Airline excise tax refund denied after failure to prove imported liquor and tobacco were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.

Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit based on a statutory tax exemption must be ready to prove every factual condition of that exemption with competent, detailed, and credible evidence. For airline operators importing commissary and catering supplies, the ruling is a warning that price lists and internal comparison tables may not be enough to recover excise taxes unless they clearly show that the imported products were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price at the time of importation.

Background of the Excise Tax Refund Dispute

The taxpayer was an airline franchise holder whose charter granted tax privileges on certain importations used in its transport and non-transport operations. The dispute arose from importations of liquor and tobacco products used as in-flight and commissary supplies for the period beginning August 2014 until February 2018. The Bureau of Customs demanded excise taxes on those importations, and the taxpayer paid the assessed amounts under protest on August 3, 2018.

The taxpayer later filed an administrative claim with the Bureau of Internal Revenue for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate in the amount of PhP20,059,948.44, representing excise taxes allegedly illegally assessed and collected. It then filed a petition before the Court of Tax Appeals after seeking recovery of the protested payments. The case eventually reached the Court En Banc after the Division denied the refund claim and denied reconsideration (CTA EB No. 2811).

The Taxpayer’s Theory for Refund

The taxpayer relied on Section 13 of Presidential Decree No. 1590, its franchise, which provides that the tax paid under the franchise is in lieu of certain other taxes, duties, fees, and charges. For importations, however, the tax privilege is not automatic. The imported articles, supplies, or materials must be for the taxpayer’s use in its operations or incidental activities, and they must not be locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.

The taxpayer argued that its imported liquor and tobacco products were covered by the franchise exemption because they formed part of its in-flight and commissary supplies. It also insisted that it had sufficiently proven the absence of reasonable local availability by presenting the testimony of its personnel, price lists from several suppliers, a table comparing importation costs with local prices, and the BIR price list under Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012.

Why the Refund Claim Failed

The Court En Banc affirmed the denial of the refund claim. It agreed that the taxpayer had proven the first two requirements: payment of the relevant franchise tax or corporate income tax condition, and use of the imported products in its transport or non-transport operations. The case turned on the third requirement: whether the taxpayer proved that the imported liquor and tobacco products were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.

For the tobacco products, the Court found a straightforward evidentiary gap. The taxpayer did not present evidence of local market prices for the tobacco products. Testimony that the taxpayer imported tobacco products was not enough. Without competent evidence comparing the relevant imported tobacco products with locally available alternatives, the Court could not conclude that the statutory condition was satisfied.

For the liquor products, the Court examined not only the number of documents submitted but also the quality and credibility of the taxpayer’s proof. The taxpayer had presented price lists from local suppliers and a comparison table, but the Court was not convinced that these documents represented the local market price for the entire country or that they reflected actual commercial pricing after meaningful negotiation.

Price Lists Alone May Not Establish Local Market Unavailability

A key point in the ruling is that courts will look beyond the existence of price quotations or price lists. During testimony, the taxpayer’s witness admitted that the comparison was based on queries rather than actual purchases, and that there had been no negotiation with suppliers to test whether local prices could be lowered or matched against importation costs. Some inquiries were informal, including a request made by phone, and the taxpayer did not present proof of genuine efforts to secure competitive pricing from local suppliers.

The Court gave weight to the observation that the taxpayer appeared to have a predetermined practice of importing the products and using local price lists mainly for refund purposes. The Court also noted that the comparison table had eighty entries for imported alcohol products, but only forty-five entries were compared with prices from local suppliers. The taxpayer failed to explain why all imported items were not matched with local price data. This incomplete comparison further weakened the claim that the imported products were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.

Burden of Proof in Tax Refund and Tax Exemption Cases

The decision reiterates a strict rule in Philippine tax litigation: a tax refund is in the nature of a tax exemption. Because taxation is the rule and exemption is the exception, the taxpayer must clearly prove entitlement to the refund. The government’s failure to present contrary evidence does not automatically entitle the taxpayer to recover. The taxpayer still carries the burden of establishing the factual and legal basis for the claim by preponderance of evidence.

The Court also rejected the taxpayer’s reliance on prior favorable rulings involving similar claims and similar types of evidence. The Court emphasized that earlier Court of Tax Appeals decisions do not bind the Court or the public as precedent. Each refund case is decided on its own evidentiary record. Even if similar evidence had been accepted in previous taxable periods, the taxpayer still had to prove the statutory conditions for the specific importations and period covered by the claim.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

Businesses seeking refunds or tax credits for taxes paid under protest should treat the administrative claim and CTA case as an evidence-heavy exercise, not a mere accounting reconciliation. When the exemption depends on local unavailability, the taxpayer should preserve proof of actual market canvassing, written requests to multiple suppliers, supplier responses, product specifications, comparable quantities, timing of quotations, and any negotiations or attempts to obtain competitive pricing.

For importers, especially those relying on franchise-based or industry-specific tax exemptions, the ruling shows that internal tables and selected supplier price lists may be attacked as incomplete, pro-forma, or unrepresentative of the local market. Evidence should be organized product by product. If eighty imported items are claimed, the taxpayer should be prepared to explain the local availability, price, quality, and quantity analysis for each item or category, and to justify any gaps.

The ruling also matters for CFOs, tax managers, and customs brokers handling payments under protest. A protest payment may preserve the right to claim, but it does not prove entitlement to refund. The refund file should be built at the time of importation and payment, while supplier data, market conditions, and procurement records are still available. Waiting until litigation to reconstruct the proof may leave the taxpayer vulnerable to the argument that its evidence is incomplete or not commercially credible.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, logistics companies, and regulated businesses in evaluating tax assessments, customs-related tax demands, refund claims, tax credit applications, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation strategy. Our tax litigation practice can help assess whether a refund claim has sufficient documentary and testimonial support, identify evidentiary gaps before filing, and prepare the administrative and judicial record needed to withstand strict scrutiny.

If your company has paid excise tax, VAT, customs duties, or other tax charges under protest, or if you are evaluating whether a tax exemption can support a refund or tax credit claim, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *