A Manila real property tax refund appeal was dismissed after the city failed to attach the required verification and forum shopping certification.

Local government units challenging an adverse real property tax refund ruling must strictly comply with appeal requirements, because failure to attach a verification and certification against forum shopping can end the case before the Court of Tax Appeals reaches the merits.

Background of the Real Property Tax Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from an auction sale conducted for the collection of delinquent real property tax over a lot in Manila. The taxpayer became the winning bidder, paid a bid price of P60,130,000.00, and received a certificate of sale. After the redemption period lapsed without the property being redeemed, she attempted to consolidate title and ownership over the property.

Instead of issuing the final deed to purchaser, the city assessed the taxpayer additional delinquent real property tax in the aggregate amount of P3,872,895.79, allegedly covering the years 1995 to 2008. The taxpayer paid the amount under protest on July 27, 2021 and filed a protest before the city on August 9, 2021. When the city did not act, she elevated the matter to the Local Board of Assessment Appeals and sought a refund of the amount paid, with legal interest.

The local board found that the taxpayer was not liable for the delinquent real property tax because she was not yet the owner of the property for the years being assessed. However, instead of granting a refund, the local board granted a tax credit. The taxpayer moved for partial reconsideration, insisting that she had asked for a refund, not a tax credit, but the motion was denied. She then appealed to the Central Board of Assessment Appeals, which ordered the city to refund P3,872,895.79 and pay 6% legal interest from August 26, 2021 until actual refund. The city then brought the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc (CTA EB No. 3005).

The City’s Arguments on Appeal

The city argued that the option to grant a cash refund or issue a tax credit certificate belonged to the city, not to the taxpayer. It relied on the idea that a cash refund would require appropriation in the city’s annual budget, while a tax credit certificate would be administratively easier for the local government to implement.

The city also challenged the award of legal interest. It maintained that the imposition of 6% interest on the real property tax refund had no legal basis. These arguments could have raised important questions for taxpayers and local treasurers: when an erroneously collected local tax is paid under protest, may the taxpayer insist on a refund, or may the local government substitute a tax credit? May legal interest be awarded against a local government for failure to return erroneously collected real property tax?

The Court Dismissed the Appeal on Procedural Grounds

The Court of Tax Appeals did not resolve those substantive questions. Instead, it dismissed the city’s petition because it was not accompanied by any verification and certification against forum shopping.

The Court applied Section 2, Rule 6 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, which requires a petition for review to be verified and to contain a certification against forum shopping. It also applied Section 3, Rule 46 of the Rules of Court, which states that failure to comply with the requirements for a petition is sufficient ground for dismissal.

The Court distinguished between defects in verification and defects in the certification against forum shopping. A defective or missing verification is generally a formal defect and may, in appropriate cases, be corrected. By contrast, non-compliance with the certification against forum shopping requirement is generally not curable by later submission, unless there is substantial compliance or special circumstances that justify relaxation of the rule.

Why the Missing Certification Was Fatal

The Court relied on Supreme Court guidance holding that the certification against forum shopping is not a mere technicality. It is intended to prevent parties from filing multiple actions involving the same issues before different courts or tribunals. For that reason, the failure to submit the required certification at the time of filing is generally a sufficient basis to dismiss the petition.

The Court emphasized that the right to appeal is not a natural right or an inherent element of due process. It is a statutory privilege that must be exercised only in the manner provided by law. A party that seeks appellate review must comply with the applicable procedural requirements. Failure to do so means the appeal is not perfected, and the reviewing court is divested of jurisdiction to rule on the merits.

Because the city failed to perfect its appeal, the Court dismissed the petition. As a practical result, the Court did not disturb the ruling that ordered the refund of P3,872,895.79 and the payment of legal interest, although its own decision rested on procedural non-compliance rather than an independent review of the refund and interest issues.

Practical Lessons for Taxpayers and Local Governments

For taxpayers disputing real property tax assessments, the case underscores the importance of paying under protest and timely elevating the matter when the local treasurer fails to act. A taxpayer who pays an allegedly erroneous assessment should preserve the record carefully: the assessment, proof of payment, protest letter, dates of filing, and subsequent appeal documents may determine whether the claim survives.

For local governments and city treasurers, the ruling is a warning that procedural lapses can defeat even potentially substantial arguments. A city may believe that a tax credit is more appropriate than a cash refund, or that legal interest should not be imposed against public funds. But if the petition for review is defective, the court may never reach those arguments.

For purchasers of delinquent real property at public auction, the case is especially relevant. Winning bidders may later face demands for prior real property tax liabilities connected to periods before they became owners. Where the buyer was not yet the owner during the assessed years, there may be grounds to contest the additional assessment, especially if the payment is made under protest and the statutory remedies are pursued in time.

What This Means for Real Property Tax Refund Strategy

The broader lesson is that tax litigation is won not only on substantive law but also on procedural discipline. In local tax and real property tax cases, parties must track deadlines, remedies, required attachments, verification, certification against forum shopping, proof of service, and appeal requirements with precision.

A taxpayer seeking a refund should also be clear about the relief requested. In this case, the taxpayer asked for a refund, while the local board initially granted only a tax credit. That distinction matters because a tax credit may be useful only if the taxpayer has future liabilities to which the credit can be applied. A refund, by contrast, directly returns the amount allegedly collected in error.

Although the Court dismissed the appeal on procedural grounds, the underlying controversy shows how real property tax disputes can become financially significant for property buyers, developers, investors, and local governments. Amounts paid to secure title or complete a transaction should not be treated casually, especially where the assessment relates to periods before the buyer’s ownership.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, property owners, winning bidders in tax delinquency auctions, corporations, and local tax stakeholders in evaluating real property tax assessments, preparing protests, pursuing refund claims, and handling appeals before local boards, the Central Board of Assessment Appeals, and the Court of Tax Appeals.

Our tax litigation practice can help assess whether a local tax or real property tax assessment is legally defensible, whether payment under protest is required, what deadlines apply, and how to preserve remedies without losing the case on technical grounds. For assistance with a real property tax refund, local tax assessment, or Court of Tax Appeals dispute, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *