The CTA ruled that appeal periods start from personal service, not email, canceling BIR’s VAT assessment against Cherie Marie T. Chan due to procedural errors.

Taxpayers can now take note: the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) has clarified that the period to file a Petition for Review cannot begin from electronic receipt of a resolution when traditional service methods were not formally adopted. This ruling affects how the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) and taxpayers compute deadlines for filing appeals in assessment disputes, emphasizing compliance with personal service or registered mail under the Rules of Court.

Background

The dispute arose from the assessment of a deficiency Value-Added Tax (VAT) for taxable year 2017 against Cherie Marie T. Chan. The BIR issued Formal Letters of Demand and a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment asserting a VAT deficiency of P4,572,117.97, inclusive of surcharge, interest, and compromise penalties. In response, the taxpayer filed a Petition for Review with the CTA on August 23, 2021.

The CTA 3rd Division, in its Resolution promulgated on April 7, 2025, (CTA Case No. 10640) initially granted the Petition for Review, canceling and setting aside the BIR’s assessment. However, procedural questions emerged regarding the timeliness of the appeal due to electronic service of the resolution.

CTA’s Ruling on Service and Timeliness

The 3rd Division emphasized that the Rules of Court (RCP), as amended, require service of resolutions via personal service or registered mail, not electronic mail, unless specifically adopted by the Court En Banc. The petitioner had received the Resolution dated April 7, 2025 by email on April 15, 2025, but personal service was only effected on April 22, 2025.

The CTA ruled that the reglementary period for filing a Petition for Review should be reckoned from the date of valid service via personal delivery or registered mail. Counting fifteen days from April 22, 2025, the petitioner timely filed the Motion for Extension of Time on May 6, 2025, and subsequently filed the Petition for Review within the extended period on May 21, 2025. Consequently, the CTA 3rd Division set aside its earlier resolution dismissing the petition for being out of time, and required the petitioner to submit proof of authorization from the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG).

Key Legal Principles Applied

The CTA reinforced that:

1. Electronic service by email cannot be used as a basis to compute appeal periods unless formally adopted by the Court En Banc or specific rules authorize it.

2. The period to file motions and appeals begins only upon valid personal service or service by registered mail.

3. Even if parties previously accepted electronic service, this does not create implied consent to disregard the prescribed modes of service for future reckoning of deadlines.

4. Authorization from the OSG is required for BIR Special Counsels to act on behalf of the government in filing petitions with the CTA.

Practical Takeaways

For taxpayers and corporate counsel, this decision underscores the importance of monitoring how resolutions and orders are served. Relying solely on email may not suffice to trigger appeal deadlines. Taxpayers should ensure proper proof of service, maintain documentation of receipt, and verify authorizations when government representatives file petitions.

For BIR and other government agencies, the ruling highlights the procedural necessity to comply with traditional modes of service and secure deputation letters from the OSG for representatives to act in CTA proceedings. Miscomputing filing deadlines due to electronic service may result in successful challenges by taxpayers.

Conclusion

This case serves as a critical reminder of procedural compliance in tax litigation. Ensuring proper service and timely filing under the Rules of Court can determine the success of VAT or other tax assessments challenged before the CTA.

For assistance in navigating BIR assessments, service requirements, and filing petitions with the Court of Tax Appeals, Ablola, Saribong & Gueco offers specialized tax litigation support for corporate and individual taxpayers. Visit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *