Tollway Operators May Face Real Property Tax on Government-Owned Roads They Operate for Profit

A tollway operator remained liable for real property tax because it had beneficial use, control, and toll revenue rights over government-owned infrastructure. Private operators of government infrastructure cannot assume real property tax exemption merely because the underlying asset is owned by the Republic or used by the commuting public. Where a tollway operator has possession, […]

Pasay Property Owners Win Refund After Transfer Tax Was Computed on Full Property Value

Taxpayers won a P2.61M refund after Pasay transfer taxes were computed on full property values instead of the inherited and donated shares actually transferred. Real property owners who pay local transfer taxes on inherited, donated, or renounced property shares should verify whether the city computed the tax on the actual share transferred, not automatically on […]

Tax Garnishment Due Process: When LGUs Cannot Freeze Public Funds

Local tax garnishment is void when it exceeds the judgment, lacks prior assessment, or denies due process in Philippine tax collection. Tax garnishment due process means a local government cannot freeze or seize bank deposits by simply inflating or combining alleged tax liabilities without first giving the taxpayer a legally sufficient notice and a real […]

Local Tax Ordinance Challenges: Why Procedure Can Defeat Tax Cases

Taxpayers challenging local tax ordinances must first use DOJ remedies and proper courts, or risk dismissal despite serious tax claims. Taxpayers challenging a local tax ordinance must usually go first to the Secretary of Justice and the proper lower court before asking the Supreme Court to intervene. The local tax ordinance procedure rule means that […]

Temperate Advocacy Rule: When Harsh Pleadings Become Contempt

Lawyers may criticize rulings, but offensive pleadings imputing gross ignorance to a court may constitute direct contempt under Philippine law. The Temperate Advocacy Rule reminds litigants and lawyers that zealous advocacy has a hard boundary: pleadings may attack legal errors, but they may not denigrate the court itself. In Philippine litigation, an intemperate motion can […]

Appellees Cannot Win More Than the Judgment Gave Them Without Their Own Appeal

A non-appealing appellee may defend a favorable judgment but cannot obtain greater relief on appeal. The ruling protects litigants in tax and property disputes. A party who wins in the trial court cannot use another party’s appeal to obtain a larger, different, or more favorable judgment unless that winning party also appeals. For taxpayers, property […]