoices or official receipts, and that the receipts were duly registered with the BIR under an Authority to Print dated June 3, 2019.

The Court En Banc did not treat antedating itself as the decisive issue. Instead, it sustained the finding that the receipts were not duly registered receipts at the point of each sale. The court relied on Section 237 of the NIRC, which requires a taxpayer to issue a duly registered receipt or invoice at the point of each sale. The transactions involved receipts dated May 9, May 10, and May 30, 2019, but the relevant Authority to Print was dated June 3, 2019 and covered only official receipts with serial numbers 12751 to 13250. The receipts in question bore serial numbers outside that Authority to Print.

For taxpayers, the lesson is direct: a VAT refund claim is not won only by showing zero-rated sales and excess input VAT. The claim must also be supported by compliant invoices and receipts. Even if the underlying transaction is otherwise zero-rated, defective substantiation can still reduce the refundable amount.

Final Outcome: Both Petitions Were Denied

The Court En Banc denied both petitions for lack of merit. The Commissioner failed to overturn the partial refund because the court recognized proportional allocation and accepted the taxpayer’s proof of non-utilization. The taxpayer also failed to recover the additional amount disallowed because the relevant receipts did not satisfy the invoicing and substantiation requirements at the point of sale.

The result is a balanced ruling. It is favorable to taxpayers on the legal standard for attributing input VAT to zero-rated sales, but strict against taxpayers on documentary compliance. Businesses should therefore treat VAT refund litigation as both a legal and evidentiary exercise: the tax theory must be correct, and every supporting receipt, invoice, return, schedule, and Authority to Print must withstand scrutiny.

Practical Takeaways for VAT Refund Claimants

First, taxpayers with mixed zero-rated, taxable, and exempt sales should not assume that direct tracing is always required. Where input VAT cannot be directly and entirely attributed to a single class of sales, proportional allocation based on sales volume may be available under Section 112(A) of the NIRC.

Second, taxpayers should carefully document non-utilization. A later VAT return showing that the amount was deducted as a VAT refund or tax credit certificate claim can be important evidence that the input VAT was not carried over and applied against output VAT.

Third, invoices and receipts remain a critical vulnerability. The court’s treatment of the disputed receipts shows that the taxpayer must prove that each receipt or invoice was duly registered and valid at the point of sale. Authorities to Print, serial number ranges, transaction dates, VAT returns, and supporting schedules must be reconciled before filing the administrative claim, not only during trial.

Fourth, taxpayers should not rely on the substantive zero-rated nature of the transaction alone. In VAT refund cases, formal substantiation rules are often outcome-determinative. A transaction may be legally zero-rated, yet still fail as a refund item if the evidence does not comply with invoicing requirements.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in VAT refund claims, BIR administrative proceedings, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review refund documentation, test allocation and non-utilization positions, identify invoice and receipt defects, prepare administrative submissions, and represent taxpayers in contested refund cases before the CTA.

For companies preparing or defending a VAT refund or tax credit certificate claim, early legal review can prevent avoidable disallowances and strengthen the evidentiary record before litigation begins. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *