Casino operators may recover CWTs withheld on PAGCOR-exempt gaming revenues, but refund claims still require specific tracing of income and withholding records.
Casino operators and other PAGCOR licensees should closely review creditable withholding taxes imposed on gaming-related receipts, because taxes withheld from revenues covered by PAGCOR’s franchise tax exemption may be refundable when the taxpayer can trace the income, withholding certificates, and accounting records with sufficient evidence.
Background of the Refund Dispute
The taxpayer is a Philippine corporation engaged in developing and operating tourist facilities, hotel-casino entertainment complexes, and casino gaming activities. It holds a PAGCOR-issued gaming license for casino operations in Entertainment City, Parañaque City, under the brand City of Dreams Manila.
For taxable year 2018, the taxpayer filed its Annual Income Tax Return on April 15, 2019. On April 12, 2021, it filed an administrative claim with the BIR Large Taxpayers Service seeking a refund or tax credit of P24,798,420.00, representing allegedly erroneous and unutilized creditable withholding taxes for 2018. It then filed a petition before the Court of Tax Appeals on April 14, 2021 (CTA Case No. 10514).
In the original decision dated January 6, 2026, the Court partially granted the claim and ordered the refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate for P12,620,976.15, representing erroneous and unutilized withholding tax on the taxpayer’s gaming revenues. The Court denied the balance relating to non-gaming revenues because it found that the taxpayer failed to establish that the income on which the taxes were withheld was declared as part of its gross income in its 2018 Annual ITR.
The Commissioner Failed to Overturn the Gaming Revenue Refund
The Commissioner sought partial reconsideration, arguing that the taxpayer should not have been granted a refund on the withholding taxes imposed on its gaming revenues. The Court rejected the motion in full.
The Court reaffirmed that the exemption of gaming revenues from income tax and withholding tax was already settled. Under Section 13(2)(b) of Presidential Decree No. 1869, as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Bloomberry Resorts and Hotels, Inc. v. Bureau of Internal Revenue, PAGCOR’s tax exemption under its franchise extends to corporations with whom PAGCOR or its operators have contractual relationships in connection with authorized casino operations, upon PAGCOR’s payment of the 5% franchise tax in lieu of all other taxes.
The Court found that the income covered by the refund consisted of credit card settlement receipts from BDO attributable exclusively to buy-in transactions at designated gaming cage terminals. These were considered income from casino gaming operations, not income from other related services subject to regular corporate income tax. The Merchant Agreement with BDO, the MID or terminal address identification system, and the BIR Forms 2307 supported that classification.
PAGCOR Franchise Tax Payment Activated the Exemption
The Commissioner also argued that the taxpayer failed to prove PAGCOR’s payment of the 5% franchise tax. The Court disagreed. It held that PAGCOR’s payment was established through documentary evidence, including the Statement of Franchise Tax Remittances for Calendar Year 2018 issued by PAGCOR and the BIR Forms 2553 filed by PAGCOR for all four quarters of 2018.
Following the Supreme Court’s ruling in PAGCOR v. BIR, the Court treated PAGCOR’s payment of the 5% franchise tax as the operative fact that activates the tax exemption for its contractees and licensees. Because the record established that payment, the Commissioner’s argument was rejected.
Taxpayers Need Not Prove Actual Remittance by the Withholding Agent
A key practical point for taxpayers is the Court’s treatment of proof of remittance. The Commissioner insisted that the taxpayer had to prove actual remittance of the withheld taxes by the withholding agent. The Court rejected this position.
The Court cited Section 2.58.3(B) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended, which places responsibility for proof of remittance on the withholding agent. The taxpayer was the payee-recipient, not the withholding agent. Its obligation was to present the BIR Forms 2307 issued to it, which constitute the prescribed evidence of withholding. The burden of proving that the withheld taxes were not remitted lies with the BIR, not with the refund claimant.
Gaming Revenues May Be Reported as Exempt Income
The Court also rejected the Commissioner’s argument that the taxpayer failed to prove that its gaming income was declared in its Annual ITR. The Court explained that because gaming revenues are exempt from corporate income tax under PD No. 1869, they are properly reported in the exempt income column of the Annual ITR, not in the taxable income column.
The Court relied on the verification of the court-commissioned Independent Certified Public Accountant, which traced the gaming revenues attributable to credit card transactions at cage terminals through BDO bank statements, journal vouchers, and the general ledger. The Court affirmed the refund of P12,620,976.15 for erroneous and unutilized withholding taxes on gaming revenues.
The Taxpayer Partially Won on Its Non-Gaming CWT Claim
The taxpayer also moved for partial reconsideration, arguing that the denied portion of its non-gaming CWT claim should be reconsidered. It contended that income payments of P168,436,849.05 from credit card transactions, with corresponding CWTs of P842,170.85, had been declared in its 2018 Annual ITR and verified by the ICPA.
The Court granted this motion in part. It held that refund claims for excess and unutilized creditable withholding taxes under Section 76 of the Tax Code are not claims for tax exemption based on legislative grace. Rather, they arise from the government’s receipt of taxes that the taxpayer could not apply against any income tax liability. For that reason, the applicable standard of proof is preponderance of evidence, not strictissimi juris.
The Court applied the Supreme Court’s rulings in Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Sonoma Services, Inc. and Tullett Prebon (Philippines), Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, which distinguish refund claims rooted in erroneous or illegal tax collection from exemption claims. Where the claim is based on solutio indebiti, the taxpayer must prove the factual basis of the claim by preponderance of evidence.
ICPA-Traced Documents Supported Only Part of the Non-Gaming Refund
The Court found that the ICPA-verified evidence established, by preponderance, that income payments of P168,436,849.05 were declared in the taxpayer’s Annual ITR for 2018. The ICPA traced these income payments through two pathways: hotel operations, using credit card front office payment reconciliations against journal vouchers and general ledger cash receipts; and food and beverage operations, using bank statements, journal vouchers, and general ledger cash receipts.
Taken together, the BIR Forms 2307, credit card payment reconciliations, bank statements, journal vouchers, and general ledger entries showed that the income from which the CWTs were withheld was received, processed through the taxpayer’s accounting system, and included in its non-gaming revenue reported in the Audited Financial Statements and Annual ITR.
However, the Court did not grant the entire denied balance. It allowed only P842,170.85 in additional CWT refund because that amount corresponded to the specific ICPA-traced subset of non-gaming income. The remaining P11,329,059.75 was still denied because it was not sufficiently linked to income declared in the 2018 Annual ITR.
Final Outcome and Practical Takeaways
The Court denied the Commissioner’s motion for partial reconsideration and partially granted the taxpayer’s motion. The final refund or tax credit certificate amount was increased to P13,463,146.00, consisting of P12,620,976.15 for erroneous and unutilized withholding taxes on gaming revenues and P842,170.85 for excess creditable withholding taxes on non-gaming revenues.
For PAGCOR licensees and casino-related enterprises, the ruling confirms that gaming revenues covered by PAGCOR’s franchise tax regime should not be treated as ordinary taxable income for income tax and withholding tax purposes, provided the taxpayer can show the connection between the income and authorized gaming operations. Credit card settlement systems, terminal identifiers, bank records, and BIR Forms 2307 can be critical in proving that connection.
For taxpayers filing excess CWT refund claims, the ruling is also important because it confirms that the evidentiary standard is preponderance of evidence, not strictissimi juris, when the claim is grounded on erroneous or excess collection. Still, the Court required specific tracing. General financial statements and broad income figures may not be enough unless the taxpayer can link the withheld taxes to income actually declared in the Annual ITR.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, gaming operators, importers, withholding tax agents, and taxpayers in evaluating, preparing, and litigating refund and tax credit claims before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help review BIR Forms 2307, reconcile accounting records, prepare evidentiary schedules, coordinate with independent accountants, and develop litigation strategy for disputed tax refund claims.
If your company has unutilized creditable withholding taxes, withheld taxes on exempt income, or a pending BIR refund claim approaching the statutory deadline, our Makati-based tax litigation team can help assess the strength of your claim and protect your remedies. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on Court of Tax Appeals litigation and Philippine tax refund disputes.