A deficiency tax assessment was cancelled after the BIR relied on a defective waiver and failed to address the taxpayer’s PAN defenses.

Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax, VAT, and expanded withholding tax assessments should closely examine both the waiver of prescription and the BIR’s written response to their protest, because an assessment may be cancelled when the BIR relies on an invalid waiver or merely repeats its preliminary findings without addressing the taxpayer’s defenses.

Background of the Assessment Dispute

The dispute involved a manufacturing corporation engaged in plastic container packaging products. The taxpayer was investigated for all internal revenue taxes covering calendar year 2010 after it received a Letter of Authority in September 2011. The BIR later issued a Notice of Informal Conference, followed by a waiver executed on June 21, 2013, which purported to extend the BIR’s period to assess until December 31, 2014.

The waiver referred broadly to the taxpayer’s “all internal revenue tax liabilities” for taxable year 2010. It did not identify the specific taxes covered and did not state the corresponding amounts. The dispute later reached the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc after the Commissioner challenged the cancellation of the assessments for deficiency income tax, value-added tax, and expanded withholding tax (CTA EB No. 3039).

The BIR issued a Preliminary Assessment Notice dated December 3, 2014, proposing deficiency income tax, VAT, and EWT assessments in the total amount of P51,434,818.07, inclusive of interest. The taxpayer responded on December 12, 2014 and raised specific defenses supported by schedules, including reconciliations of purchases, services, professional fees, rental expenses, labor and employee costs, and explanations on importations that the taxpayer claimed had already been accounted for in its VAT returns.

Despite that reply, the BIR issued the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices dated December 19, 2014, assessing the taxpayer for P52,229,401.69. The Court found it significant that the FLD and FAN merely repeated the PAN findings and did not address the defenses raised by the taxpayer. The taxpayer later received a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment dated April 5, 2019 demanding P69,508,589.91, plus interests.

The Court of Tax Appeals’ Ruling

The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc denied the Commissioner’s petition and affirmed the cancellation of the deficiency tax assessments. The Court sustained two independent grounds for nullifying the assessments: first, the BIR’s right to assess had prescribed because the waiver was void; and second, the BIR violated the taxpayer’s right to due process by issuing the FLD and FAN without addressing the taxpayer’s reply to the PAN.

On prescription, the Court emphasized that the BIR’s right to assess is not unlimited. Under Section 203 of the National Internal Revenue Code, internal revenue taxes must generally be assessed within three years from the last day prescribed by law for filing the return, or from the actual filing date, whichever is later. The Court characterized this prescriptive period not as a mere technicality, but as a substantive taxpayer right intended to protect taxpayers from belated and oppressive tax investigations.

The Court recognized that Section 222(b) of the NIRC allows the BIR and the taxpayer to extend the assessment period by written agreement before the original period expires. However, the Court held that such a waiver must comply with the requirements under applicable revenue issuances and jurisprudence. Citing the Supreme Court’s ruling in First Philippine Industrial Corporation, the Court reiterated that a valid waiver must specify the kind and amount of tax due. Without that specificity, there is no clear meeting of minds on the scope of the extension.

Why the Waiver Failed to Extend the BIR’s Assessment Period

The waiver in this case referred only to “all internal revenue tax liabilities” for taxable year 2010. It did not specify income tax, VAT, EWT, or any corresponding amounts. For the Court, this omission was fatal. Because the waiver failed to identify the specific taxes and amounts covered, it was void and could not extend the BIR’s prescriptive period to assess.

The Commissioner argued that Revenue Memorandum Order No. 14-2016 dispensed with the requirement that the particular kind and amount of tax be stated in the waiver. The Court rejected this argument because the waiver was executed on June 21, 2013, while RMO No. 14-2016 was issued only on April 4, 2016. The Court held that the later issuance could not be applied retroactively to validate a waiver executed years earlier, especially where doing so would impair a vested taxpayer right to invoke prescription.

Based on the Court’s computation, the assessment periods for the taxpayer’s 2010 income tax, VAT, and EWT liabilities had already expired before the FLD and FAN were served on December 19, 2014. The income tax assessment period expired on April 15, 2014. The VAT assessment periods expired on dates ranging from April 25, 2013 to January 25, 2014. The EWT assessment periods likewise expired from February 10, 2013 to January 15, 2014. Since the waiver was void, the December 19, 2014 assessments were already time-barred.

Due Process Requires the BIR to Address the Taxpayer’s Defenses

Even apart from prescription, the Court held that the assessments were void for violation of due process. Section 228 of the NIRC requires that the taxpayer be informed in writing of the law and facts on which an assessment is made; otherwise, the assessment is void. For the Court, this requirement is central to the taxpayer’s constitutional right to due process in tax assessments.

The Court relied on the principles in Avon and Unioil, where the Supreme Court made clear that the BIR cannot simply receive a taxpayer’s explanations and then ignore them. The Commissioner is not required to accept the taxpayer’s position, but when rejecting the taxpayer’s defenses, the BIR must state the reasons and the particular facts supporting its conclusions.

Here, the taxpayer filed a reply to the PAN on December 12, 2014, raising specific factual and documentary defenses. Seven days later, the BIR issued the FLD and FAN on December 19, 2014. The Court found that the FLD and FAN merely reiterated the PAN findings, did not discuss the taxpayer’s submissions, and did not even meaningfully address the reply. This made the opportunity to respond hollow, because the BIR did not show that it had considered the taxpayer’s evidence and arguments.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Under BIR Audit

This ruling is important for taxpayers handling deficiency tax assessments, particularly those involving old taxable years and waivers of prescription. A taxpayer should not assume that every waiver signed during audit automatically extends the BIR’s assessment period. The waiver must be examined for compliance with the applicable rules at the time it was executed, including whether it sufficiently identifies the taxes and amounts covered.

The ruling also reinforces that a taxpayer’s reply to the PAN is not a ceremonial filing. If the taxpayer raises specific defenses and submits supporting documents, the BIR must consider them. A final assessment that simply copies or repeats the preliminary assessment, without explaining why the taxpayer’s defenses were rejected, may be vulnerable to cancellation for violation of due process.

For CFOs, tax managers, accountants, and corporate counsel, the key lesson is to preserve the record early. Replies to the PAN and administrative protests should be specific, well-supported, and properly documented. They should include reconciliations, schedules, explanations, and documentary references. If the BIR later ignores those submissions, the taxpayer will have a stronger basis to argue that the assessment is void under Section 228 of the NIRC and the Supreme Court’s due process rulings.

The decision also shows that prescription and due process are separate and powerful defenses. Even if the BIR argues that the taxpayer had the chance to submit documents during the audit, that does not automatically cure a defective assessment. The BIR must issue a reasoned assessment within the lawful period. A void assessment cannot be revived by a later FDDA, because the FDDA rests on the validity of the earlier FLD and FAN.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in evaluating BIR assessments, drafting PAN replies and administrative protests, reviewing waivers of prescription, and litigating tax disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps businesses identify prescription, due process, evidentiary, and substantive tax defenses before deadlines are missed or arguments are waived.

If your company received a Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, or collection notice from the BIR, our team can help assess your options and prepare a litigation-ready response. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on Philippine tax assessment and Court of Tax Appeals litigation strategy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *