Tax crime appeal dismissed after BIR lawyers lacked OSG authority and the Information for alleged willful failure to pay tax was filed beyond five years.

Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may invoke prescription where the government files the Information in the Court of Tax Appeals beyond the five-year period, and prosecutors handling tax cases must also prove that the appeal was brought by the proper government counsel. For corporate taxpayers, officers, and tax managers, the ruling is a reminder that procedural defects in criminal tax prosecutions can be decisive even before the court reaches the merits of the alleged deficiency tax.

Background of the Criminal Tax Dispute

The case arose from a criminal charge for alleged willful failure to pay deficiency income tax for taxable year 2010. The taxpayer was a domestic corporation engaged in construction, installation, and design of water treatment systems and trading of related goods. Its president and treasurer were also charged as corporate officers during the relevant taxable year.

The BIR revenue officers filed a complaint-affidavit with the Department of Justice on June 6, 2019, alleging violation of Section 255, in relation to Sections 253(d) and 256, of the National Internal Revenue Code. The DOJ later found probable cause. The Information, however, was filed with the Court of Tax Appeals only on December 5, 2022, charging the taxpayer and its officers with failure to pay deficiency income tax of ₱18,515,728.66, exclusive of surcharge and interest (CTA EB Crim. No. 125).

Why the Government Appeal Was Dismissed

The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc dismissed the government’s petition for review. Although it first clarified that the prosecution’s motion for reconsideration and subsequent petition were timely filed, the court held that the appeal suffered from a fatal representation defect. The petition was filed by BIR legal officers without proof that they were authorized or deputized by the Office of the Solicitor General.

Under Section 10, Rule 9 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, the Solicitor General represents the People of the Philippines in criminal cases brought to the Court of Tax Appeals in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction. While the Solicitor General may deputize BIR legal officers in cases involving the Tax Code, that deputation must be shown. It is not presumed from the mere fact that the case involves internal revenue taxes.

The court applied Supreme Court jurisprudence holding that, where the criminal aspect of a case is being appealed after dismissal or acquittal, only the People, represented by the Office of the Solicitor General, may bring the appeal. Because the appeal was filed by BIR legal officers without proof of proper deputation, the petition was dismissible on that ground alone.

The Five-Year Prescriptive Period in Tax Crimes

The court also held that, even assuming the BIR legal officers had authority to file the appeal, the prosecution would still fail because the criminal action had already prescribed. Section 281 of the Tax Code provides that violations of the Code prescribe after five years. It also states when prescription begins to run and when it may be interrupted.

For this case, the Formal Letter of Demand covering taxable year 2010 was received by the taxpayer on January 10, 2014. The court treated the tax offense as having been committed on February 10, 2014, after non-payment despite demand. Counting five years from that date, the government had until February 10, 2019 to institute the criminal case in court. Since the Information was filed only on December 5, 2022, the court found that prescription had already set in.

Filing With the DOJ Did Not Save This Tax Prosecution

A key issue was whether the filing of the complaint-affidavit with the DOJ in 2019 interrupted the running of prescription. The government argued that the complaint for preliminary investigation should toll the prescriptive period. The court rejected that argument for this case.

The Court of Tax Appeals relied on the rule applicable to tax cases before it: prescription is interrupted by the filing of the Information in court, not merely by the filing of a complaint for preliminary investigation. The court acknowledged the Supreme Court’s 2025 ruling in People v. Consebido, which adopted a unified rule that filing before the prosecution office tolls prescription. However, because the Supreme Court made that rule prospective, it did not apply to this earlier prosecution. The court therefore resolved the case under the prior tax-case rule, which favored the accused.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers

For taxpayers and company officers, this ruling shows that criminal tax exposure is not determined solely by the amount assessed or by the BIR’s finding of deficiency taxes. Timing, authority, and strict compliance with criminal procedure matter. A taxpayer charged with willful failure to pay tax should immediately examine when the alleged offense was committed, when the demand became final for criminal prosecution purposes, when the complaint was filed, and most importantly when the Information was actually filed in the Court of Tax Appeals.

For corporations, the ruling is also important because officers may be personally charged in tax crime cases. Presidents, treasurers, finance officers, and responsible corporate officials should not assume that a criminal tax case is valid simply because the BIR or DOJ initiated proceedings. The defense should review the authority of the lawyers who filed the appeal, the applicable prescriptive period, and whether later jurisprudence can be applied retroactively without violating the rule that prescription in criminal cases is construed in favor of the accused.

For the government, the case highlights two recurring litigation risks in tax prosecutions. First, appeals involving the criminal aspect must be handled by the Office of the Solicitor General or by counsel whose deputation is properly documented. Second, delays between assessment, DOJ proceedings, and the filing of the Information may defeat the prosecution if prescription has already run.

How Our Tax Litigation Team Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, and businesses facing BIR assessments, tax collection actions, DOJ preliminary investigations, and Court of Tax Appeals proceedings. Our tax litigation practice reviews both the substantive tax issues and the procedural defenses that may determine the outcome of a case, including prescription, authority to sue or appeal, validity of assessments, and compliance with Tax Code requirements.

If your company or officers are facing a tax assessment or criminal tax complaint, early review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax litigation strategy, Court of Tax Appeals representation, and defense against criminal tax enforcement.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *