Halliburton PH Branch successfully obtained PHP 1.76M input VAT refund after CTA recognized a previously excluded zero-rated sale due to properly submitted receipts.
Businesses claiming input VAT refunds must ensure all supporting documents are properly substantiated and readable, as failure to do so can affect refund claims. Following a recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) decision, Halliburton Worldwide Limited – Philippine Branch successfully secured a refund of PHP 1,759,680.34 for unutilized input VAT attributable to its zero-rated sales for the 2018 calendar year.
Background
Halliburton Philippine Branch filed a petition for refund against the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR), seeking recovery of unutilized input VAT linked to its zero-rated sales in CY 2018 (CTA Case No. 10467). In the original decision dated July 26, 2024, the CTA partially granted the refund, amounting to PHP 249,846.59. A key issue involved a sale to Energy Development Corporation (EDC) totaling PHP 22,229,678.09, which was initially excluded from zero-rated sales because the submitted Official Receipt No. 1153 was deemed unreadable.
CTA’s Amended Ruling
Upon reconsideration, Halliburton submitted original carbon pink and white copies of Official Receipt No. 1153 to prove the transaction. The CTA accepted the submission, recognizing the EDC sale as valid zero-rated. The Court emphasized that while a VAT-registered person must issue official receipts for every sale, the receipts must be duly registered with the BIR through a valid authority to print (ATP). Receipts issued beyond the ATP validity period are not acceptable for refund claims.
Legal Principles Applied
The ruling reaffirmed Section 113(A)(2), Section 237, and Section 238 of the Tax Code. The CTA clarified that proper documentation is critical in substantiating input VAT claims. Sales of services supported by official receipts with expired ATP remain disallowed. Only receipts within the valid ATP period or properly substantiated can justify a refund.
Practical Takeaways
Taxpayers must maintain clear, BIR-registered VAT documentation for all zero-rated transactions. The CTA’s decision underscores the importance of preserving original receipts and verifying ATP validity when claiming input VAT refunds. In Halliburton’s case, meticulous documentation enabled the taxpayer to expand its allowable zero-rated sales, increasing the refund from the original decision to PHP 1,759,680.34 for CY 2018.
Businesses should review internal VAT compliance procedures and ensure that receipts, invoices, and supporting documents are both legible and properly registered with the BIR. Failure to meet these requirements can result in partial or complete denial of refund claims.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Our tax litigation team at Ablola, Saribong & Gueco specializes in securing input VAT refunds and handling complex disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. We guide taxpayers on proper substantiation, compliance with BIR invoicing rules, and strategic representation in motions for reconsideration. Learn more about how we can help safeguard your tax rights at