Criminal tax charges for willful failure to pay VAT prescribed because the Information was filed in court beyond the five-year NIRC period.

Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases may defeat prosecution where the government allows the five-year prescriptive period to lapse before filing the Information in court, even if a complaint for preliminary investigation was earlier filed with the Department of Justice.

Why This Criminal Tax Case Matters

For business owners, proprietors, and corporate officers, a deficiency tax assessment can carry two separate consequences. First, the Bureau of Internal Revenue may pursue civil collection. Second, where the government believes the taxpayer willfully failed to pay taxes, file returns, supply correct information, or remit taxes, the matter may be elevated into a criminal case under Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code.

The decision is important because it clarifies when the government must act if it wants to pursue a criminal tax case for willful failure to pay assessed taxes. The ruling confirms that prescription is not merely a technical defense. It is a substantive protection against stale criminal prosecution, especially where the assessment had already become final and executory years before the Information was filed in court.

Background of the Dispute

The government charged the taxpayer, a sole proprietor engaged in computer systems and convenience store operations, with willful failure to pay deficiency value-added tax for taxable year 2012. The Information alleged a deficiency VAT amount of Php2,437,154.63, exclusive of interest and surcharge, and cited the taxpayer’s receipt of assessment notices and collection demands.

The Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice were received on January 5, 2016. The taxpayer filed a protest on January 25, 2016, but the BIR treated it as insufficient for failure to meet the requirements of a valid protest under Revenue Regulations No. 18-2013. A later protest was denied for being filed out of time. The assessment was deemed final, executory, and demandable, and the BIR issued collection letters thereafter. The Information, however, was filed in court only on December 5, 2022 (CTA EB Crim. No. 140).

The Government’s Argument on Prescription

The government did not dispute the material timeline found by the Court in Division. Instead, it argued that the criminal action should be considered timely because the filing of the complaint for preliminary investigation with the Department of Justice on October 23, 2020 interrupted the running of prescription.

Under that theory, the government claimed that the five-year period was suspended before it expired, and that the later filing of the Information in court should not defeat the criminal case. In practical terms, the government’s position would have allowed the preliminary investigation stage to stop the prescriptive clock for criminal violations of the Tax Code.

The Court’s Ruling: The Information in Court Controls

The Court En Banc rejected the government’s argument and affirmed the dismissal of the criminal case on the ground of prescription. It held that, for criminal tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals, the institution of the criminal action that interrupts prescription is the filing of the Information in court, not merely the filing of a complaint with the Department of Justice for preliminary investigation.

The Court relied on Section 281 of the NIRC, which provides that violations of the Tax Code prescribe after five years. Prescription begins to run from the day of the commission of the violation, or if unknown, from discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment. The Court also cited Section 2, Rule 9 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, which states that criminal actions before the Court in Division are instituted by the filing of an Information in the name of the People of the Philippines, and that the institution of the criminal action interrupts the running of prescription.

Because the Information was filed only on December 5, 2022, the Court held that the filing came well beyond the five-year period counted from the finality of the assessment. The petition was therefore denied, and the dismissal of the criminal case was affirmed.

When Does the Crime of Willful Failure to Pay Tax Begin?

The ruling is also useful because it restates an important principle for Section 255 cases. A taxpayer does not commit the offense of willful failure to pay deficiency taxes simply because the taxpayer filed a return years earlier or because the BIR later disagreed with the tax treatment. For this type of offense, the violation is committed only after the assessment becomes final and executory, coupled with the taxpayer’s willful refusal to pay within the allotted period.

Here, the Court treated the assessment as final and executory after the taxpayer failed to file a valid protest within the required period. Counting from that point, the five-year period had already expired before the Information was filed in court. This distinction matters because the start of prescription depends on the nature of the tax offense charged. Failure to file a return, filing a false return, tax evasion, and failure to pay an assessed tax may involve different triggering facts.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers

Taxpayers who receive a Final Assessment Notice should treat the protest period as critical. If no valid protest is filed within the required period, the assessment may become final, executory, and demandable. Once that happens, the BIR may pursue collection, and in appropriate cases, the government may also consider criminal prosecution for willful failure to pay tax.

At the same time, taxpayers and their counsel should carefully reconstruct the timeline in any criminal tax case. The relevant dates include receipt of the FLD and FAN, filing and validity of any protest, denial of protest, finality of the assessment, collection letters, filing of any complaint for preliminary investigation, and filing of the Information in court. A prescription defense may turn entirely on these dates.

For corporate officers, proprietors, and finance teams, the ruling highlights the need to preserve assessment records and proof of receipt. In criminal tax litigation, the date when the assessment became final may determine whether the government still had the right to prosecute. Missing registry records, incomplete protest files, or unclear receipt dates can materially affect the defense.

What This Means for BIR Criminal Tax Prosecutions

The ruling reinforces that prosecutors must file the Information within the statutory period when pursuing criminal tax cases under the NIRC. The filing of a DOJ complaint for preliminary investigation may be an important procedural step, but the Court held that it does not substitute for the institution of the criminal action before the Court of Tax Appeals for purposes of interrupting prescription.

This is especially significant in cases involving old assessments. If the BIR has already made an assessment final and executory, and several years pass before the case reaches court, the taxpayer should examine whether the government’s criminal remedy has prescribed. Conversely, taxpayers should not assume that prescription automatically applies merely because the taxable year is old. The correct analysis depends on the date the offense was committed and the date the Information was filed.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, business owners, corporate officers, and importers in handling tax assessments, BIR collection actions, criminal tax investigations, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review assessment timelines, evaluate prescription defenses, prepare protests and pleadings, and represent clients in disputes involving deficiency VAT, income tax, withholding tax, excise tax, customs issues, and alleged violations of the Tax Code.

If you or your company is facing a BIR assessment, a DOJ preliminary investigation, or a criminal tax case before the Court of Tax Appeals, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on your tax litigation and CTA defense options.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *