When Local Environmental Charges Are Fees, Not Taxes: Why the Correct Appeal Route Matters

Businesses disputing local environmental charges must classify the exaction correctly; the court dismissed the appeal after finding the charge was a regulatory fee, not a tax. Businesses paying local environmental charges under protest must first determine whether the exaction is truly a tax or merely a regulatory fee, because choosing the wrong appellate forum can […]

Excise Tax Refund Upheld After BIR Applied Beer Tax Increase Too Early

Businesses may recover excise taxes paid under protest when the BIR applies higher tax rates before proper publication or relies on invalid issuances. Taxpayers facing tax refund disputes should treat this ruling as a reminder that the government cannot collect higher internal revenue taxes before the law imposing them has properly taken effect, and that […]

Excise Tax Refund Granted for Distilled Spirits After Premature RA 11467 Implementation

Distilled spirits taxpayer wins PHP66.37M refund after court finds RA 11467 excise tax hike unenforceable before printed Official Gazette publication. Alcohol manufacturers and other excise taxpayers may challenge tax collections based on a law that was enforced before its valid effectivity date, especially where the Bureau of Internal Revenue relied only on online publication or […]

Airlines Seeking Excise Tax Refunds Must Prove Local Unavailability With More Than Price Lists

Airline excise tax refund denied after failure to prove imported liquor and tobacco were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit based on a statutory tax exemption must be ready to prove every factual condition of that exemption with competent, detailed, and credible evidence. For airline […]

When a Municipal License Tax Is Not an Illegal Sales Tax

The Supreme Court upheld Virac’s municipal license taxes, ruling that taxes measured by capital or purchases are not automatically illegal sales taxes. Local governments may impose graduated municipal license taxes on businesses based on capital investment or prior-year purchases, so long as the tax is imposed on the privilege of doing business and not directly […]

Property Owners Cannot Bypass Tax Assessment Appeals by Suing for a Refund

Property owners must timely appeal disputed real property tax assessments; paying under protest and suing for refund cannot bypass the assessment appeal process. A property owner who believes a real property tax assessment is illegal, excessive, or unreasonable must challenge the assessment through the statutory appeal process; paying the tax under protest and filing a […]