Holding companies may recover local business tax on dividends when city billings are not valid assessments and dividends are excluded from the LBT base.
Holding companies assessed local business tax on dividend income should carefully examine whether the city treasurer issued a valid notice of assessment and whether the dividends are even part of the taxable base. In this ruling, the taxpayer was allowed to recover local business tax paid on dividend income because the city billing statements were not proper assessments, the refund claim was timely under the Local Government Code, and the taxpayer was a holding company rather than a bank or financial institution.
Background of the Local Business Tax Dispute
The dispute arose from the taxpayerâs renewal of its business permits with the City of Taguig for 2018 and 2019. During the renewal process, the city treasurer issued billing statements that included local business tax on dividend income. The taxpayer paid the amounts assessed, including local business tax on dividends of P139,064.34 for 2018 and P514,035.47 for 2019, or a total of P653,099.81.
After payment, the taxpayer filed a written protest and claim for refund before the Office of the City Treasurer on September 25, 2019, arguing that the local business tax on its dividend income had been erroneously collected. The taxpayer then filed a judicial claim before the Regional Trial Court of Taguig on January 20, 2020. The trial court granted the refund and ordered the return of P653,099.81 with legal interest. The city treasurer appealed to the Court of Tax Appeals (AC No. 323), arguing that the claim was filed out of time and that the taxpayer remained liable either as a bank or financial institution, or alternatively as a holding company under a local ordinance.
Billing Statements Are Not Automatically Local Tax Assessments
The central procedural issue was whether the billing statements issued during business permit renewal should be treated as notices of assessment under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. If they were valid assessments, the taxpayer would have had only 60 days from receipt to protest, and failure to follow the protest and appeal periods could make the assessment final and unappealable.
The Court held that the billing statements did not qualify as notices of assessment under Section 195. A proper local tax assessment must state the nature of the tax, fee, or charge; the amount of deficiency; and the corresponding surcharges, interests, and penalties. The billing statements in this case were issued in connection with the taxpayerâs business permit renewal, did not indicate that the city treasurer had found any deficiency, and did not impose surcharges, interest, or penalties. They were billings, not deficiency assessments.
This distinction matters for every taxpayer dealing with local government units. A document demanding payment during permit renewal is not necessarily a formal local tax assessment. If the document lacks the statutory elements of an assessment, the taxpayerâs remedy may fall under Section 196 of the Local Government Code, which governs recovery of taxes, fees, or charges erroneously or illegally collected.
The Refund Claim Was Timely Under the Two-Year Rule
Because the billing statements were not valid assessment notices, the Court applied Section 196 of the Local Government Code. Under that provision, a taxpayer seeking recovery of local taxes erroneously or illegally collected must first file a written claim for refund or credit with the local treasurer, and the court action must be filed within two years from payment of the tax, fee, or charge, or from the date the taxpayer became entitled to the refund or credit.
The taxpayer paid the questioned local business taxes on January 20, 2018 and January 19, 2019. It filed its administrative claim on September 25, 2019 and its judicial claim on January 20, 2020. Since the relevant two-year period for the 2018 payment ended on a Saturday, the filing on the next working day was considered timely. The Court therefore rejected the city treasurerâs prescription argument.
Dividend Income of a Holding Company Was Not Taxable as Bank or Financial Institution Income
On the substantive tax issue, the city treasurer imposed local business tax on the taxpayerâs dividend income under the provision applicable to banks and other financial institutions. The Court rejected this treatment because the taxpayer was not a bank, non-bank financial intermediary, lending investor, finance company, investment house, pawnshop, money shop, insurance company, stock broker, dealer in securities, or dealer in foreign exchange.
The taxpayerâs corporate documents and BIR registration showed that it was engaged in financial holding company activities. Its stated purpose was to invest in, hold, acquire, manage, and dispose of properties, stocks, bonds, and securities. The Court emphasized the distinction between a holding company and a financial intermediary. A holding company may hold investments, but that does not automatically make it a regulated financial institution or an entity performing banking or quasi-banking functions.
Because the taxpayer was a holding company, its dividend income could not be taxed under the local provision applicable to banks and other financial institutions. The local governmentâs power to tax must remain within the authority delegated by law, and the classification used for local business tax must match the taxpayerâs actual business and legal status.
The City Could Not Shift to a New Holding Company Tax Theory at Trial
The city treasurer also argued that even if the taxpayer was not taxable as a bank or financial institution, it was still liable under a separate ordinance imposing a tax on dividend income received by holding companies. The Court did not sustain this argument.
First, that basis was not included in the billing statements and was raised only later during trial. The Court recognized that using a new tax basis after the fact would raise due process concerns. Taxpayers must be informed of the legal and factual basis for the tax being imposed; a local government cannot simply substitute a different theory after collection is challenged.
Second, the Court considered the rule that passive income such as interest, dividends, and gains from sale of shares does not form part of gross sales or receipts for local business tax purposes. Since local business tax is generally computed on gross sales or receipts, dividends excluded from that base should not be subjected to local business tax.
Refund Granted, But Legal Interest Deleted
The Court ultimately denied the city treasurerâs appeal and affirmed the taxpayerâs entitlement to a refund of P653,099.81. However, it modified the trial courtâs decision by deleting the award of 6% legal interest.
The Court applied the principle that interest on tax refunds is allowed only when authorized by law or when the collection was attended by arbitrariness. Since there was no law directing payment of interest on the local business tax refund and no showing that the cityâs collection was arbitrary, the refund was granted without legal interest.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Holding Companies
Businesses renewing local permits should not assume that every amount in a city billing statement is legally due. If the billing includes local business tax on dividend income, passive income, investment income, or other non-operating receipts, the taxpayer should review whether those items properly form part of gross sales or receipts under the Local Government Code and applicable local ordinances.
Holding companies should also be careful when local governments classify them as banks, financial institutions, finance companies, or investment companies. The legal classification matters. A corporation that merely holds shares or securities for investment or control purposes is not automatically a financial intermediary subject to the same local business tax treatment as banks and regulated financial institutions.
For local tax disputes, timing remains critical. If a formal notice of assessment is issued, the taxpayer must observe the 60-day protest period under Section 195. If there is no proper assessment and the issue involves recovery of erroneously or illegally collected local taxes, the taxpayer should file both the administrative claim and judicial action within the two-year period under Section 196.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, holding companies, property groups, operating companies, importers, and corporate finance teams in disputes involving local business tax, city treasurer assessments, refund claims, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review local tax billings, determine whether a valid assessment exists, prepare refund claims, and represent taxpayers before local treasurers, trial courts, and the Court of Tax Appeals.
If your company has paid local business tax on dividend income, passive income, investment receipts, or amounts included during business permit renewal, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com to evaluate whether a refund claim or tax protest may still be available.