The CTA dismissed Sankyu-ATS Consortium-B’s tax credit petition due to defective verification and certification against forum shopping, emphasizing strict procedural compliance.

Taxpayers seeking refunds or tax credits must ensure strict compliance with verification and certification requirements to avoid dismissal of their petitions. A recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) En Banc decision emphasizes that even a statutory privilege like filing a Petition for Review can be denied if the supporting verification and certification against forum shopping are improperly executed.

Background of the Dispute

Sankyu-ATS Consortium-B filed a Petition for Review to contest a prior administrative decision denying their refund claim (CTA EB No. 3014). The Petition was accompanied by a Special Power of Attorney (SPA), a Verification, and a Certification of Non-Forum Shopping executed on December 27, 2023, and photocopies of earlier CTA Division decisions dated April 18, 2024, and October 1, 2024. The CTA En Banc questioned the procedural validity of these documents, given that the Verification and Certification predated the Division’s Decision and Resolution on which the Petition for Review was based.

CTA’s Analysis and Ruling

The CTA found that the Verification and Certification of Non-Forum Shopping were executed more than ten months prior to filing and before any Division decision existed. The En Banc highlighted that while verification primarily ensures the truthfulness of allegations, certification against forum shopping prevents multiple proceedings on the same issue. Strict compliance is mandatory unless substantial compliance can be justified under exceptional circumstances. The Court determined that the ten-month gap, coupled with the absence of the underlying Division rulings at the time of execution, undermined both purposes.

The CTA referenced established Supreme Court precedents, including Peak Ventures Corporation v. Heirs of Villareal and Spouses Valmonte v. Alcala, noting that while minor variances between verification and pleadings may be explained, a significant discrepancy without corrective action is unacceptable. The Court concluded that the Petition for Review could not be given due course because the verification and certification failed to satisfy the formal requirements under Sections 5 and 7, Rule 43 of the Revised Rules of Court.

Key Legal Principles Applied

First, the CTA reinforced that the right to appeal is a statutory privilege, not a natural right, and must be exercised in strict accordance with procedural rules. Second, verification of pleadings may be substantially complied with when allegations are true and the signatory has personal knowledge. Third, certification against forum shopping is distinct and generally not curable if defective, as it serves a preventive function to avoid duplicative litigation. Finally, compliance with these requirements is critical, and failure to provide a proper certification is sufficient grounds for dismissal, even with prior opportunities to correct defects.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

Business owners, CFOs, corporate counsel, and importers should take note that procedural formalities in tax litigation are strictly enforced. When filing for refunds or tax credits, ensure that verifications are contemporaneous and accurately reflect the basis of the petition, and that certifications against forum shopping are properly executed by the party-pleader or via an authorized SPA. Failing to do so can result in dismissal of claims regardless of substantive merit. It is advisable to review all supporting documents carefully and to seek legal guidance to preempt procedural deficiencies.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Our tax litigation team in Makati specializes in navigating the procedural requirements of the Court of Tax Appeals. We assist clients in preparing compliant petitions, verifications, and certifications to maximize the likelihood of success in refund and tax credit claims. Visit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *