Court cancels Folares Pharmaceuticals’ 2017 tax assessments, citing BIR’s failure to comply with due process requirements in issuing PAN and FLO/FAN.

Taxpayers now have a reinforced reminder that due process is non-negotiable in internal revenue assessments. Folares Pharmaceuticals Inc. successfully challenged deficiency income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, improperly accumulated earnings tax (IAET), and compromise penalty assessments for 2017 after the Court of Tax Appeals found the Bureau of Internal Revenue’s Final Letter of Demand and Assessment Notice (FLO/FAN) void due to failure to properly inform the taxpayer of the factual and legal bases of the assessments.

Background

Folares Pharmaceuticals, a domestic corporation based in Makati City, received a Preliminary Assessment Notice (PAN) from the BIR on September 22, 2020, identifying alleged deficiencies for the 2017 taxable year. The PAN cited basic tax, interest, VAT, EWT, IAET, and a compromise penalty totaling over P22 million. Petitioner filed a timely Reply and later received the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices (FLO/FAN) reiterating the same findings. Despite submitting supporting documents and attending an informal conference, the BIR merely acknowledged the submissions without addressing the taxpayer’s arguments.

CTA Ruling

The Court examined whether the BIR complied with due process requirements under Section 228 of the NIRC and Revenue Regulations No. 12-99. It emphasized that the taxpayer must be fully apprised in writing of the law, facts, and evidence underlying the assessment, and must have the opportunity to submit explanations and supporting documents. The Court found that the FLO/FAN merely replicated the PAN without engaging the taxpayer’s explanations, rendering the assessments null and void. Consequently, the Petition for Review filed on May 12, 2022, was granted, cancelling all deficiency tax assessments and the related Final Decision on Disputed Assessment issued on April 13, 2022

CTA 1st Division Decision FOLA…

CTA 1st Division Decision FOLA…

.

Legal Principles Applied

The decision reinforces established jurisprudence that any tax assessment failing to comply with procedural due process is void. The Court referenced the Supreme Court’s rulings in Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Avon Products and Liquigaz Philippines Corp., which underscore the requirement that the BIR must not only receive taxpayer submissions but actively evaluate and provide reasons when rejecting taxpayer defenses. The presumption of regularity in BIR actions is rebuttable when positive evidence shows disregard of procedural safeguards.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

For taxpayers and importers, this ruling highlights the importance of documenting all submissions to the BIR, including Replies to PANs, supporting evidence, and formal protests. Businesses should insist on receiving specific factual and legal explanations whenever assessments are issued. Assessments that merely reiterate audit findings without addressing taxpayer defenses may now be challenged successfully on due process grounds. Additionally, the ruling serves as a caution for the BIR to rigorously comply with pre-assessment notification and post-assessment procedural requirements to avoid invalidation of its notices.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Our team provides strategic tax litigation support for corporations facing BIR assessments or disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. We assist clients in filing timely protests, ensuring complete documentation, and asserting procedural and substantive defenses to protect your business from unwarranted liabilities. For guidance on navigating deficiency assessments and enforcing your rights as a taxpayer, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and consult our experts.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *