Exporter’s Php2.43M VAT refund was denied after foreign currency remittances could not be matched to claimed zero-rated sales.
Exporters claiming input VAT refunds must be able to trace each zero-rated sale to the corresponding foreign currency remittance; bank certifications showing lump-sum remittances may not be enough if the Court cannot match the payments to the invoices under review.
Background of the VAT Refund Dispute
The taxpayer was a VAT-registered corporation engaged in agricultural operations, including the planting and cultivation of organic cavendish bananas and other farm products. It was registered with the Board of Investments as an existing export producer of cavendish banana and with the Bureau of Customs as an exporter.
For taxable year 2021, the taxpayer filed an administrative claim with the BIR for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate in the amount of Php2,433,849.28, representing alleged excess and unutilized creditable input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales. The BIR denied the entire claim through a VAT Refund Notice dated June 6, 2023, which the taxpayer received on July 4, 2023. The taxpayer then elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA Case No. 11248), asking that the denial be reversed.
Why the BIR Denied the Claim
The BIR disallowed the claim on several grounds. It identified deductions from the claim, including alleged invoicing violations, disallowed amortized input VAT, output VAT on sales declared as exempt, output VAT on other income, and output VAT on collected intercompany billings. It also questioned the taxpayer’s claimed zero-rated sales of goods and services amounting to Php255,525,186.21.
A major point in the administrative denial involved the taxpayer’s sales documents. The taxpayer had a Permit to Use a Computerized Accounting System covering system-generated documents described as