A tax court resolution confirms that BIR assessments may be void when reassigned revenue officers continue an audit without a new Letter of Authority.

Taxpayers facing a BIR audit should closely check whether the revenue officers who examined their books were actually named in a valid Letter of Authority, because a reassignment through a mere Memorandum of Assignment may be fatal to the assessment. In this January 2025 resolution, the tax court refused to revive deficiency tax assessments for taxable year 2014 after finding that the audit and assessment were conducted by officers who were not properly authorized through a new LOA.

Background of the Tax Dispute

The dispute arose from deficiency internal revenue tax assessments issued against the taxpayer for taxable year 2014. The BIR had issued a Letter of Authority naming specific revenue officers and a group supervisor to examine the taxpayer’s accounting records. Later, however, the investigation was reassigned to a different revenue officer and group supervisor through a Memorandum of Assignment, not through a new Letter of Authority issued by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or another duly authorized official.

The tax court had earlier granted the taxpayer’s Petition for Review, cancelled and set aside the Final Letter of Demand, the assessment notices dated March 27, 2018, and the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment dated October 18, 2019, and enjoined the Commissioner and those acting on his behalf from collecting or taking further action on the subject deficiency taxes for taxable year 2014 (CTA Case No. 10217). The Commissioner moved for reconsideration, arguing that the revenue officers acted pursuant to a valid LOA and that the later Memorandum of Assignment merely implemented or continued the authority already granted.

The Commissioner’s Argument on Reconsideration

The Commissioner insisted that the tax court erred in ruling that the investigating revenue officers had no authority to conduct the investigation and assessment. According to the Commissioner, an LOA had been validly issued to the taxpayer naming the original revenue officer and group supervisor, and the subsequent Memorandum of Assignment reassigned the investigation to a new revenue officer and group supervisor pursuant to that LOA.

The Commissioner also argued that the taxpayer was notified that its records for taxable year 2014 would be examined, that it was required to submit accounting records, and that it knew the officers conducting the audit were not the same officers named in the original LOA. Since the taxpayer participated in the audit and did not object at the time, the Commissioner maintained that there was no violation of due process. The Commissioner further contended that the naming of revenue officers in the LOA was an internal matter and not a statutory requirement that could create a vested right in favor of the taxpayer.

Why the Tax Court Denied the Motion for Reconsideration

The tax court rejected the Commissioner’s position and held that the issue was no longer novel. Relying on Supreme Court jurisprudence, the court reiterated that when a new set of revenue officers takes over an audit, a new LOA is required to confer authority on those officers. A mere Memorandum of Assignment, referral memorandum, or similar document signed by officials who are not authorized to issue LOAs cannot substitute for a new LOA.

The court emphasized that the issuance of an LOA is part of due process in tax investigations. Under Section 6 of the National Internal Revenue Code, the Commissioner or his duly authorized representatives may authorize the examination of a taxpayer’s return and the assessment of the correct amount of tax. Under Section 13 of the same Code, a revenue officer assigned to perform assessment functions may examine taxpayers pursuant to a Letter of Authority issued by the Revenue Regional Director. The court also referred to Revenue Memorandum Order No. 43-90, which identifies the BIR officials authorized to issue and sign LOAs, including the Regional Directors, Deputy Commissioners, and the Commissioner, subject to prior authorization in specific circumstances.

The practical point is simple: the authority to audit must be traceable to a proper LOA. If the revenue officers who actually examined the taxpayer’s books are not named in the LOA, the taxpayer cannot verify whether those officers had lawful authority to conduct the audit and recommend an assessment. That lack of verifiable authority is a due process problem, not a mere technicality.

Key Legal Principle: A Memorandum of Assignment Is Not Enough

The court applied the doctrine that when revenue officers named in the original LOA cannot continue an audit because of transfer, reassignment, resignation, retirement, or other reasons, the BIR must issue a new LOA naming the new officers who will continue the examination. The court relied on Supreme Court rulings holding that reassigning a tax audit through a mere Memorandum of Assignment or similar document, instead of a new LOA, is invalid because it effectively allows an unauthorized official to exercise the statutory authority of the Commissioner or his duly authorized representative.

This matters because a tax assessment is not valid merely because the taxpayer received notices, submitted documents, or participated in the audit. Participation does not automatically cure a defective authority to examine. The question is whether the officers who conducted the examination were duly authorized in the manner required by law and jurisprudence. If they were not, the resulting assessment may be void and ineffectual.

Outcome of the Resolution

The tax court denied the Commissioner’s Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. It affirmed its July 19, 2024 decision cancelling and setting aside the Final Letter of Demand, the assessment notices, and the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment for taxable year 2014. The Commissioner and those acting on his behalf remained enjoined from collecting or taking further action on the subject deficiency taxes.

For the taxpayer, this meant that the deficiency tax assessments remained void. For other taxpayers, the resolution reinforces a powerful procedural defense in BIR assessment cases: a taxpayer should inspect the LOA, identify the named revenue officers and group supervisor, and compare those names with the officers who actually conducted the audit, issued findings, or participated in the assessment process.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Under BIR Audit

Taxpayers should not treat the LOA as a routine attachment. It is the legal source of the BIR officers’ authority to examine books and records. If the audit team changes, the taxpayer should ask whether a new LOA was issued naming the new revenue officers. A Memorandum of Assignment may show an internal reassignment within the BIR, but it does not necessarily supply the statutory authority required for a valid tax audit.

Companies should also maintain a clear audit file containing the LOA, notices, memoranda, correspondence, requests for documents, submissions, protest letters, and assessment documents. These records are crucial in determining whether the BIR complied with due process, whether the correct officers acted on the case, and whether the assessment can be challenged before the Court of Tax Appeals.

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, the ruling is especially relevant when reviewing deficiency income tax, VAT, withholding tax, percentage tax, or other internal revenue tax assessments. Even before reaching the substantive tax issues, the authority of the examining officers may determine whether the assessment can stand.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in evaluating BIR Letters of Authority, audit notices, deficiency tax assessments, administrative protests, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation strategy. Our tax litigation practice can help determine whether an assessment is vulnerable due to an invalid LOA, unauthorized revenue officers, defective service, due process violations, prescription, or substantive errors in the computation of tax liabilities.

If your business has received a BIR assessment, a Final Letter of Demand, or a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, early legal review can preserve defenses that may otherwise be overlooked. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team on BIR audit disputes, tax assessment protests, and Court of Tax Appeals cases.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *