Court grants a P1.097B excise tax refund for Jet A-1 fuel sold to international carriers, but disallows unsupported and unverified portions.

Petroleum manufacturers and importers that pay excise tax on Jet A-1 fuel may recover the tax when the fuel is later proven to have been sold and delivered to qualified international carriers, but only to the extent that the taxpayer can trace the tax payment, the covered fuel, the buyer’s qualification, and the delivery documents with precision.

Background of the Jet A-1 Fuel Refund Dispute

The taxpayer sought a refund or tax credit of P1,499,409,664.00 in excise taxes allegedly paid from January 1, 2019 to December 31, 2019 on locally produced and imported Jet A-1 fuel. The fuel was allegedly sold and delivered to international carriers and other tax-exempt entities. The case reached the Court of Tax Appeals after the administrative claims filed with the BIR were not acted upon and the two-year prescriptive period was about to lapse (CTA Case No. 10439).

The claim was divided into P1,488,202,976.00 for imported Jet A-1 fuel and P11,206,688.00 for locally produced Jet A-1 fuel. The Commissioner opposed the refund, arguing in substance that Section 135 of the Tax Code does not grant the seller a refund right and that the exemption applies only to the buyers identified in the statute.

Why the Court Recognized the Seller’s Right to Claim the Refund

The Court rejected the Commissioner’s theory that only the buyer may benefit from the exemption under Section 135 of the National Internal Revenue Code. It applied the settled rule that excise tax on petroleum products is a tax on the article itself, and that the statutory taxpayer remains the manufacturer, producer, owner, or importer that is legally required to pay the tax.

Because excise tax is an indirect tax, the economic burden may be passed on to the purchaser as part of the price. However, passing on the cost does not transform the purchaser into the statutory taxpayer. The legal liability to pay remains with the manufacturer or importer. For that reason, when petroleum products become exempt by reason of a qualifying sale under Section 135, the refund or tax credit should accrue to the party that actually paid the excise tax to the government.

The Court also emphasized that Section 135 refers to petroleum products sold to international carriers and exempt entities. The wording focuses on the petroleum products, not merely on the personal status of the buyer. This matters because the exemption is treated as impersonal in character: it attaches to the product once the statutory conditions are met.

Imported and Locally Produced Fuel Were Both Covered

A key point for fuel companies and aviation suppliers is that the Court did not limit the exemption to locally manufactured petroleum products. The Court observed that Section 135 does not distinguish between imported and locally produced petroleum products. Since the law does not distinguish, the exemption may apply to both imported and locally produced Jet A-1 fuel, subject to proof of the statutory and evidentiary requirements.

The taxpayer also cleared the timing hurdle. For imported Jet A-1 fuel, the earliest relevant excise tax payment was made on March 1, 2019; for locally produced Jet A-1 fuel, the earliest removal and payment occurred on January 1, 2019. The administrative claims filed on December 17, 2020 and the judicial claim filed on December 29, 2020 were held to be within the two-year period under Sections 204(C) and 229 of the Tax Code.

Why the Full Refund Was Not Granted

The taxpayer won the legal issue but not the entire amount claimed. The Court required strict proof that the excise taxes were actually paid, that the fuel was sold to qualified entities, and that the documentary trail connected the tax-paid fuel to qualifying sales and deliveries.

Out of the P1,499,409,664.00 total claim, the Court first found that only P1,114,513,804.00 in excise tax payments had been traced or verified. The unverified portion of P384,895,860.00 was excluded because a refund cannot be granted for taxes that were not adequately proven to have been paid or remitted.

The Court then made additional deductions. It disallowed P321,064.00 for sales to international carriers that lacked sufficient proof of valid authority such as a foreign air carrier permit, certificate of public convenience and necessity, or air service agreement. It also disallowed P6,338,928.00 for aviation delivery receipts with unreadable details, no destination, or a local destination. Another P4,470,592.00 was disallowed because the delivery receipts were dated before the March 13, 2019 authority to release imported goods, making the sourcing of the claimed fuel insufficiently established.

The Court further disallowed P5,820,072.00 relating to sales to alleged tax-exempt entities. The submitted certificates for some entities were photocopies, while one entity was not supported by proof that it qualified as exempt from direct and indirect taxes. This portion is a useful warning: even if the buyer appears to be treated commercially as exempt, the taxpayer claiming the refund must prove the legal basis of the exemption with competent evidence.

Final Outcome: Partial Refund Granted

The Court partially granted the petition and ordered the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate for P1,097,563,148.00. This amount represented substantiated excise taxes on imported and locally produced Jet A-1 fuel that was subsequently sold and delivered to various international carriers from January 1, 2019 to December 31, 2019.

The ruling is significant for petroleum companies, aviation fuel suppliers, importers, and large taxpayers with recurring excise tax refund claims. It confirms that the statutory taxpayer may pursue the refund, but it also shows that the Court will scrutinize the paper trail at the transaction level.

Practical Takeaways for Excise Tax Refund Claims

First, taxpayers should file both administrative and judicial claims within the two-year period counted from actual payment or removal, depending on whether the fuel is imported or locally produced. Waiting for BIR action may be risky if the prescriptive period is about to expire.

Second, the claimant must be ready to prove payment, movement, storage, withdrawal, sale, delivery, buyer qualification, and use or consumption outside the Philippines. In high-value refund claims, the weakest delivery receipt, unreadable document, missing original, or unsupported exemption certificate can reduce the recoverable amount.

Third, sellers should not assume that the buyer’s international carrier status alone is enough. The record should include the necessary permits, authorizations, agreements, or legal basis showing that the buyer falls within Section 135. For entities claiming exemption from direct and indirect taxes, certified and competent proof should be secured before relying on the sale as part of a refund claim.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, petroleum companies, aviation suppliers, and other regulated businesses in preparing, filing, substantiating, and litigating tax refund and tax credit claims before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help review the refund theory, organize the evidentiary trail, identify gaps before filing, and defend the claim through trial and post-decision proceedings.

For assistance with excise tax refunds, VAT refunds, tax credit certificates, BIR assessments, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco for a focused evaluation of your tax dispute.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *