Taxpayers won a P2.61M refund after Pasay transfer taxes were computed on full property values instead of the inherited and donated shares actually transferred.

Real property owners who pay local transfer taxes on inherited, donated, or renounced property shares should verify whether the city computed the tax on the actual share transferred, not automatically on the full fair market value shown in a tax declaration. In a recent local tax appeal involving Pasay City transfer taxes, the taxpayers obtained a substantial refund because the city used the full value of several properties even though only undivided portions were actually transferred.

Background of the Local Transfer Tax Dispute

The dispute arose from a family estate settlement involving two parcels exclusively owned by the deceased spouse and eight parcels classified as conjugal properties. After the spouse died intestate, the surviving spouse and two children executed an extrajudicial settlement. Two heirs renounced and waived their hereditary rights in favor of the remaining heir. Separately, the surviving spouse donated his one-half share in the conjugal properties to his grandchildren.

The city treasurer issued twenty-eight transfer tax orders of payment covering transfers arising from intestate succession, repudiation or waiver of hereditary shares, and donation. The taxpayers paid the assessed transfer taxes, surcharges, interests, secretary’s fees, and transfer fees, then filed a protest and claim for refund. When the city treasurer adhered to the city legal officer’s view that the issues should be ventilated before the proper forum, the taxpayers treated the response as a constructive denial and sued for refund before the Regional Trial Court. The trial court dismissed the complaint, and the taxpayers appealed to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA AC No. 309).

The Core Issue: Full Property Value or Only the Share Transferred?

The central legal issue was how to determine the tax base for local transfer tax when the transaction covers only an undivided share in real property. The city relied on the fair market values reflected in the tax declarations and treated those values as the basis for the transfer tax assessments. The taxpayers argued that this overstated the tax base because the relevant transfers covered only aliquot or proportionate shares, not the entire properties.

The court agreed with the taxpayers on this point. Applying Section 135(a) of the Local Government Code and Section 16 of the Pasay City Revenue Code, the court held that the phrase fair market value refers to the portion of the property actually transferred. Nothing in those provisions requires the full fair market value in the tax declaration to be used when the conveyance covers only an undivided share.

Why Conjugal Property Shares Matter in Transfer Tax Computation

The court emphasized that the spouses were married before the effectivity of the Family Code, and their property relations were governed by the conjugal partnership of gains. Upon the death of one spouse, the surviving spouse has an actual and vested one-half undivided share in the conjugal properties, while only the deceased spouse’s one-half share is transmitted to the heirs.

This distinction directly affected the transfer tax computation. For the intestate succession of the deceased spouse’s share in the conjugal properties, the tax base should have been limited to the deceased spouse’s one-half interest, not the full value of each conjugal property. For the donation by the surviving spouse, the tax base should likewise have been limited to the donor’s one-half share in the conjugal properties. The city’s use of the full fair market value resulted in overassessment.

Renunciation in Favor of a Specific Heir Was Treated as a Taxable Transfer

The taxpayers also argued that the repudiation or renunciation of inheritance should not be subject to transfer tax because no transfer of ownership supposedly occurs. The court rejected that argument based on the wording and structure of the extrajudicial settlement.

Although parts of the settlement suggested a general renunciation, the instrument ultimately directed the repudiated shares in favor of a specific co-heir. The court treated that act as an acceptance of inheritance followed by a gratuitous transfer or donation of the renouncing heirs’ shares. As a result, the repudiation was taxable. However, the tax base still had to be limited to the shares actually transferred: two-thirds of the deceased spouse’s exclusive properties and two-thirds of her one-half interest in the conjugal properties.

Refund Granted, But No Interest, Damages, or Attorney’s Fees

The taxpayers originally sought a refund of P3,311,276.24. After recomputing the transfer taxes, the court found that the city’s total assessments on the contested transfers amounted to P4,827,394.62, while the correct amount should have been P2,213,052.25. The difference, P2,614,342.36, was ordered refunded to the taxpayers.

The court did not award legal interest, exemplary damages, or attorney’s fees. It found no statutory basis requiring the government to pay interest on the refund and no sufficient showing that the collection was attended by arbitrariness. While the city treasurer’s computation was wrong, the court characterized it as a good-faith interpretation of the applicable law and ordinance, not bad faith or oppressive conduct.

Practical Takeaways for Property Owners and Estate Administrators

This ruling is important for families, estate administrators, real estate owners, and corporate property holders dealing with local transfer tax assessments. A single tax declaration does not automatically mean the entire property value is the correct tax base. When the transaction transfers only an undivided share, the assessment should be proportionate to the share actually conveyed.

Taxpayers should also be careful in drafting estate settlements and waivers of inheritance. A general renunciation may have different tax consequences from a renunciation expressly made in favor of a specific heir. If the document effectively directs the share to a named co-heir, the local treasurer may treat the transaction as a taxable gratuitous transfer, even if the document uses the language of repudiation or waiver.

For refund claims, the ruling also reinforces the need to preserve evidence: transfer tax orders of payment, official receipts, the estate settlement, deeds of donation, tax declarations, protests, and correspondence with the local treasurer. The refund was granted because the taxpayers were able to show the nature of each transfer and the correct proportional tax base.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, property owners, estate administrators, and businesses in contesting local tax assessments, preparing refund claims, and litigating tax disputes before the Regional Trial Courts and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can review local transfer tax computations, assess whether a refund claim is viable, prepare protests and pleadings, and represent clients through appeal.

For assistance with local transfer tax assessments, estate-related tax disputes, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation, visit MakatiLawFirm.com or contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco for a confidential consultation.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *